
Vacation rentals in Fairy Island
Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb
Top-rated vacation rentals in Fairy Island
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

YurtSimple
YurtSimple is where life slows down and people unplug. It’s forest bathing in nature. It’s getting away from it all to spend time with a partner, by oneself, and sometimes with pets. You’ll be driving past YurtCation (about 300 feet past YurtCation) to get to YurtSimple. YurtCation is 20’ in diameter and YurtSimple is 16’ in diameter. Wood and charcoal are provided. You may cook on the indoor wood stove top, or visit any number of great restaurants 2 miles away. You can even order pizza delivery

Stay With Horses Escape Near Madison
Get ready for a quiet and peaceful stay. Take your pick: - 1King+1Queen Bed & 1 bath for 4 people - 1King+2Queen Beds & 2 baths for 6. (+$125 per night, contact host for payment) This home is attached to a barn with 6 Icelandic horses! Wake up to Icelandic horses just outside your window. A scenic escape with quiet mornings, fuzzy horses, and a one-of-a-kind IamGlytja experience - only 25 minutes from Madison - No horse riding allowed, owners to supervise all horse visits - No smoking / parties

Lake Lovers Hideaway near Lake Geneva
Perfect getaway with all the camping and lake amenities. Enjoy the sights and sounds of the Kettle Moraine with a clean and spacious hot tub, fire pit, propane grill, and activities to keep you busy. Even better, Lauderdale Lake access is less than a mile away with a pier for fishing, kayak for exploring, or bring your own boat for more lake fun! With parking space enough for two cars and a boat, day boat slip access, and Wisconsin favorites ready for you on arrival, you won't be disappointed!

Pet-Friendly Industrial 2 Bedroom Near UWW Campus!
This newly renovated two bedroom unit is conveniently located near UWW, Starin Park, and the Kettle Moraine! We are pet friendly! We are within walking distance to sports fields and UWW. Explore all that Whitewater has to offer with our personalized guidebook! Hike the Kettle Moraine, enjoy many local dining options and events, or shop your heart out. We are local hosts and strive to provide a five star experience! If your group is larger than 4, we have two other units in the same building.

Exquisite Modern A-frame all WithInnReach
An amazing space that truly caters to the guest experience. We've built this art piece to have our guests immerse themselves in all the amenities, from heated floors to in-ceiling speakers - all whilst losing yourself in the wood burning fireplace. At WithInnReach the attention to detail was paramount - with an emphasis of what we enjoy...amazing food through a well balanced kitchen, beautiful sound through Klipsch speakers and relaxation with floor to ceiling showers...enjoy to the fullest.

House on 5 acres - Walk to Alpine Valley
Valley Oasis is a private 3 bedroom 2 bath home located on 5 acres next to the entrance of Alpine Valley Resort. Far enough off the road to enjoy the quiet beauty of nature. Woods located behind the house and a field next to it. Enjoy the outdoors on the deck, have dinner in the screened in porch, enjoy a fire in the fire pit, or warm up by the fireplace. You will have access to the entire house and immediate yard. The garage is not accessible. No smoking in the home. No parties allowed.

Charming Lake Geneva, Wisconsin 3BR/2Bath Home
Step into the comfort of this sun-soaked 3BR 2Bath home in a tranquil area in Lake Geneva, WI. This relaxing retreat with a picturesque private pond is immersed in a breathtaking natural ambiance offering a perfect escape from the big city crowds. The stylish design and rich amenity list will leave you in awe. ✔ 3 Comfortable Bedrooms ✔ 2 Living Areas ✔ Sunroom ✔ Fully Equipped Kitchen ✔ Patio with a grill ✔ Pond Access ✔ High-Speed Wi-Fi ✔ Smart TVs ✔ Board Games/ Learn more below!

TheGlassCabin @ HackmatackRetreat
The Pond House, a vintage glass cabin filled with art, water views & eclectic vibes privately perched on the sacred grounds of Hackmatack Retreat Center. Native prairie, a winding slow river, two ponds, 200+ year old oaks & big sky- Countless places to curl up, gathering, focus-- nooks and crannies indoors and out, we offer “time out for time in” amidst this noisy world. Minutes from 2 small towns, all amenities, we're all about peace & ease-- let us custom curate your experience !

Mariner Hills Chalet
Escape to this cozy 3-bedroom cabin tucked away in Elkhorn, Wisconsin. Surrounded by peaceful wooded scenery, this charming retreat offers the perfect mix of comfort and adventure. Enjoy coffee on the front deck or screened 3-seasons porch, grill on the back deck, and gather around the firepit at night. With fast WiFi, Smart TVs, pet-friendly stays, and nearby lakes, trails, Alpine Valley, and Lake Geneva, it’s the perfect getaway for families, friends, or couples.

Charming Elkhorn Cottage - Romantic Getaway
At Mysa, (Swedish for cozy) , we aim to create a space that encompasses slowing down, coziness, comfort, and enjoying the simple pleasures with friends and loved ones. Our modern minimalist design is inspired from nature, using clean lines, and natural light, resulting in simplicity, elegance, and tranquility. This stylish, yet comfortable, recently renovated cottage is the perfect atmosphere to take a break from stress and experience connection and togetherness.

Glamping Cabin on Cold SpringTree Farm
Unfortunately we can't accommodate same day bookings as we don't have enough lead time to prep the cabin for your stay. Glamping on a working Christmas tree farm. Beautiful single room stone cabin with loft and wood burning stove. Two small beds in loft and futon on main floor folds out into full bed. Lots of room around to pitch tents as well. Situated on 40 acres of land with a pond, barn with basketball court, creek and Christmas tree fields.

2 Bed - Anchor Cabin, Steps to Lake Como, Fire Pit
Welcome to Anchor Cabin, one half of Anchor & Oak — a boutique two-cabin retreat just steps from Lake Como and minutes from the heart of downtown Lake Geneva. This airy, coastal-inspired space features calming colors, breezy textures, and cozy touches designed for the ultimate lakeside reset. Whether you're sipping coffee in the morning sun or relaxing under porch string lights, Anchor cabin is your peaceful escape.
Popular amenities for Fairy Island vacation rentals
Other great vacation rentals in Fairy Island

Fully Renovated | 15 Min to Lake Geneva

Spacious Home Near Lake Geneva - Heated Pool

Long Lake Retreat - Cottage in Burlington, WI

Lake shore cottage on beautiful Rock Lake

The Elmwood- East Troy Village

Forest getaway; Alpacas, fire pit, trail access!

Luxury Wine Barrel Stay at Hidden Creek Estates

The Log Cabin on Back Rd
Destinations to explore
- Chicago Vacation rentals
- Indianapolis Vacation rentals
- Detroit Vacation rentals
- Minneapolis Vacation rentals
- Milwaukee Vacation rentals
- Traverse City Vacation rentals
- Des Moines Vacation rentals
- Saint Paul Vacation rentals
- Downtown Chicago Vacation rentals
- Ann Arbor Vacation rentals
- Windsor Vacation rentals
- Grand Rapids Vacation rentals
- Naval Station Great Lakes
- Six Flags Great America
- Alpine Valley Resort
- Wilmot Mountain Ski Resort
- Illinois Beach State Park
- Baird Center
- Lake Kegonsa State Park
- American Family Field
- Milwaukee County Zoo
- Milwaukee Public Museum
- Riverside Theater
- Marquette University
- Bradford Beach
- Discovery World
- Pabst Mansion
- Fiserv Forum
- Lake Geneva Public Library
- Gurnee Mills
- Mitchell Park Horticultural Conservatory
- Holy Hill National Shrine of Mary
- South Shore Park
- Lake Geneva Cruise Line
- Betty Brinn Children's Museum
- Atwater Park





