Vacation rentals in Plum Island, Newburyport

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

A cozy outdoor seating area is visible at Sunset Club, featuring multiple picnic-style tables adorned with multi-colored surfaces. The building's shingled exterior is complemented by a large sign. The sky displays soft hues as twilight approaches, enhancing the relaxed atmosphere.

Cottage in Newbury

Plum Island Sunset Cottage

Come to PI to stay at our renovated beach house! Enjoy daily sunsets, a short walk to the beach, ice cream, restaurants, convenience, and wild life! The house sleeps 8, with 2 queen bedrooms & 1 bunk room that sleeps 4. The perfect spot to stay to be close to Newburyport, the surf, bird watching, running, cycling, and scenic walks through the peaceful Wildlife Refuge. Please note: this is NOT a party house. It's a cottage to be enjoyed by friends & family, in respect to neighbors and our home.

Sturdy wooden steps lead to the entryway of the cottage, flanked by decorative potted plants. A seating area is visible to the left, featuring a cozy arrangement of outdoor furniture. Colorful flowers bloom in pots along the steps, contributing to the inviting atmosphere.

5 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

The Chic Shack! Steps 2 Beach & Restaurants.

Welcome to The Chic Shack by Casa De Moraga! This tiny beach cottage is steps away from all PI has to offer! 3 min walk to main beach, Sunset Club, Riptide, Cottage Market/Ice Cream etc. 7 min drive to historic downtown Newburyport with the best restaurants & shopping in the North Shore. This tiny cottage is cute & cozy with a boho beach vibe & all the amenities you need. PLUS, a private fenced in yard with deck for lounging/dining & an outdoor shower! We are dog friendly, bring your fur baby!

A well-lit open living space features high ceilings with exposed wooden beams. Large windows provide clear views of the surrounding area, while a dining table with white chairs invites gatherings. Natural light enhances the warm tones of the wooden flooring.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Brivera by the Sea, a Beautiful Plum Island Escape

Coveted South Island location for your New England beach vacation. Ample yard space for beach and ocean views! 3 min walk to sand, 5 min walk to restaurants & stores at the Island center; 3 min to Parker River Wildlife Refuge; 10 min drive to historic Newburyport. There are enough beds for the whole family to comfortably sleep up to 10 people. Fish from the sand, walk or bike the island, visit the Parker River Reserve, or enjoy the fantastic Newbury/Newburyport area with many dining options!

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

An outdoor seating area features bright orange Adirondack chairs arranged around a fire pit, complemented by a shaded area provided by a large umbrella. The cottage is visible in the background, showcasing its coastal charm with fresh landscaping enhancing the inviting space.

Cottage in Newbury

Designer decorated-Sunset Bliss- Beach 3 min walk

Peaceful Plum Island cottage, renovated fall of 2018 and 2023 with New England coastal charm. Open floor plan and water views of the marsh, a short 3 minute walk to the beach. Watch the sun rise over the Atlantic and enjoy the spectacular sunset directly in front of the house for a nightly show. Walk the cottage for ice cream, Rip tide & the Sunset Club for cocktails and dinner. Beach, boating, fishing, wildlife sanctuary, and the historic downtown Newburyport all just 40 miles from Boston!

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 388 reviews

The exterior of the house features a spacious deck with white railings and steps leading to the ground level. The lower terrace is adorned with decorative pots and greenery, while a gravel pathway provides access to the entryway.

Apartment in Newbury

My Dream house with views of the marsh and sunset

Our rental space has two bedrooms, living room, full bath and a mini kitchen. There is a full deck across the front of the house and a large patio off the bedrooms which is accessed though the sliders in each bedroom. This is all private space for our guests. The views from the front deck are of the great marsh along with the beautiful sunsets. With the Two bedrooms one with a queen size bed and the other with full size bed the house can have 2 to 4 people depending on sleeping arrangements.

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Apartment in Newburyport

Walk to Beach | Playground | Lighthouse | North En

Welcome to this charming 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath cottage on the island's northern tip. Just steps from the beach, boardwalk, Merrimack River, playground, and Plum Island Lighthouse, this cozy retreat sleeps up to 6 guests. Discover your perfect island getaway and enjoy your morning coffee or dinner in the spacious outdoor area while taking in the sea breeze. Only a 10-minute drive from downtown Newburyport's top dining, shopping, and entertainment. Your perfect New England getaway begins here!

Guest suite in Newburyport

Gentle waves caress a sandy beach, meeting a rocky shoreline. The ocean glistens under clear blue skies, showcasing a peaceful atmosphere. Distant waves roll towards the horizon, creating a serene coastal scene.

5 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Sunset Studio on Plum Island

Great location on Plum Island in Newburyport. This is the quiet side of the island, which is great for relaxation. Short walk or bike ride to the beach, bars, and restaurants. The Parker River Wildlife Refuge is a must-see during your stay. Downtown Newburyport is another must do...lots of fabulous shopping and eateries, and while you're there, you can walk the rail trail or just walk along the waterfront. Feel free to give me a call or text with any questions. My cell #978-314-1886.

5 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Bungalow in Newburyport

The Bungalow Luxe & Cozy Retreat by the Sea

The Bungalow is a coastal chic dream built for two! A newly updated & thoughtfully designed gem, nestled at the northern-most point of Plum Island, Newburyport, MA (not more than 100 paces from the ever watchful beacon of the famous Plum Island Lighthouse). Whether relaxing at the beach, paddling around the Basin, biking to one of the island stores or restaurants , or simply exploring the pristine Federal Wildlife Refuge, a special experience & adventure awaits you at The Bungalow!

A coffee station is displayed with a machine featuring a digital interface. A clear glass sits on a stainless steel drip tray, next to a glass jar labeled 'Coffee' filled with coffee pods. The countertop is blue, creating a clean and functional space.

5 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

Plum Perch: Professionally Cleaned, Close to Beach

Enjoy the best of Plum Island at this getaway walking distance from the beach and town center. 5 min walk to Newbury Beach. Central A/C. 3 full bedrooms and a private loft w/ king size bed. 2 full baths. Expansive private deck w/seating. Ample parking for 4-5 vehicles, including garage parking. Dry basement with addl rec space. Full washer dryer. Stocked kitchen with major appliances: stove, dishwasher, refrigerator, Vitamix, and pod coffee maker. Sheets and bath linens provided.

5 out of 5 average rating, 204 reviews

A modern cabin with an A-frame shape is illuminated by warm lights, surrounded by tall trees. In front, a fire pit with wooden chairs invites gatherings, while a hot tub and sauna are visible nearby, contributing to the outdoor relaxation space.

Cabin in South Berwick

Romantic A-Frame cabin in the woods

Modern cabin tucked privately in the forest. Loaded with modern amenities make it perfect for a romantic getaway. Unwind in the hot tub looking up at the sky full of stars. Take a Sauna while being surrounded by nature all around. Relax by the fire pit. Located in the majestic forest of mount agamenticus, the extensive trail system is off our road. Short drive to the Ogunquit/ york beaches, outlets at Kittery and near Portsmouth, Dover and Portland restaurant scenes.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

A spacious living area features a high wooden ceiling and large windows with views of the waterfront. A comfortable sectional sofa with a patterned ottoman and decorative cushions is positioned on a striped rug. A dining table is visible in the background, alongside a wall-mounted television.

Cottage in Newburyport

Sunset Waterfront Privacy Beach

Newly renovated waterfront with private beach and panoramic views. Enjoy the private pool (open June through September). Unmatched privacy and large outdoor living. Front row wildlife views of marsh. Bikes to venture out and discover the island. Evenings by the firepit watching the tides roll in. Amazing sunsets! Private sleeping loft in bedroom 3 perfect for older kids. Modern kitchen with a washer/dryer combo. Wake up to a fresh Tea or Coffee.

A spacious deck area is visible through sliding glass doors, featuring a wooden table and a large, round umbrella. Potted plants are placed on the table and beside it, while soft natural light filters into the interior space.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

The Pink Cottage

If the sounds of the ocean waves and the natural scent of the salt air is what you crave then look no further then our quiet cottage nestled in the sand dunes of Plum Island. We have great views of the protected dunes where you can experience beautiful sunrise and sunsets. We are lucky to have a very quiet location. There is almost no sound at night, just the sound of the ocean that will lull you to sleep and the wildlife off in the distance.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Plum Island, Newburyport vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Plum Island, Newburyport

5 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

An outdoor deck features a seating area with a woven sofa and armchairs, accented by vibrant orange and turquoise cushions. A small table is positioned in the center, surrounded by a wooden railing that overlooks the neighborhood with scattered houses and open spaces in view.

Home in Newburyport

4bd/2bth on Plum Island - 2 min walk to Beach

AndreaRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

This was a great house for our annual girls weekend. Our group of 5 had plenty of space to hang out in the kitchen/dining area and living room and had our own beds (2 people shared the upstairs room and everyone else had their own room). The house looked just like in the photos and was very clean. It was a short walk to the beach, and a short drive to nearby restaurants. We would absolutely rent it again!

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

"Shooting Star" | Beach Front

SandraRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Joshua was an amazing host! He went above and beyond to help us out during a tough time, and he was incredibly friendly to boot. Great local recomendations! To be honest, I hesitate to leave this review because I fear letting the secret out. Joshua's place is a local hidden gem that our family would love to keep all to ourselves! An Iconic beach house in a pristine location, what more could you ask for? Don't hesitate to book here, I guarantee you will not be disappointed!! Oh! And did I mention the views? Yeah, and there's that.... Outstanding!

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

A small outdoor entryway is displayed, featuring a welcoming doormat and a white chair positioned beside a round side table. A white picket fence encloses the space, with steps leading to the main door. Nearby, the neighborhood is visible with houses and trees.

Home in Newburyport

Basin House, Steps to water

MarkRating, 5 stars9 months ago

Great location and a great property, recently updated and felt like we were staying in a nice hotel. The outside is even better than the pictures display, as it had an enclosed patio with nice furniture and a blackstone grill. 7 minute walk to a full beach and right across the street from an inlet, if you have your own kayak. Plum Island is beautiful, with multiple beach options (including a state park) and downtown Newburyport has great restaurants. We even did a day trip to Hampton Beach for fun. We had to book last minute due to a different host cancelling on us last minute and Kevin and the owners were very accommodating. We would definitely stay again.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

A modern kitchen is presented, featuring white cabinetry with open shelves showcasing an assortment of glassware, dishes, and utensils. A stainless steel stove and microwave are highlighted on a clean countertop, complemented by a compact toaster. Ample natural light fills the space through a nearby window.

Home in Newburyport

The Birdhouse—Sunny Plum Island Home, Pet-Friendly

AmritaRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

Overall, our experience was great. Ben and Maggie have a beautiful place and we enjoyed our stay.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

The image depicts a sandy beach with foamy water washing ashore, reflecting the sunlight. In the background, waves can be seen crashing against a weathered wooden structure, adding a natural texture to the coastal setting.

Apartment in Newbury

Pretty Cottage on Plum Island, Newbury MA

WilliamRating, 5 stars7 months ago

Paula's Airbnb on Plum Island is very spacious and comfortable. She also responds to questions and concerns very quickly! We recommend her place if you are looking to stay in Newbury!

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 56 reviews

Plum Island Dream Home

Samantha JRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Beyond expectations!

A view of a serene waterscape is framed by lush greenery and flowering bushes. A picnic table and two chairs are positioned on the grassy area, offering a spot to enjoy the surroundings. Across the water, houses are visible against the horizon.

Cottage in Newbury

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Plum Island Basin Waterfront Weekly Rental

PatriciaRating, 5 stars10 months ago

We had a great week The cottage is 500 steps to the beautiful beach!! We enjoyed relaxing on the deck right on the water (cove). Newbury is a wonderful town to walk around, shop, eat, etc. Mike was extremely attentive and helpful.