Vacation rentals in Sheffield

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sheffield

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A serene exterior view of a renovated house with a wooden facade, surrounded by lush green grass. The spacious deck features red chairs and overlooks landscaped areas with various plants and flowers, all set against a misty, tranquil backdrop of trees.

Home in Titusville

5 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

Hotel Clarence

Completely renovated house converted to look like a vintage gas station on exterior. First floor has open living area/kitchen, with functional antique wood walk in cooler, 1/2 bath, bar and garage door which opens to deck. Many reclaimed materials used in construction including brick, doors for bar, etc. Upstairs was modeled after boutique hotel with king bed, full bath and picture window overlooking stocked pond and vintage fire truck. Garage portion not included, but could be available.

Top guest favorite

A winding pathway leads to two rustic cabins nestled among lush green trees. The inviting porch of the larger lodge features seating areas, while a smaller structure sits in the background, surrounded by well-maintained landscaping and the tranquility of nature.

Guesthouse in Bradford

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 205 reviews

Timberdoodle Lodge: Kellidoodle Cottage

Enjoy the peace and quiet and night sky of Timberdoodle Lodge at the Kellidoodle or Grammy's Cottage, surrounded by the Allegheny National Forest. It's the perfect place to unwind, relax or play (or even keep in touch or do a little work). Hiking? Over 650 miles of trails are nearby. In winter you can snowshoe or cross country ski on those trails! Fishing? Bring your waders and fishing rod for superb trout fishing on nearby Kinzua Creek, Sugar Run or Willow Creek. See more details below.

Guest favorite

A new cabin is surrounded by lush greenery, sitting directly beside a gently flowing stream. The building features a green metal roof and a welcoming front porch with steps leading to the entrance. A fire pit is positioned nearby, enhancing outdoor relaxation.

Cabin in Sheffield

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Just Beautiful - 2 bedroom camp with loft!

Brand new 2022 build on a Pennsylvania Class A and Stocked trout stream. Minutes from countless pristine streams, Chapman Dam Lake and the beautiful Kinzua Reservoir. Walk directly to public hunting lands and over 500,000 thousand acres of national forest. Allegheny national forest ATV and snowmobile trails a short drive away. North Country Trail. Mountain Biking Trails. Kayaking. Endless outdoor recreation and a beautiful place to rest and sleep at night. Covered parking for vehicles or ATVs.

Top guest favorite

A comfortable living room features a leather sofa and a light-colored couch, each accompanied by lamps on either side. A wooden coffee table with intricate detailing sits in front of a patterned rug, while framed artwork decorates the wall. Natural light is filtered through floral curtains.

Home in Ridgway

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Cozy, well appointed home in the Pennsylvania Wild

Visit Ridgway next to the Clarion River & part of the Allegheny National Forest. Enjoy kayaking, hiking, fishing, & biking trails. Our quaint small-town has many shops, restaurants, a bakery, pottery, antiques, chain saw art, & a micro-brewery. Love history? See outstanding mansions from an era when lumber & tanning were king & Ridgway had more millionaires per capita than any U.S. city. You are a short drive to Cook Forest State Park, Kinzua Dam, Elk viewing areas, & Straub Brewery. Enjoy!

Top guest favorite

A spacious interior features a wooden staircase leading to a loft bedroom with a blue bedspread. Natural light enters through large windows, illuminating the area. A small desk and chair are positioned on the lower level, next to a shiny kitchen appliance and brick wall.

Loft in Ridgway

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 201 reviews

The Church Loft

Welcome to Ridgway! This 1 bed/1 bath loft style apartment sits inside of what was once the area's first Free Methodist church - it’s certainly not what you’ll expect to see inside. You’ll love the super high ceilings and the open concept. Originally built in 1894, we’re conveniently located near downtown and steps away from great PA Wilds hiking! Ridgway’s Rail Trail is also just blocks away. Enjoy a full kitchen and your own laundry room, as well as a dining area and personal work space.

Guest favorite

The kitchen features high ceilings and large windows, allowing natural light to illuminate the space. A modern island with seating is complemented by sleek cabinetry and a farmhouse sink. Scenic views of the surrounding area are visible through the windows.

Cabin in Irvine

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Riverbend Cabin~ Allegheny Island Wilderness Area

Located at the end of a quiet lane, with a stunning view of the Allegheny River, our riverfront cabin is the perfect getaway to relax with family and friends. Nestled right between Tidioute and Warren, our cabin is close to many sites within the National Forest: Buckaloons, Heart's Content, Rocky Gap, etc. There's also a great view of Crull's Island, a 96 acre paradise within the Allegheny Wilderness Area. Be on the lookout for heron, osprey, waterfowl, deer, and the amazing bald eagle!

Guest favorite

A serene landscape features a gently flowing creek surrounded by lush greenery. Trees with fresh leaves create a vibrant canopy overhead. A wooden bridge crosses the creek, adding a natural touch to the tranquil setting.

Cottage in Warren

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 380 reviews

The Edy

Nestled in the Allegheny National Forest along the Allegheny River. A cozy home with nearby fishing, hunting, historical landmarks, cross country, skiing, hiking, biking, antique shops, boating, and kayaking/ canoeing. Moments away from adventures nearby including the Kinzua Dam where the Alleghany River is poured from. Peaceful & quiet for relaxation. 😊Pets are permitted an additional cleaning fee is charged. “Must” notify us if planning on having a pet with you on your visit .

Guest favorite

The cabin is nestled beside the river, surrounded by lush greenery and large trees. A spacious deck is visible, featuring a canopy for shade, with views of the water and nearby natural landscape, reflecting a peaceful outdoor atmosphere.

Cabin in Tidioute

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 216 reviews

Riverfront Cabin w/ amazing views! Summer!

A camp with a million dollar view and only one other camp on the other side of the stream and wooded area. Bring your family and friends to camp out, cook out, go fishing, canoeing or kayaking. Children can play in the stream beside the camp or on the jetty, or even walk across the Allegheny to the island to play and explore. A fun, relaxing retreat for years of memories. This is a 4 season cabin so come and experience the Lehmeier's lodge during the various seasons.

Guest favorite

The cabin is illuminated by warm string lights against a night sky, surrounded by tall trees. Large windows reflect the soft glow from inside, while the outdoor area features seating for relaxation beneath the canopy of branches.

Cabin in Clarendon

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 219 reviews

🌲Rustic Run Cabin in the Allegheny National Forest

The Rustic Run Cabin located in Warren County, Pennsylvania, surrounded by Timberlands, State and National Forests. Rustic Run is a perfect cabin getaway for couples, families, and groups of friends searching for a relaxing vacation or ideal lodging close to many outdoor adventures! Open year-round. We welcome well behaved, mature and non-destructive dogs. Two dogs is our limit. There is an extra $50 pet fee per stay.

Guest favorite

A modern living room is shown, featuring a blue sectional sofa adorned with decorative pillows. Two dark armchairs provide additional seating. A circular coffee table occupies the center, and a light area rug lines the floor. Windows allow natural light to enhance the space.

Home in Warren

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Lush Newly Renovated Home - Downtown Warren Pa

Sleeps: Up to 8, W/Hypo Allergenic Luxury Bedding 4 Bedrooms - 5 Beds: (1) Queen, (1) Full, (1) Twin W/ (1) Twin Trundle, (1) Queen w/2nd Recreation Area (Seating, Gaming, Work Space) Living Room w/Electric Fireplace, Dinning Area with Large Table, 1-Bathroom w/Double Sinks and Large Vanity Hair Dryer, Straightener and Toiletries Provided (Soap, Shampoo, Condition, Lotion), TV’s in all Sleeping and Living Areas

Guest favorite

A charming cabin is set in a wooded landscape, featuring a red metal roof and large glass doors that open to a deck area. Two Adirondack chairs surround a fire pit on a gravel base, inviting relaxation amidst nature.

Cabin in Russell

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Secluded Egypt Hollow Cabin

Escape to a serene cabin near the Allegheny National Forest in Russell NWPA. Perfect for travelers and couples seeking a relaxing getaway surrounded by nature. 1 Bed. 1 Bath. Private Cabin Enjoy a stream, fire pit, and private driveway. Explore hiking, biking, and all types of boating nearby. Enjoy local businesses downtown Warren. Host available for questions and recommendations. Book your getaway now!

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area is presented with a soft blue sofa and an armchair near a charming brick fireplace. Natural light enters through large windows. A dining table with wooden chairs is visible alongside decorative plants, creating a comfortable space for relaxation and socializing.

Home in Warren

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Cheerful two bedroom home!

Kick back and relax in this quaint space, located on outskirts of Town. You’ll find everything you need to enjoy a weekend get-a-way to a long vacation. This home is located just a short drive from restaurants, shops, and more. Or take the scenic drive to the the hidden gem of Pennsylvania…The Allegheny National Forest. Guest will be able to use the entire property including a small one car garage.