Family-friendly vacation rentals in Baiting Hollow

This is the 2nd Thanksgiving weekend we spent at Deeanna's. Her home is beautiful, comfortable and each detail is thought though in the best way. Deeanna went above and beyond to accommodate my family and we are so grateful to her. The kitchen is perfection and the bedrooms are lovely and comfortable. The scenery and views are breathtaking. Overall, this home is a total gem. Thank you, Deeanna! We hope to come back next year!

This getaway was very last minute and there was huge importance on it because I needed some time away and because I had never booked an Airbnb before. I wanted to make sure that my family and I were able to be someplace peaceful and have a really good time and Brian’s home provided just that. The stay was so much more than we expected and Brian was absolutely amazing. He’s super responsive and accommodating. Hoping to stay here again in the near future!

Fantastic stay/fantastic hosts! My adult children and I spent a great weekend hosted by David and Abby. Their place was perfect for us and very comfortable. David reached out and described check in and proactively answered any questions we would have had. We were there in cold weather but I will earmark it for a warm weather stay as it has so many appealing summer amenities! We will stay again for sure.

Six of us flew in from all over the world to have a friend reunion here since it was the most convenient location for us all to meet up. The house was great for this occasion in that it is cozy, and conveniently located. Our favorite spot in the house was the sunroom with the wood burning stove since the weather was mostly gray and on the chilly side. The kitchen was the next most popular spot and was well equipped, better than most places actually. David and Claire provided clear check in and checkout guidance and were proactive in their communication with us. Thank you!

Had an absolutely wonderful stay! Location is perfect and Jaime was incredibly friendly throughout!! He let me know that they had everything we would need.. but as a self-described obsessive packer I didnt listen. He wasn't kiding! They had beach chairs, umbrellas, and everything else you need for the perfect beach day. I brought an entire wagon of stuff and used one bag. It really is an awesome little find!!

We had a wonderful stay at Jennifer’s place. It was.l beautiful, immaculate, and incredibly well equipped—especially for kids with the plethora of games and toys. Jennifer was responsive and a great host. The house is on a serene, dead-end street, and outdoor area is perfect for kids.

Great getaway for our family of four. Many things to do both on sunny days enjoying the yard to play sports with the kids and also rainy days with plenty of games, shuffleboard, the hot tub and theatre downstairs which our eldest loved to watch movies. Josh was always very responsive and everything was very smooth

We loved our stay at Chandra’s place, it was peaceful, super comfy and was close to everything we needed. It was great to enjoy a few runs locally and come back to the private garden and hot tub in the evening. The property was beautiful and well stocked with towels, soft bedding and kitchen equipment. I’d love to come back again in the future

Been here twice. It’s becoming a lovely family tradition! The kids loved being able to see the animals everyday :) The only downside is one of the beds is bit soft - my husband has a sensitive back and said it bothered him.

We absolutely loved our quick getaway from the city at Kate’s lovely home. It is hard to articulate in words just how beautiful of a home and location this was. It was truly magical. We were very comfortable as a family traveling with young children. Despite the weather being a bit chilly, we had a wonderful time soaking the views and discovering “treasures” by the water. We cannot wait to come back again soon.

The place is wonderful, had a great cozy stay, the beds are comfortable. Would recommend if you’re looking for a place that’s close by all the restaurants and attractions.

Ed was great at communicating, house was everything we could have asked for. Would definitely book again!

This home is beautiful and so spacious! Proximity to East Hampton and Springs, yet very private and peaceful. Couldn’t recommend enough!

We had a wonderful stay at George’s. The unit is exactly as described, don’t be deterred by the adherence to the house, it’s completely private. It’s at a great location for north fork explorations and the amount of towels was outstanding!

This was a great find! I booked this Airbnb for myself and 4 other girls and there was plenty of room and space for us to hangout, sleep, and get ready. Walkable to town. Extremely clean and had all the amenities you would need for a short weekend getaway. Marianne and Steven were very responsive whenever I had a question. I would totally book this Airbnb again!

We enjoyed our stay! Such easy access to the beach was so convenient. You’re definitely better off venturing out after high tide to enjoy the most amount of beach and there are a lot of shells that make being barefoot challenging. We did arrive after major storms which could have contributed to that. The house was spotless with everything you need to be comfortable! We did not utilize the outdoor space but definitely would have if the weather was drier! Definitely would stay here again.

Great spot, would definitely stay again.

We had a wonderful stay. Cute and comfortable house in an amazing location. Very comfortable for a family of 4.

Gaby’s place was clean and comfortable! She is very kind and it was exactly what we needed for the week. Her check in instructions and directions were thorough and the home is in a beautiful area. Already have our next stay booked :)

Michael was a great host, friendly, flexible and helpful. The house is beautiful and has all the amenities you would expect. We loved staying there and would definitely like to stay again.

Loved the place! Clean and comfortable. Had everything we needed. Perfect location near family for the Thanksgiving holiday. The main street w/ restaurants & shops was just 10 min away. Robert and Chris were very responsive and provided detailed instructions and many recs for the village. Very kind! 10/10

The house is beautiful, looks like photos. Stephen is a great host! Overall great stay, could not recommend more!

We had an amazing time at Marybeth’s suite—it truly felt like a winter wonderland. Our kids had a blast "swimming" in the snow and "rolling" over the gentle hills. Every moment was filled with joy, whether we were relaxing in the sunroom, playing in the snow, or swinging outside. The time spent together as a family, along with our conversations with Marybeth and her family, was truly precious. We can’t wait to return in the summer!

We loved our stay here. The house was sparkling clean and the yard was big and beautiful. Can only imagine the vibes here during the summertime when the pool is open!