Waterfront vacation rentals in Central Eleuthera

Comfortable stay. Convenient location. Highly recommend.

Always a pleasure staying here

Very nice room with an amazing view.

Our stay with Carolyn was incredibly special. The room was perfect: very clean, comfortable bed, nicely upgraded, cute design touches, a tranquil shared porch, and a thoughtful assortment of snacks. And don’t get me started on the location, right across the street from the beach and stunningly blue water. We also loved the surrounding neighborhood! When we realized that we wouldn’t be as easy as expected to get our next stay in Governor’s Harbor, Carolyn quickly and graciously offered us a ride. Such a thoughtful gesture and we had a lovely drive with her & her fiancé - they didn’t want to take any money for the ride, which alone speaks to their overall kindness & character, but we wouldn’t take no for an answer. One of the best stays of our lives, and we will be returning, no doubt about it. YOU SHOULD STAY HERE TOO!! Beyond grateful for our stay and the warmth, generosity, and genuine kindness we felt from each person we encountered, especially Carolyn. Thank you so much!!!!

Joy and Dom's air bnb suited our needs well. We did not need to be directly on a beach and we had beautiful sea view from our lower unit. Since we had a car rental, (which most will need anyway) we could drive to any beach we wanted to explore. Communication was always quick and I really appreciated Joy sending us in detail well in advance of our stay directions to our airbnb, car rentals, things to do, restaurants, etc. Dom also met us on arrival to go over any questions and helpful tips of the area. This property was in a nice a quiet neighborhood and still quiet even being the lower unit. We will definitely stay here again.

Absolutely stunning location……the home sits on acres of beautifully landscaped grounds and a clean seemingly private beach. We saw only a handful of friendly neighbors (residents) each day. It was windy so the surf was rough but we found times when it was calm enough to snorkel on the reefs right off the beach. We did bring wetsuits just in case and that helped but we also swam in bathing suits, especially the kids. If it was windy at our beach, we could take a 5 min drive to Ten Bay Beach (and other spots) on the opposite side of the island where it was protected from the winds and the water was clear and flat calm. The house was extremely clean; furniture felt new; kitchen well equipped. The BBQ was a bit rough and no gas so we didn’t use. The downstairs bedroom/bath were furnished beautifully and worked out well but it had a slight smell of paint; didn’t bother the kids. Double Bay and this beautiful home made for a dream vacation and we highly recommend Wish House!

Gumbo Limbo was great for our family of 5 (kids 14, 13 and 12). The house was really nice and new and the location was beautiful and private. The beach across the street is gorgeous and almost entirely empty the whole time we were there. We also spent a lot of time at the pool, which was great. The kitchen was really well stocked for cooking. Eleuthera is amazing and worth the trip, and Gumbo Limbo is a great place to stay.

I could not have asked for a better place to stay in!! This was perfect for our little family with our 10 month old baby. The view was spectacular and it was so convenient walking down to the beach everyday with our girl! The kayaks supplied were so fun! My husband and I took turns while we watched the baby on the shore. Such a great location too! Felt super safe! Next to great restaurants (Tippy’s and La Bounganvillea). Hewitt the property manager on site was so sweet. And dealing with Pam was amazing. Her communication was impeccable and she was so patient with us and All our questions. The house itself was beautiful and so comfortable. Book it! You won’t find a better place or property management team!!!!

My wife and I enjoyed our stay at Poponi. The cottage was comfortable and we especially enjoyed the patio and kitchen. The surrounding landscaping is beautiful and it's a short walk to a very nice and private stretch of beach. The owners were pleasant and very responsive when we had a question.

We stayed here while attending a wedding at Coco di Mama and loved it. It was the perfect week long getaway! Private and beautiful. We felt right at home and loved the easy walk to the shops. When comparing to where our friends and wedding guests stayed there is no question we made the best choice. We highly recommend this place, loved it, and hope to stay again soon.