Vacation rentals in Shelley Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Shelley Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Wrightsville

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 252 reviews

The Roundtop Chalet (romantic couples retreat)

Indulge in a getaway to our charming cabin, the perfect retreat for all your special celebrations - be it anniversaries, birthdays, or simply a much-needed escape from routine. Perfectly designed for romantic getaways, this cabin seamlessly blends rustic charm with modern comforts. Savour the warmth of a cozy fireplace, unwinding in a hot tub,and indulge with unlimited lattes, crafted by our Breville Touch Espresso Machine. Embrace serenity at its finest and make memories that will last forever

ValueLocationView

Guest favorite

The cottage exterior is illuminated by soft string lights, creating a welcoming entry. A white door with an oval window leads inside, flanked by two large windows. Two adirondack chairs are positioned nearby, with potted plants adding natural touches to the entrance.

Guesthouse in Goldsboro

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Garden Cottage Charm for 2 - Near Hbg/York/Hershey

This beautifully styled cottage is truly a sanctuary - perfect for those who enjoy travel, personal retreat, or working remotely. Located on a pleasant 1.5 acre setting only 10 mins from Harrisburg and 20 mins to Messiah College, York, and Hersheypark. You will enjoy complete privacy with plenty of space to relax and make memories. A cozy living room, full kitchen, lovely bedroom with garden view (seasonal), and bath. Central AC, fresh linens, free WiFi, and parking provided. Pet/smoke-free.

LocationFamilyAmenities

Top guest favorite

The living area features high, exposed wood beams and large windows that fill the space with natural light. A cozy white wood-burning stove is positioned near a leather sofa, complemented by a collection of firewood nearby, creating a warm and inviting setting.

Home in Columbia

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Restored Distillery | Sunroom + Outdoor Sauna

Stay at this historic c. 1755 stone house that was once an operating distillery, now reimagined with stunning design and eco-friendly geothermal power. The showstopper is the dramatic two-story sunroom with stone walls, artwork, and natural light. Enjoy a chef’s kitchen, Peloton bike, and beautifully furnished living spaces. Outdoors, relax in the BRAND NEW top-of-the-line sauna (installed Fall 2025). 15 min to Lancaster, 40 min to Hershey, and easy drives from Baltimore, Philly, DC, and NYC.

FamilyValueRiver

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Mechanicsburg

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 404 reviews

Rare Fantasy Acotar Themed Cabin Romantic Kayaks +

One of a kind fantasy cabin inspired by ACOTAR, that whispers of Prythian & the cauldrons magic. 2 cozy themed bedrooms await w/queen beds, plus a third sleeping loft reached by ladder, crowned with a king-size bed & couch/Futon in living room for lingering dreams in moonlight. Surrounded by nature yet moments from revelry & nite life. Fire pit & grill under the stars + massage table. Kayaks to glide our nearby creek. For couples, magical gatherings, families with older kids & solo retreats.

FamilyLocationParks

Top guest favorite

The exterior view of the log cabin is set amidst a lush, wooded landscape. A stone path leads to the cabin, which features a spacious outdoor deck adorned with plants and seating. The serene ambiance of the surrounding nature invites relaxation.

Place to stay in Airville

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 282 reviews

Waterfront Log Cabin with Hot Tub

Situated on the water's edge of Muddy Creek, this newly renovated log cabin offers a unique, luxury getaway for those seeking a stay immersed in all that nature has to offer. While relaxing on the spacious outdoor deck, you will be treated with a panoramic view of Muddy Creek complete with an occasional sighting of the neighborhood eagle. Perfectly set up for a romantic getaway for two, The Log Cabin on Muddy Creek was created to provide a space for couples to rest and reconnect.

ValueLocationWifi

Guest favorite

A spacious open-concept living area features modern cabinetry and a large kitchen island with seating. Warm string lights illuminate the space, highlighting the comfortable seating area and expansive windows that offer natural light. Hardwood floors add a welcoming touch.

Apartment in Harrisburg

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

Midtown's Coolest Penthouse Apt—Free Parking!

Historic Midtown Retreat: Discover the perfect blend of history and modern comfort in our spacious 2-bedroom, 2-bath apartment, located on the top floor of an old department store. Ideal for lively gatherings or cozy escapes, this unique space in Harrisburg’s trendy Midtown offers easy access to Downtown, the State Capitol, and local breweries. Enjoy free off-street parking, a fully stocked kitchen, and in-unit laundry. Explore Hershey and Harrisburg from this unique spot!

LocationFamilyAmenities

Top guest favorite

The charming stone house is bathed in warm light, highlighting its inviting windows. Lush landscaping features a gravel pathway and seating areas, with a fire pit surrounded by chairs. Soft lighting strung between trees creates a cozy ambiance in the outdoor space.

Cottage in Stevens

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Cozy Cottage •HOT TUB • FIRE PIT• Peaceful Getaway

🌾 Welcome to Your Cozy Farm Retreat A peaceful, private guest cottage located on our small, quiet farm — complete with your own private hot tub, fire pit, and beautiful views. This is the perfect escape to relax, recharge, and enjoy the countryside. Sip coffee overlooking the fields, unwind in the hot tub under the stars, or explore the local farms, breweries, and trails nearby. Perfect for couples or solo travelers seeking a quiet getaway.

FamilyValueHot tub

Guest favorite

Home in Harrisburg

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 684 reviews

Walk to Midtown From Contemporary Uptown Harrisburg Home

Beautifully remodeled, single family, brick rowhome in the "Olde Uptown" neighborhood of Harrisburg. Take advantage of the extra care and personal touches in this property such as complimentary beverages and snacks, continental breakfast items, professionally designed interior, and incredibly comfortable king sized bed. You can walk to the fantastic Broad Street Market, local coffee shop and cafe, and the beautiful riverfront trail.

ValueLocationPets

Top guest favorite

The bathroom features a claw-foot tub set against a backdrop of textured stone walls and warm wood accents. Natural light filters through a window adorned with a simple shade, illuminating the space. Decorative elements include a wall clock and plush towels arranged on the tub.

Cottage in Elizabethtown

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Private Cottage for Getaway for 2

A romantic getaway, or a time for solitude, at the stunning Liberty Spring House located at Stone Gables Estate in Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania. Cultivate a tranquil state of mind by relaxing on the private veranda overlooking Lake Liberty. Queen bed, fire place, claw foot tub, and walk-in shower will provide much relaxation in addition to the plush robes for use during your stay. Close to: Hershey, Lancaster, Harrisburg

FamilyLocationCondition

Top guest favorite

The guesthouse features a charming exterior with a combination of brick and siding. A covered porch is highlighted by rocking chairs, surrounded by landscaped gardens and stone pathways. Lush greenery and a white fence create a serene countryside setting in the background.

Guesthouse in Middletown

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Historic 1 bedroom guesthouse with parking.

Beautiful 1840's pre-Civil War country summer kitchen guesthouse situated on a private farm. Completely remodeled from floor to ceiling! Private off road parking. Within 15 minutes of all Hershey attractions and medical center. Conveniently located 3 miles from Harrisburg International Airport and short travel to various other destinations such as Spooky Nook Sports, Elizabethtown, Harrisburg, Hershey and Lancaster areas.

FamilyLocationAir conditioning

Guest favorite

The unique exterior of the Shoe House is prominently displayed, featuring a smooth, white plaster finish contrasted by gray accents. A bright yellow door serves as an inviting entrance, framed by small windows. Lush landscaping and a well-maintained yard contribute to the charm of this landmark.

Place to stay in Yorkana

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

Iconic "Shoe House" w/ Hot Tub, Firepit & Arcade!

👞 Welcome To The Haines Shoe House 👞 Featured On HGTV & The Amazing Race, Our Incredibly Unique Airbnb Is Nestled Along The Historic Lincoln Highway and Sits Beside Beautiful Pennsylvania Farm Fields! Recently Designated A Historic Landmark, We've Meticulously Designed The Shoe House For Our Guests To Feature A Wood-Burning Outdoor Firepit, Charcoal Grill, Outdoor Dining, Hot Tub, 300 Game Arcade Machine & Foosball!

FamilyValueParking

Guest favorite

Apartment in Middletown

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Circle 12B Cozy Modern & Secluded Covered Parking

Circle 12B Airbnb is situated in a quiet cul-de-sac central to Harrisburg, Lancaster, Hershey and York. The space features one bath and one bedroom with a king-sized bed, a cozy living space including a dedicated work area and a kitchenette. Guests enjoy a private rear entrance and covered parking. The unit is 5 minutes from a Target and 20 minutes from Hershey stadium/park. Fire-stick apps require your own logins.

ValueFamilyHospitality