Vacation rentals with lake access in West Milford

10/10, best rental! The house felt like a hotel - it was immaculately clean with beautiful decor and in an ideal location. They put a lot of thought into it, there were so many little things we weren't expecting from an Airbnb that made this one top notch. We appreciated the fluffy clean towels and toiletries they provided. They had a whole section of baby items stored neatly in the garage and we used the baby monitor to keep an eye on the kiddos during the night. We really enjoyed the kayaks with life jackets in adult and kid sizes. They even thought to provide things like waterproof cell phone cases to take on the kayaks! They also had a small cooler, tons of beach chairs and lawn games. The location of the house is great, there's a little beach around the corner and 1 min drive into a part of town with some nice restaurants. We took a recommendation from the house's Insta-page and went on an easy hike on the boardwalk section of the Appalachian trail! It was a great time!

It was so peaceful out there no complaints we love it I would definitely love to have a little bit more time with the house everything we needed was there it was the best

My family and I really enjoyed Elizabeth property very comfortable and quiet, we definitely thinking about coming back soon.

Everything was perfect ! My family and I had a great time. Looking forward to staying here again in the summer.

House was amazing. Plenty of space for activities and had more than enough room for all of us to sleep.

We had a wonderful time staying at Amanda’s lake house, so much so that we extended our trip. It the perfect cozy, warm cabin that we were hoping for. It was so nice sitting by the lake and watching the day go by

We had a great time, very cute house. We enjoyed the creek and lake view. We loved spending time by the fire pit. We even got to see a fox a few of the nights there. Really was very relaxing and would recommend.

Had a great weekend with our 3 kids for a wedding at Woodloch pines. The house was spotless, Christine was very helpful and it actually seemed larger than the photos. The lofted space is perfect for kids. Thank you, Christine !

Alice is a great host, and her place was absolutely what we were looking for. Beautiful views of the lake, that presented us with an exquisite sunset. The place was cozy, clean, very peaceful, and it met all of our expectations. We look forward to returning during a different time of the year.

We loved our stay at Janice’s lakehouse! The apartment was super homey — we honestly wished we had booked more than just one night. It was simple, clean, and even had some snacks waiting for us, which we really appreciated after our long drive. The patio overlooking the lake was the perfect spot to kick back, order some Doordash, and just relax. Janice was super responsive and made everything really easy. Would definitely come back!

the place is really nice and comfortable.

Thank you Bee for letting us stay at your beautiful house🙏, it was very clean, had everything we needed for our stay. We will definitely want to come back or recommend our friends and family 💕

This was just what I needed for my first trip to Mohegan Lake! Quiet neighborhood. Cozy bed. Great water pressure. I’ll definitely be booking again if I come back to this cute little town.

Fantastic experience! Kelly was very clear with instructions, check-in was an absolute breeze. Upon arrival we found the space exceptionally clean and well stocked with everything you could ever wish for. The bed was extremely comfortable and the views along the river did not disappoint. Also loved being able to have a campfire after a long day of hiking. Great place :)

We had a wonderful three-month stay here at the lake. The setting was beautiful and Elmir was a fantastic host. I especially liked watching the people enjoying the lake when it was frozen over, and the Buffleheads and other diving ducks after the ice was gone.

Johns place was perfect for a little getaway. Our dog loved it as much as we did. We walked around the lake with stunning views (especially around fall season) and the fireplace is great for doing s’mores at night. Dasha was absolutely amazing, friendly and always reachable if anything.

Stayed here with some friends for my birthday and it was wonderful. Ben is very friendly, responsive and made sure to take care of us. The views of the backyard were beautiful and peaceful. We also had lots of privacy. Will definitely be booking again in the future!

This was my husband & I's first Airbnb experience, and absolutely glad we chose this cottage for our first wedding anniversary weekend getaway! I booked the trip very last minute and the responsiveness was very quick and we were accommodated the next early morning, I was wowed by how quick it was. The instructions were very clear with check in/out, house rules, using amenities including the boat, fire pit and overall organization of all the information, loved how everything was laid out. We also got a recommendation of restaurants and experiences in the local area with description of each when we arrived in a binder. As soon as we walked in, the coffee & candy was on table with a little welcome note. WE WERE IN LOVE WITH THE PLACE! Cleanliness is 10/10 with all beds made, towels sectioned, awesome shower with sitting area, and OMG the level of spices/cooking supplies available was just perfect for making the perfect meal. This cottage by the lake was everything i was looking for!!!

Rene was very responsive and gave very clear instructions on things. Place was very neatly put together and the area is very beautiful for a getaway.

A hidden gem! This spot has a ton of character and the hosts are awesome! The lake and surrounding area is beautiful as well, with plenty to do for the outdoorsy type and cute shops and great restaurants within minutes. would highly recommend and hope to find time for a return trip!

Our stay was absolutely wonderful! The house was adorable with everything you could want for a relaxing weekend away. We loved the hot tub and fire pit! The hosts included s'mores fixings and a bottle of wine..... Which was appreciated! Thank you for a wonderful stay!

Great place to be with beautiful views of a private lake, gorgeous sunrises, cozy cottage and warm, electric fireplace a plus, full kitchen, near my family and friends, and my favorite places to hike and enjoy nature, easy access from route 84, very peaceful and tranquil and great hosts

Stayed for a long weekend with my wife and two dogs. Cottage was comfortable and clean with an amazing view of the lake with a nice patio and access to the dock which we enjoyed. Also great location just a bit over an hour from the city but within a 15 minute drive to many great hikes and close to many great food options. Tony was also very responsive and helpful with recommendarions. Highly recommend.

My family of three enjoyed two day stay at Stella 's cottage. We fed the animals, walk around the pond, cooked food, fried bonfire. The nearby historical Milford town, Grey Towers mansion, and scenic trails, waterfalls are amazing. Stella is a supper host!