Vacation rentals with a pool in Sugarloaf Key

Casa loca was Absolutely beautiful! So close to everything in the keys. Host super friendly and helpful. The house was very clean! 10/10 stay LOVED IT!

We all loved the house. Plenty of space, the outdoor patios were a daily hangout, the views were great, what's not to love. The maintenance of the house itself was excellent and it didn't feel like a "rental". Well decorated, not worn down, a bathroom for everyone, it was great. We rented a golf cart to get back and forth from town which was very easy and barely a ten minute drive. We did have a small issue with the pool while there, which apparently is very unusual. It is Key West so it took a few days to get the parts needed. However, Javier was always easy to reach and while he did eventually fix it it was his 'out of the box' thinking and communication on everything that was superbly professional. I understand he manages several properties and we would gladly stay at any of them. With an AirBNB, if something goes wrong and you're far from home all you have to rely on is the owner/manager and you are in excellent hands with Javier. A++ on customer service

I am typically not an Airbnb person, as I prefer a hotel. This home was better than any resort we could’ve stayed at. Check in was simple. The home was beautiful. The location was perfect. Our favorite part was the second space that was separate from the main house. We are a family of four (mom, dad and two kids) who were traveling with my sister. She was able to have her own space with a private bathroom and entrance and could “go home” when the craziness of two kids was enough. Both units were adequately stocked with towels and linens. The kitchens had anything you could need including coffee maker, blender, toaster, pots and pans. The pool and hot tub were incredible! So much so, that we took two full days and only left for dinner! Sean and Denise were great hosts and super responsive! We will be back.

fantastic cottage and pool with plenty of privacy, close to the water. basically 3 master suites with adjoining bathrooms, one living area and a kitchen. really big pool deck with seating and cornhole, Webber grill and outdoor dining table. (bring bug spray). we had a great time, close to key West and Bahia Honda, a great cottage!

We had a great time at Judy’s airbnb. It was super nice, clean and had really comfortable beds. The pool was right across the parking area, very clean, private and always had chairs available. Over all our stay was great and we will definitely be back.

Our stay was wonderful! Key Colony is a quiet and peaceful community. Our condo was beautifully decorated and had everything we needed for the first couple days. The sheets and towels were soft The beds were very comfortable. We really enjoyed our stay and hope to go back soon again!

This was the most perfect Airbnb for our vacation. First of all, Marathon is the perfect location if you are looking to explore multiple parts of the Keys. 1 hour to Key Largo, 1 hour to Key West. We could not have asked for a better location. The home looks just like the photos and was perfect for our family of 4 + our pup. The beds were comfortable, the living space had plenty of room for our crew, but the real show stopper was the pool. If we weren't out and about exploring the Keys, we were definitely in/by the pool! A few added bonuses: (1) K-cups for our use for that first morning. This kept us from having to worry about an emergency grocery store trip the evening of our arrival (2) pool floats available for our use (3) bikes & kayaks for everyone (4) EVERYTHING. We couldn't have asked for better - we will definitely be back!

We had a great stay. The backyard is absolutely beautiful and feels very peaceful. We were treated to four manatees as well as a nurse shark off the dock over the course of our week here! The pool and spa were great and as advertised. Heather’s home is incredibly well stocked- more than enough towels for the baths and pool and the kitchen had everything needed for cooking as well as a great dishwasher which was great for vacation. Although we did have some issues with the property after check-in, the property host, Katie, was immediately available and very responsive to our concerns, and we were more than happy with the outcome. Would stay here again.

We had a great time! Awesome community with walkable restaurants and bars. We loved the local beaches. The people at the complex were super nice. Our four boys loved running from the pool to the beach. Everyone we met was very nice. Great instructions and recommendations. Loved it!

We had a great time at Julia's place! The condo was beautifully furnished and we enjoyed pool and private beach area. We love to walk and the location was perfect for us! The nearby deli and restaurants were also very good. Ubers are very quick and reasonable.

This place was great for an in between Miami and Key West! The pool was perfect for relaxing at all day! Restaurants near by were all fantastic! Doable drives for day trips to key west and Miami!

Carrie's place was absolutely beautiful! it was so clean, the beds were insanely comfortable, and there were tons of linens and towels for everyone. We very comfortably fit 8 people into the home with no problems. The view from the balcony is absolutely amazing and we were all blown away. Carrie was extremely responsive and friendly. We were here for our wedding and had our wedding party stay here so it was extra magical. The pool and hot tub is super close, elevator to help with our bags, and the resort itself is gorgeous. 10/10 would stay again. We loved it so so much! Don't miss out.

Stayed at Vanessa’s place twice while visiting the Keys. Quiet, clean and private. A great host and would definitely stay again next time a visit. Easy access to everything off the highway and great amenities with the pool and beach nearby. 10/10.

This was our first time in Key West. We wanted to stay a little tucked away from the downtown bustle. The complex is beautiful with great amenities. And it’s close enough to shopping, restaurants and bars! We definitely plan on booking the same place in the future!!

Eric’s place was lovely, well maintained, nicely appointed, and immaculate. The 3 of us enjoyed the balcony overlooking the pool. Even though the apartment is near the airport we only heard planes twice in the 4 days we were there. There is a convenient little grocery store on the site and excellent BBQ from a food truck near the pool. Eric responded to our questions promptly. Comfy beds, everything worked and we enjoyed our stay. Would stay here again.

My twin sister and I had such a wonderful time at Kim's home celebrating our birthday. She is super responsive and the place was exactly as described! It was so nice to sit on the patio in the morning and overlook the beautiful water. Pool is very nice and plenty to do in the property with the beach, tennis courts, BBQ, restaurant/baror just walk around in a safe, secluded environment. Condo was perfectly appointed with all the comforta and amenities of home! Can't wait to visit with Kim again! Wish I could give her 10 stars !!!!