Lake house vacation rentals in Crooked Lake

If you’re looking for a place for the whole group to stay together and have some fun - look no further! The house itself was better in-person than the photos and was spotless. The beds were very comfortable and the main level is a great hang out area for everyone. We had so much fun in the game garage and honestly didn’t want to leave. It’s close to proximity to everything, including a great relaxed restaurant on the water next door. Jeremy and Houston were very responsive and couldn’t have asked for a better stay. Can’t wait to book another trip soon!

We enjoyed our stay at the Firefly Cottage. Everything was perfect and the view of the lake is beautiful. We hope to stay next year for our granddaughter’s birthday.

What a wonderful home. I could not have asked for a more peaceful, beautiful stay. Waking up and seeing the frozen lake outside was such a nice experience. Will definitely be back!

We enjoyed out stay! The location worked perfect for visiting with friends on the Lake. Would stay here again.

This place was absolutely fantastic! Needed a quick get away and this could not have been a more perfect spot. The bonus was meeting the incredible folks that make up the neighborhood. Welcoming is an understatement! There is no other place I would rather stay! I have a feeling my little quick get away will become tradition! Welcoming, friendly…. Perfect!!!

We all enjoyed the spaciousness of the house, the number of bedrooms and bathrooms so we had our privacy yet room to work and eat together. The lake view was beautiful in spite of the wind and rain!

Beautiful location on the lake! We brought our kayaks and inflatable paddle board - our teen boys enjoyed themselves. If we get the opportunity to visit again, we will look into renting a pontoon boat!

The home was absolutely perfect for our annual girls trip. Fully equipped with everything you could possibly think of. The large table for meals and games has the best views. Sunsets from the fire pit, the beach or the house are beautiful. We will definitely be back!

Had a girl’s weekend and there was plenty of space for everyone to sleep. Decor was stylish, plenty of seating arrangements, and plenty of outdoor activities. Beautiful house, great scenery, and owner was great communicator!

We enjoyed our time at the lake. Amazing and serene home. So wonderful to have my dogs with me and they loved the yard. Anna is helpful and responsive. Looking forward to our next visit this summer and fall.

Beautiful space for a large family gathering. The house is lovely and the big windows overlooking the lake were fantastic. Beware, if you claim the master bedroom, the en suite shower is so awesome, everyone will be trekking in to use the six nozzle shower :-) Joe was great to communicate with. We highly recommend this place!

Great place for our wedding! We rented all 4 cabins for the full family.

We had a large gathering of family and friends. The accommodations were wonderful. The kitchen had dishes and utensils. The washer and dryer worked well. Both bathrooms were clean, the water hot and good water pressure. The hot tub was amazing and the view of the lake was wonderful. The host was readily responsive to questions and made check-out easy.

Another wonderful stay at The Lake House. Erica and Josh were wonderful! Great communicators! Location is quiet and peaceful! We will definitely be back! 🩷

We traveled downstate for a wrestling tournament for our 2 sons. We wanted a place to relax and away from the city for our time off of wrestling. This place was perfect! It was so peaceful being right on the lake and had such a beautiful view from the back patio. Although it's March in Michigan, we were still able to enioy the outdoor amenities. The sun was shining and we took advantage of it. We went kayaking, played corn hole and played the axe game. The house was stocked with lots of board games and everything we needed in the kitchen. We'd definitely recommend this house to others. Plus, Jim was so easy to talk to and very informative and helpful!

Can’t say enough about Jake’s place. It was heaven. Beautiful sunsets on the lake. Awesome fishing. Comfortable beds. Clean. The back porch is huge and awesome. The backyard is an outdoor paradise. Our kids used the beach, the kayaks, the pier, the paddle boat, the pontoon. No complaints. Owners are the most gracious hosts and beautiful family. Thank you Jake for sharing your little slice of heaven with us. We will return ASAP.

We had such a wonderful stay! A few college friends got together for a long weekend getaway to antique shop in Nappanee and North Webster and this was the perfect spot. We all agreed we’ll need to come back when it’s warmer so we can enjoy the lake and kayak!

This Lakes James retreat is just as promised. It is bright, clean, has everything you need to feel right at home, and the view of the lake is spectacular. Due to the timing of our stay, we weren't able to use the lake front cabin, but it would be perfect for a summer visit. Travis is extremely responsive to questions. We highly recommend this location to others.

So glad I stumbled upon Steph's Ice House listing. Had a peaceful, almost secluded stay yet close to the many Shipshewana attractions. Impeccably clean and decorated, with modern amenities which would be fantastic for an extended stay. Steph sent a greeting message immediately after my booking and followed up with detailed instructions and area tips. Was pleasantly surprised with doughnuts and popcorn when I arrived, a very nice touch. Looking forward to booking with her again!

My stay was nothing but amazing! My host were so amazing! They were very accommodating, communicative, and informative from the beginning to the end of my trip. Their home is so beautiful. Very clean, very spacious, nicely decorated, great views from the inside and outdoors could be no better. Kitchen was equipped with everything you could think of to prepare a nice meal. Waking up to a nice sunrise on the lake was such an experience. Large deck with great views. Grill and Firepit is available along with paddle boat etc. I also loved how they had a guestbook available with everything you should know such as house expectations to local attractions etc. I would recommend to my co workers, family, and friends to have such an experience. I am very grateful for my weekend anniversary get away!

Awesome host and home

I would recommend this space and I would stay here again myself! Leslie was so accommodating and responsive when I had any questions. It was a safe place, had everything we needed, and was overall a nice place to stay - very good distance to everything.

The house was spotless, and the kitchen was well stocked with everything possibly needed to cook or prepare meals. The neighborhood was quiet and peaceful, and we enjoyed relaxing on the back porch and listening to nothing but birds singing. The bed we used was comfortable, and the shower in the master bathroom was beautiful and very well constructed. We had a very nice, relaxing stay.

This home was Absolutely Amazing. Very peaceful, and was great for our family gathering. Local Butcher Shop was outstanding and everything we needed was conveniently located. Ashley was an exceptional host by providing clear instructions and information needed. Highly Recommend.