Vacation rentals with lake access in Cattaraugus County

Find and book unique lake access rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated lake access rentals in Cattaraugus County

Guests agree: these lake access rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A canoe glides across a calm pond, framed by trees showcasing autumn foliage. Two people paddle gently, surrounded by vibrant reflections of fall colors on the water's surface. A clear blue sky enhances the serene atmosphere, inviting exploration of the tranquil landscape.
Home in Randolph
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 237 reviews

Quiet Convenience

Quiet Convenience 1 mile from I-86 Enjoy the secluded comfort of this rustic retreat close to many area attractions. Nestled in the woods overlooking a large pond with nature at every turn. Enjoy a campfire, fishing, bird watching, snowmobile trails, and skiing. Close to the Amish Trail, and Chautauqua Lake, Allegheny State Park, National Comedy Center, Lucille Ball Museum, Chautauqua Institution, and more! We welcome Sewing/Quilting Retreats, Faith Based Retreats, etc. Come for a visit!

Guest favorite
Ranch in Cattaraugus
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 95 reviews

Peaceful Ranch Stay: Family Fun&Fall Foliage Views

Escape into nature, perfect for family getaways or solo retreats, this unique barn apartment offers a quiet hideaway. Set on 110 scenic acres of forest and pasture, an ideal spot for hiking, exploring & reconnecting with nature. The property invites you to slow down unwind & take in the beauty of your surroundings. Fish, kayak or swim in private onsite pond and creek. Conveniently located: 12 Miles from Ellicottville 45 mins to Buffalo 1 hour & 15 min to Niagara Falls Accommodates 1–5 guests

Top guest favorite
A vibrant streetscape features colorful storefronts and flower-filled planters. A cafe sign hangs prominently, with small tables arranged outside. Pedestrians stroll along the pathway, complemented by the presence of flags and shop signs, creating a lively atmosphere in the village.
Home in Ellicottville
5 out of 5 average rating, 77 reviews

Best Village Location/Firepit/Bar/Games/Yard/etc

Location, location, location! Village center, 1 mile to skiing. Voted top 10 Main St in the US by USA today. Spacious, clean, newly renovated home close to everything. Walk 100 feet to shops, restaurants, breweries, winery, cafe’s, etc! Great location for bachelor(ette) gatherings. Enjoy the outdoor movie projector, firepit, grill, corn hole and large back yard and deck. Inside, enjoy 9' shuffleboard, photo wall, fireplace, turntable/albums, games, books+bar area. Keypad for easy check-in! 😊

Guest favorite
The living room features a comfortable blue sofa with decorative pillows, a wooden coffee table, and a gas fireplace. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, with a view of the outdoors. A flat-screen TV is mounted on the wall across from the seating area.
Townhouse in Ellicottville
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews

★ SKIING, HIKING, VILLAGE OF EVILLE MTN ESCAPE ★

Snugly nestled at the foot of the Ellicottville mountains, this Wildflower townhome provides easy access to skiing (across the street from Holiday Valley), hiking, fishing, golf and a whole host of nature activities. With the village of Ellicottville only a 15-20 minute walk (or very short drive) away, the nearby comforts of civilization include plentiful shops, restaurants and other attractions. You can't beat this location if you are looking for a relaxing retreat from the hustle and bustle.

Guest favorite
A welcoming living area features large windows allowing natural light and offering views of the outdoors. A stone fireplace adds warmth, while comfortable sofas are arranged around a patterned area rug. A wall-mounted TV is positioned above the fireplace.
Townhouse in Ellicottville
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Slope Views & Close to Downtown E-Ville

You are right across the street from Holiday Valley to enjoy the main lodge and best slopes. Take a short walk or use the free shuttle. Then come back to warm up in front of the fireplace, use the fully stocked kitchen, and enjoy the slope views from our spacious deck. Full access to ski locker included. You are also less than a mile away from downtown Ellicottville, where you can shop or dine at the best local places all day & night. Free parking, pack n play, wifi, & netflix included.

A charming wooden structure with a shingled roof overlooks a serene pond, reflecting the vibrant autumn foliage of the surrounding hills. A traditional American flag flaps gently in the breeze, while a spacious, multi-level property is visible in the background, set against a clear blue sky.
Farm stay in Ellicottville
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Cozy Maples Retreat for Family & Freinds - HotTub

Discover The Maples, a 5-bedroom Ellicottville treasure sprawled across 8 breathtaking acres of countryside. Perfect for groups of 16+, this haven boasts stunning views, a massive yard for fun, and all the comforts for an epic getaway. Gather in the spacious living areas, cook in a full kitchen, or roam the scenic grounds—your adventure starts here. With 5 bedrooms, High-speed Wi-Fi, smart TVs, parking, and self-check-in. Ask us how to create unforgettable memories in this countryside escape!

Guest favorite
A charming log cabin features a welcoming front porch with decorative flowers and a wooden railing. Large windows are framed by shutters, and string lights create a cozy atmosphere. The lawn is well-maintained, with an inviting pathway leading to the entrance.
Home in Machias
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Little Log Cabin on the Lake!

Relax, vacation and make memories on picturesque Lime Lake in Machias NY. This sunny, cozy home is perfect for people who'd like some solitude while watching the spectacular sunsets on the lake! This fully furnished, waterfront cottage includes a glassed-in sunroom to enjoy your morning coffee as the sun rises. Enjoy boating, swimming and fishing. Boat dock, rowboat, gas grill and firepit included for your enjoyment. A 20-minute drive to Ellicottville where you can enjoy shopping and dinner.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a charming home is observed, featuring a covered front porch with wooden posts. Lush landscaping surrounds the property, including vibrant shrubs and trees. A gravel path leads to the entrance, while rolling hills and blue skies fill the background.
Home in Hinsdale
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Privacy sleep 6 250 acres pond

Everyday price of $120 but with mandatory 6 night stay -10% discount to$108 Long term rental of month or more 30% discount. Three bedroom 2 bath, fully stocked kitchen, everything you need for a private country getaway. 250 acres Trails to hike, adjacent pond to fish. Beautiful large screened porch with colorful seating, Webber grill, table and chairs for dining alfresco! Fire pit with Mountain View 10 min Olean or Bonaventure 20 min Ellicottville . Great vistas, quiet, nature, relax!!

Guest favorite
A spacious villa is nestled within a winter landscape, surrounded by snow-covered grounds and evergreen trees. The stone exterior features multiple colorful doors and windows, and a clear pathway leads to the entrance, while a winding driveway provides access from the road.
Home in Ellicottville
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Ashford Villa near Ellicottville

Privacy & Grandeur awaits you at this 4,000 sq. ft. Villa located on a 10 acre estate close to Ellicottville (12 min) & Holiday Valley (15 min). It sleeps 14 (16 with air mattress): 1 king, 3 queen, 2 single & two bunk bed sets & 2 Pack n Plays. Also, four full bathrooms ensures there is no wait! Finally, a 2 car garage and a huge basement. It is a great meeting place for big groups such as family gatherings, re-union of friends, etc. Make memories with the people you cherish most!

Top guest favorite
An aerial view showcases a spacious cabin adjacent to a large, calm pond surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage. The lush greenery of pine trees complements the colorful leaves, while a gravel driveway leads to the cabin and outbuilding, enhancing the serene country setting.
Home in West Valley
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

5BR cabin on a private lake with 8 acres & hot tub

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space, 10 mins from the heart of Ellicotville, NY. Ideal in the winter to the slopes, or in fall and summer for golf and mountain biking, or just to hang out on the dock. Our cabin has it all: a bunk room for up to 4 kids, 4 queen bedrooms that sleep up to 8 adults and swimmable private waterfront with 6 person hot tub. Ideal location for a getaway with family or friends, with an open-concept kitchen, large private bedrooms & 8 acres to roam.

Superhost
Cabin in Machias
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Cozy Cabin near Lime Lake

Experience a full day of skiing at the local slopes or enjoy riding your snowmobiles, then unwind in our log cabin featuring 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths! This warm and comfortable cabin is perched atop a hill, offering stunning views of Lime Lake. Just steps away from the lake and minutes from various local amenities! -Ideal for a family getaway or a couples retreat. - Keyless keypad for quick and easy self-check-in - ROKU smart TVs - Relax on the spacious deck overlooking Lime Lake

Guest favorite
A gravel driveway leads up to a garage apartment situated behind a two-story house. Flower beds with vibrant plants line the path, while a lush green lawn extends on either side. Tall trees provide a natural backdrop, completing the serene outdoor setting.
Apartment in Machias
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

Lime Lake 3 bedroom getaway

Lovely 3 bedroom garage apartment. Just a 5 minute walk down the road, you will find Lime Lake, and the Odosagih Bible Conference. We are only a short 20 minute drive from Ellicottville, a charming year round resort town, home to Holiday Valley & Holimont. If snowmobiling, hiking or mountain biking are what you are after, NY State Lands, Finger Lakes Trail, Sculpture Park, Letchworth & Allegany State Parks are nearby. Experience a classic, the Delevan Drive-in is just 5 miles away.

Popular amenities for Cattaraugus County lake access rentals