Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Shelter Island Heights

Loved Kenneth’s house. Perfect for my wife & I to get away and explore the north fork for a weekend. Great location Private house Clean Comfy Walkable to Kenneys beautiful beach sunset Drivable/uberable to key winery or Greenport locations if needed Exactly what we were looking for as a mini couples getaway Would highly recommend; likely a returning customer Kenneth was responsive and pleasant with clear instruction 5 stars!

We had a fabulous stay at this adorable cottage. It had everything we needed and more. Great spaces indoors and out to hang out, walkable to one of our favorite wineries, other wineries & restaurants close by. Appreciated having a tandem kayak to use & explore Goose Creek. Enjoyed watching birds, including Baltimore oriole parents in a nest in the backyard. Would return again. Thank you!

This home was charming and cozy. The area was super quiet and peaceful. The location was incredible. We walked everywhere and had access to everything we needed. Would definitely recommend if you want to easily explore Greenport and enjoy the local shops and restaurants.

Luigi was an excellent host, super responsive and a pleasure to interact with. The house is beautiful, super clean and well appointed. The beds were very comfortable and created the perfect sleep environment. Close walking distance to all the Greenport activities. I would absolutely stay here again and highly recommend staying here.

had an amazing time staying at Jessica's house. the place is close to everything, very convenient. Jessica is very quick to respond and flexible with check in and check out. Will definitely come back

House was perfect for our quick And easy family get away. Would certainly Stay again and recommend

Wonderful stay! George was very responsive and helped answer all our questions.

Great place to stay. We were in the area for business and this was close to our job site location. The location is perfect though - close to everything! Modern and sleek design which was really nice! Harris was also so responsive and communicative throughout the whole process which we really appreciate! Definitely recommend this property!

This was our second time here and it was a wonderful place to stay, as always. Lovely little sanctuary with very kind and friendly hosts. Can’t beat this charming home and location. It’s fantastic. Highly recommend!

Viviana’s place is in a great location, lots of room and squeaky clean. We were very comfortable and felt welcomed. She was very proactive and responsive. Would come back again!

Abby and Curran are genuinely nice hosts. Their place is ideal for people who enjoy old homes, New England, and coastal life. The suite has a comfortable queen sized bed and an arm chair and sofa, perfect for reading and reflecting. The sofa also folds out into a bed. Chickens and rabbits welcomed us home after time away exploring Milford and the surrounding area. Americana at its best.

We had two family events to attend during our stay. Erica was so helpful in getting back to me about the original availability of the apartment! It was a perfect place to relax sleep! Everything was clean and wonderful snacks! It made a great oasis to return to each day! Thanks for all of your attention to details! We appreciated Erica’s quick response during our stay! I hope we can stay there in the future! A 5 star ⭐️ review! All our best, Jen and Sean

Perfect for a weekend getaway with the pup! Place was peaceful and a short walk or drive to parks, beaches, or town. Aunt Clare was friendly and attentive. Would book again!

This is our second time staying at Jennifer’s home and we love it so much!! Jennifer’s home is beautiful, very comfortable and the decor is well done. The lawn and garden were prestine. We enjoyed sitting on the deck having a drink and sipping a cup of coffee. Our granddaughter loved the flowers and playing in the backyard. If she could she would've picked all of the beautiful flowers. Lol! This is a really extraordinary property and you couldn't ask for a better host. Jennifer is an amazing host!!

Great place , nice people , very commucative, place has everything you need , clean , and felt home , definitely will come back again for great experience

Dawn and Bob’s place is one of the top Airbnb’s we have stayed in! Top notch in every way. It was spotless, comfortable and had everything we needed. And on top of that Dawn and Bob were the most friendly hosts we have met! I would recommend this Airbnb without reservation and will be back whenever we are back in CT!

I had an amazing stay. The house was nice and very clean with everything I needed. The host was responsive and got back to me within minutes to provide me with items I needed or answer any questions I had. Overall it was peaceful and I highly recommend staying here.

Clean and cozy cabin. Close to Mystic without being right in the thick of it. We enjoyed a night by the fire with a friendly local fisherman. It worked nicely for our short trip to the area.

The location was great it’s so peaceful and calm. Paul was great he responded in a timely manner and helpful. I look forward to returning and spending more time on the marina.

Was exactly as advertised

The cabin is lovely, with a great wrap-around deck overlooking a bucolic scenery complete with a river and cascades. Jessica was always helpful and responsive and the house is comfortable with a very well equipped kitchen which is unexpected in an Airbnb. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would love to return!

We will definitely try to book at Marina Bay again. Charming and such a great alternative to urban chain hotels. Lived hearing the frogs at night and the birds chirping in the morning!

Second time staying at this cabin. Absolutely wonderful, peaceful and amazing place. Cozy and private cabin in a beautiful wooded area but super close to amenities and lots to do in the general area. Highly recommend if you’re looking to stay in Old Lyme. Thank you Keith!

We just stayed at this Airbnb for less than 12 hours but it was perfect!! We got in late, but the check in was so easy and seamless. Marina has the whole place stocked with essentials like bath products, snacks, and water bottles.