Vacation rentals in Shelley Island

My family and I had a great time at Dream on Main. Plenty of room for us and my daughter loved the playroom & fuseball table in the basement. We got to enjoy the hot tub, but not the fire pit (maybe next time). We enjoyed the snacks that were left in the kitchen for us! We used Door Dash & Instacart for groceries for the long weekend, never had an issue with the deliveries. We could hear the trucks on Main st & saw that the bedrooms had white noise machines, but we did not feel the need to use them. We cant wait to come and stay again!

My spouse and I stayed the night at the Creekside Cottage it was perfect for us the kitchen was clean and perfect open concept we kayaked, made a fire, roasted marshmallows, then went in and ended the evening with unsolved mysteries we look forward to staying again soon this is our New go to spot for our PA trips. Host was responsive house was very clean and comfortable, more than enough room for a couple or family. It was close to shopping and we had Cracker Barrel for dinner which I highly recommend.

The house was huge. Beautifull and well stocked kitchen. Outdoor was peaceful and enormous yard where we could run and play. My whole family can't wait to go back.

There are no words to describe the peace and tranquility of this home. My family, including our dog, enjoyed Mark's home and VAST property. The ladies (cows), were so playful; I didn'tknow they were such playful animals. My heart broke leaving them. I had trouble deciding where to spend my time because there were so many spots to choose from; all peaceful. If you are a lover of books; there are MANY to choose from. I always say that i won't ever go back to the same place twice but I will absolutely revisit in the future if Mark will have us again. Mark, your attention to detail was noticed and appreciated. Thank you.

The barn is beautiful. Situated on a pond, this place is perfect for families or anyone looking for breath of fresh air. The hosts were extremely communicative and went above and beyond to ensure our stay was as smooth as possible. There are many areas of the property to explore - fishing in the pond, chickens, fire pit, and hot tub. The barn itself was very clean and had everything we needed. We will be back!

This little quaint place was what me and my honey needed! It was small yet spacious and it was the cutest thing I’ve ever seen. It’s exactly how it looked in the photos. The host was responsive and super helpful, and that was very appreciated!!! If we are ever in the area again we will definitely be staying there!!

I spent a 4 day weekend to get away from busy New York with my family and it was exactly what I hoped for and more! Tiffany was such an amazing host. Very responsive and friendly. The cottage was way bigger than I expected in the inside. Very spacious and the view!! The view was absolutely stunning from the hill top!!

Very remote place we seen a lot of wildlife from the house and when we walked the trails..Dave and Barb were very helpful with everything thank you for sharing this beautiful place with us we hope to come back soon..

My friends and I had a great stay! Quiet, clean, and not far from downtown Lancaster and many other things to do in the area. Would definitely recommend.