House vacation rentals in Pickaway County

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Pickaway County

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Home in Laurelville

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Marjie's Retreat with Hot Tub & Swimming Pool

Located just 15 miles from the beautiful Hocking Hills state park and numerous trails, and only 5 miles from the Riser Barn wedding venue, Marjie's Retreat offers 4 spacious bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, all new appliances and an outdoor deck, propane grill, swimming pool and 6-person hot tub. Marjie’s Retreat is conveniently located in the heart of Laurelville where you can find several local restaurants, pizza shops, an ice cream shop and a grocery store. NOTE: Pool is open May 1st-September 30th

Home in Circleville

High Court

Unwind in Circleville at this quaint house that was built in the early 1900s. With 3 full beds spread across 3 bedrooms, guests can enjoy a comfortable stay. This enjoyable property also offers everyday amenities. We also offer complimentary items and a desk for you to catch up on work, if needed. This adorable house is located within walking distance to local shops & restaurants. The courtyard allows for outdoor seating and activities as well. We look forward to welcoming you to our place!

Guest favorite

Home in Laurelville

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Mayor's Manor: Hot Tub | Game Room | Fire Pit

Come stay in our quiet secluded home in Laurelville, OH, this cozy 4-bedroom house is perfect for families and friends exploring the Hocking Hills. It is centrally located within 10 miles of the Hocking Hills and Tar Hollow State Park. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, pool table, ping pong, hot tub, and a relaxing outdoor patio with a fire pit. The Mayor's Manor is located within walking distance to many local Restaurants, Pizza Shops and Grocery Store! Book now for your perfect getaway!

Superhost

Home in Amanda

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Moccasin Creek Cottage

Come enjoy a stay at our little cottage. It is tucked up close to the woods, with a lovely secluded backyard. We have a tv - amazon fire tv, you have to have your own subscriptions. We have WIFI, out door sitting area, and a grill. We are 7 miles from rock house. We are 2.5 miles from Tarlton, Ohio which has a IGA convenient store, Dollar General, and Crosstown diner. We are 5 miles from Laurellville with gas, grocery store and restaurants, and the famous Apple Cider House open in the fall.

Top guest favorite

Home in Canal Winchester

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Bellawood Farmhouse

Bellawood Farmhouse is a one of a kind Agritourism experience! This 1800’s French Country brick home is nestled on 82 acres of beautiful active farmland. The updated chef’s kitchen is equipped with a 48”, 6 burner gas range, double ovens, a pot filler and 7’ custom fridge. The large island, buffet and dining table make this home perfect for large gatherings! Outside you will find a secluded in ground pool, out door dining, lounge area and outdoor bar and grill designed for entertaining.

Guest favorite

Home in Laurelville

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews

PetsOK-SunsetViews-EpicGameroom-Hottub~Daybed

💥Special Discount on 2+ Nights 🌙Sleeps 15 🌳Secluded yet 2 mins to town 🌐1–15 mi to attractions 🎮1300 Sq Ft Temp Controlled Game Barn: 2x 65" TVs, Pool, Ping Pong, Air Hockey, SkeeBall, Basketball Arcade, 4x Arcades (Golf, NBA, MK, PacMan), Shuffleboard, Poker Lounge 🛁In-ground Hot Tub & Soaking Tub 🌅5 Outdoor Spaces 🔥 4 Fireplaces 💼 2 Workspaces 🌅Sunset Views, Balcony, Outdoor Dining 👶Pack 'n Play, High Chair 📽️ 65" Media Room, Record Player 🌟Foosball, Cornhole, Giant Jenga

Top guest favorite

Home in Orient

5 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Welcome To Twin Run Farm!

***Private events/parties-pricing is different, please inquire directly. Our home is an 1800's farmhouse that has been completely renovated! Sitting on 5 1/2 acres, TRF has a large private outdoor space, firepits, 3 bedrooms sleeping 10 guests, and has everything a hotel stay could offer and more! And the best part? We are dog friendly! We do have a 2 dog minimum. TRF is located in Commercial Point, Ohio-just south of Grove City and 15 miles from downtown Columbus.

Home in Circleville

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Shady Pines

Welcome to this cozy townhome! This 2 bedroom townhome provides all the amenities to make your stay at this Circleville property very enjoyable! With a fully stocked kitchen, with a microwave, toaster, coffee maker, plus all the utensils. Each bedroom is furnished with a full size bed. TV and dresser.Private outdoor patio space at the rear of the property. Centrally located, within walking distance to Circleville, OH-Downtown restaurants, shops, and bars.

Guest favorite

Home in Laurelville

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

The Laurelville House

Come stay with us for a peaceful getaway! The Laurelville house has all the amenities for you to have the best vacation. Located 8 1/2 miles from the Hocking Hills State Park and 10 miles from Tar Hollow State Park. It is also conveniently close to the grocery store, restaurants and coffee shops! Enjoy a fully stocked kitchen, games and puzzles, coffee on the front porch, a dip in the hot tub, and a latte from the coffee bar.

Guest favorite

Home in Tarlton

5 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

The Main House @ Tarlton’s Edge

The Main House is the perfect place for your family to enjoy a relaxing getaway! Easy access to Hocking Hills State Park hiking trails, Circleville 15mins, Lancaster & Chillicothe under 30mins. Watch a family movie in the great room, play a game of air hockey in the basement, or simply relax with a good book next to the gas fireplace. Whatever the reason, we are sure you will love your stay at the Main House!

Guest favorite

Home in Orient

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

62 Farmhouse

Relax with family and friends at this peaceful place to stay. This renovated 1900s farmhouse is conveniently located near Grove City and Columbus yet far enough to escape the hustle and bustle. Nearby Battelle Darby Creek metro park offers areas to hike, bike, and kayak. Also only 1 mile away is the beautiful White Willow Meadows event space!