House vacation rentals in South Eleuthera

We really enjoyed our stay at the Hibiscus House. The beautiful blue of the ocean could be seen through the trees and there was a real sense of privacy. Listening to the waves crashing during the evening while sitting on the screened in porch was incredibly relaxing. The beach was a short walk from the house and was where we spent our late afternoons after exploring the island during the day. The house had a large stash of toiletries, bug spray, sunscreen, beach gear, and a few clothes items in select closets--which was wonderful considering our luggage got lost and took days to get to us. Lydia, the house's caretaker, came by to say hello and make sure we were comfortable...and we absolutely loved learning about the island and recommendations from her local perspective. I would absolutely love to stay here again if we make it back to Eleuthera.

Everything was just as pictures or better

Our 2nd stay at Ken’s place was nothing short of fabulous! Perfectly situated, clean, & well-equipped with everything we needed, including beach chairs, a hair dryer, a few drinking waters to get you started, & a breathtaking view. The washer and dryer were a great convenience, (leave most of your clothes at home & just bring swimsuits & sunscreen). The comfy bed ensured we were well-rested for each day's adventures. We enjoyed the peace and tranquility, with great snorkeling, swimming, & fishing spots just a short walk down the hill. One of the highlights was the amazing hospitality provided by Sherrie, who was always available to help with any questions and has become a treasured friend. Claudette was also fantastic, making sure everything was clean and comfortable. We love the little community Kens place is in. Everyone is friendly & welcoming but also quiet & peaceful. We can’t wait to return for another incredible vacation Mind @Ease. Thank you for an unforgettable experience!

Heidi was very responsive and the place was very comfortable.

We loved our stay at Deborah's home. It was private and quiet with a beautiful view of the Caribbean sea and lots of stars at night. The pool was super refreshing after a day in the ocean. The bedrooms and bathrooms were comfortable and we had plenty of room for our family of 4. There were so many good tips and recommendations in the information we were sent, and everything was printed out for us at the house. The power went out briefly (it can happen, Eleuthera is remote and rugged!), and there were flashlights at the ready at the house. Its a bit hard to find things on Eleuthera, and we made several wrong turns looking for her place, but it was mostly fatigue that caused our confusion. Once we got our bearings on the island we were able to navigate quite easily. You'll definitely need a 4-wheel drive vehicle to get around the island - the caretaker he met us at the airport with a jeep. Bring your own snorkel equipment, some of stuff at the house is old and might not fit kids.

This rental has the best of it all. High end soaps, shampoos, linens, decor, even the appearance was high end. Great location from French leave beach and shops

Words cannot describe how incredibly beautiful this home is. Private but easy to get to. Having the large pool and ocean access on property was awesome. I appreciated how responsive Dina and the property manager Anne were. The kitchen is stocked full of everything you might need. Comfortable rooms and nice having multiple bathrooms. Easy to get to Ten Bay Beach with the most gorgeous water I’ve seen. Recommend Island Farms, Tippys, and The Front Porch. Didn’t want to leave and definitely will be back!

It's hard to describe Paradise, but if I had to picture what it would be like it would be Cayo Loco! The beach and the water were the prettiest I have ever seen (and I have lived in Hawaii). You can walk for miles and not see anyone. To me there is nothing better than sleeping with the windows open and having the sound of the ocean waves lull you to sleep. Plenty of great things to do and wonderful places to eat. Our host would give us updates everyday with suggestions which was so helpful! They went above and beyond to make our stay the best it could be. Other than the amazing beaches, the most memorable experiences we had were with the people of Eleuthera. The culture there is to be welcoming, kind and considerate to everyone. They truly love and respect their island and want you to feel at home there. We can't wait to return and hope to stay longer this time.

The pictures don't do justice to this home (light and beautiful) and its surroundings (paradise). There should be one of the view from the deck directly down to the ocean! :) Architecture is stunning. Full on views of the beach and tropical vegetation from every side. Two different work spaces with desks and views out the back. Kitchen is a little small if you're having a big group, but for two it was terrific. Everything worked. Fans in all the rooms! Great shower with fabulous water pressure. Loved the simplicity of the decor and having the beach to ourselves. BE SURE TO READ THE INSTRUCTIONS (and maybe print them at home). VERY useful information. Contact Latoya for practical questions. She was able to get us a rental car when other companies said they had no vehicles left. Do get a 4WD. The high chassis is important for rutted roads if you go anywhere off the beaten track. We didn't plan to, but it happens! :)

We really enjoyed our stay in Rock Sound Eleuthera. This was not our first trip to the island, but was the first time we stayed in Rock Sound. Ordinarily we stay further North but we wanted to explore Southern Eleuthera and the Cape. The home shares a parking lot with a restaurant we’ve enjoyed in the past, which we were looking forward to eating at again, but unfortunately it’s no longer in business. However, the grocery store is within walking distance and there are a couple of good restaurants and shops a little south of the home. The home itself was very clean and nicely decorated. The bedrooms were nearly identical so there was no fighting over who got the better room. With the exception of pantry items, and food storage, the house had everything we needed to enjoy our stay. They even provided beach chairs which we used every day! The best thing about the house was the sunsets. We enjoyed watching the sun set every evening on the wraparound deck. We would stay here again!

We really enjoyed our stay at Baha Mara. It was everything we had hoped for and more. The house itself is spacious and light-filled, well appointed and equipped, with lovely art and nice touches throughout. Comfortable beds and living room space, great kitchen for cooking, large porch for sitting out. We spent a lot of time relaxing on the day beds at water's edge, as well as exploring the tide line and in the water on the SUPs and with snorkels. This was our first visit to Eleuthera, and we found Baha Mara to be perfectly located to venture out to various villages, beaches, restaurants and grocery options not too far from the house. We discovered on our first day that the closest eastside beach, Islandia, is closed to the public pending a sale of the surrounding 466+ acres (!), so we explored a handful of the myriad sandy stretches up and down the coast. We only wished that we had more days to spend and that we had booked a day out on the boat with John/Big Mac Fishing. Next time!

We stayed a week. Check in was easy and precise, Walter is a friendly person who gave us lots of advice on the beaches and how to get around in general. The accommodation is spacious and comfortable. We perceived and experienced the authenticity of the place and the friendliness of the local people. Also 2 minutes walk from the beautiful beach of Tarpum Bay, we saw beautiful sunsets. It was a beautiful week. I recommend it and we will return.

My friend and I had a wonderful stay at Jim's beautiful farmhouse! Jim couldn't have been more helpful and his quick communication made navigating our trip around Eleuthera that much easier. His home is uniquely designed and I appreciated the eclectic pieces that adorn his space. I had the best sleep that I have had in a long time at his home. The area is so peaceful and the bed and pillows were so comfortable that I am now looking to purchase the same models for my own home! The back patio was such a lovely space to drink coffee in the morning. My friend and I felt that we were high up in a forest surrounded by lush vegetation sitting there in the mornings. Such an idyllic, tranquil spot. I would definitely stay at Jim's home the next time I visit Eleuthera.

The picture does not do the place justice, it is much bigger and nicer in person. Host was very communicative and accommodating, exceeded my expectations.

A HOME AWAY FROM HOME. The host Ms. Barbara is very helpful, communicative, and accommodating. The photos doesn’t give this cottage any justice! It’s super huge, clean, and well equipped with everything you may need during your stay. There is an amazing private beach steps away from the back porch. I would most definitely stay at this cottage if I was to visit southern Eleuthera again.

Great spot. Jonathan was always prompt when responding to a question both before and during our stay. Great local knowledge. Thank you!!

The pictures don't do justice to this home (light and beautiful) and its surroundings (paradise). There should be one of the view from the deck directly down to the ocean! :) Architecture is stunning. Full on views of the beach and tropical vegetation from every side. Two different work spaces with desks and views out the back. Kitchen is a little small if you're having a big group, but for two it was terrific. Everything worked. Fans in all the rooms! Great shower with fabulous water pressure. Loved the simplicity of the decor and having the beach to ourselves. BE SURE TO READ THE INSTRUCTIONS (and maybe print them at home). VERY useful information. Contact Latoya for practical questions. She was able to get us a rental car when other companies said they had no vehicles left. Do get a 4WD. The high chassis is important for rutted roads if you go anywhere off the beaten track. We didn't plan to, but it happens! :)

We really enjoyed our stay in Rock Sound Eleuthera. This was not our first trip to the island, but was the first time we stayed in Rock Sound. Ordinarily we stay further North but we wanted to explore Southern Eleuthera and the Cape. The home shares a parking lot with a restaurant we’ve enjoyed in the past, which we were looking forward to eating at again, but unfortunately it’s no longer in business. However, the grocery store is within walking distance and there are a couple of good restaurants and shops a little south of the home. The home itself was very clean and nicely decorated. The bedrooms were nearly identical so there was no fighting over who got the better room. With the exception of pantry items, and food storage, the house had everything we needed to enjoy our stay. They even provided beach chairs which we used every day! The best thing about the house was the sunsets. We enjoyed watching the sun set every evening on the wraparound deck. We would stay here again!

We really enjoyed our stay at Baha Mara. It was everything we had hoped for and more. The house itself is spacious and light-filled, well appointed and equipped, with lovely art and nice touches throughout. Comfortable beds and living room space, great kitchen for cooking, large porch for sitting out. We spent a lot of time relaxing on the day beds at water's edge, as well as exploring the tide line and in the water on the SUPs and with snorkels. This was our first visit to Eleuthera, and we found Baha Mara to be perfectly located to venture out to various villages, beaches, restaurants and grocery options not too far from the house. We discovered on our first day that the closest eastside beach, Islandia, is closed to the public pending a sale of the surrounding 466+ acres (!), so we explored a handful of the myriad sandy stretches up and down the coast. We only wished that we had more days to spend and that we had booked a day out on the boat with John/Big Mac Fishing. Next time!

We stayed a week. Check in was easy and precise, Walter is a friendly person who gave us lots of advice on the beaches and how to get around in general. The accommodation is spacious and comfortable. We perceived and experienced the authenticity of the place and the friendliness of the local people. Also 2 minutes walk from the beautiful beach of Tarpum Bay, we saw beautiful sunsets. It was a beautiful week. I recommend it and we will return.

My friend and I had a wonderful stay at Jim's beautiful farmhouse! Jim couldn't have been more helpful and his quick communication made navigating our trip around Eleuthera that much easier. His home is uniquely designed and I appreciated the eclectic pieces that adorn his space. I had the best sleep that I have had in a long time at his home. The area is so peaceful and the bed and pillows were so comfortable that I am now looking to purchase the same models for my own home! The back patio was such a lovely space to drink coffee in the morning. My friend and I felt that we were high up in a forest surrounded by lush vegetation sitting there in the mornings. Such an idyllic, tranquil spot. I would definitely stay at Jim's home the next time I visit Eleuthera.

The picture does not do the place justice, it is much bigger and nicer in person. Host was very communicative and accommodating, exceeded my expectations.

A HOME AWAY FROM HOME. The host Ms. Barbara is very helpful, communicative, and accommodating. The photos doesn’t give this cottage any justice! It’s super huge, clean, and well equipped with everything you may need during your stay. There is an amazing private beach steps away from the back porch. I would most definitely stay at this cottage if I was to visit southern Eleuthera again.

Great spot. Jonathan was always prompt when responding to a question both before and during our stay. Great local knowledge. Thank you!!