Vacation rentals in Pickaway County

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Pickaway County

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

A cozy family room is centered around a leather sectional sofa, with ample seating for guests. A large TV is mounted on the wall across from the seating area, beside a classic decorative fireplace. Soft lighting is provided by table lamps, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.

Apartment in Circleville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

The Happy Place, in historic uptown Circleville

Housed in the 1859 Jones Building, the Happy Place keeps the integrity of the original space with meaningful updates. High ceilings, original decorative fireplaces, newly refinished original hardwood floors and a billiards room. Located in historic uptown Circleville, just steps away from dining, the Ted Lewis Museum, Wittich's Candy Shop - the nation's oldest family owned and operated confectionary. 30 minutes to downtown Columbus and 30 minutes to the Hocking Hills and Deer Creek State Pk

ValueFamilyDecor

Guest favorite

Townhouse in Circleville

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 98 reviews

Charming Historic District 3-Bedroom Townhouse

Bring the whole family to this Historic Home with lots of room to relax. This Federal Style home was built in 1835 and has three bedrooms, two baths, kitchen, dining room and living room. Features include hardwood floors, 12' ceilings and modern decor. Enjoy all that Circleville has to offer: within walking distance to Lindsey's Bakery, Wittich's Candy Shop, local restaurants & shopping. The dining room offers seating for everyone and the kitchen has everything you need for the family.

LocationFamilyAmenities

Guest favorite

An indoor game area is presented, featuring several tables, including a foosball table and an air hockey table. The space is illuminated by overhead lights, with a rustic wooden decor in the background. Comfortable seating is available along the walls.

Cabin in Circleville

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Private Fun Barn~Hot Tub~Pool Table~Karaoke

Fun Barn NEW for 2025!!! Take a step of serenity into our Norwegian inspired Hocking Hills Lodge. Luxuriously designed and perfect for large families, friends, wedding parties, and even corporate retreats. Enjoy a campfire under the stars, relax in the oversized hot tub, or embrace your competitive side in the Fun Barn! Locally owned and available 24/7. Hocking Hills Hikes: Rockhouse: 14mi Cantwell Cliffs: 19mi Conkle's Hollow: 19mi Old Man's Cave: 22mi Support small businesses, Book Now!

ValueFamilyDecor

Guest favorite

The front exterior of the cottage is seen, featuring a light-colored facade and large windows. A grassy lawn is surrounded by shrubs and trees, providing shade. A gravel path leads to the entrance, enhancing the welcoming appearance of the property.

Apartment in Circleville

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Roundtown Blue Cottage

Discover a perfect short-term, mid-term rental on a tranquil street located on the north side of " Roundtown" This updated 2-BR, 1-bath combines comfort with convenience. Within walking distance of Berger Hospital, perfect for traveling hospital staff. Enjoy a spacious living area, a fully equipped kitchen, and work space. Just minutes from shops and dining. Famous for Circleville "Pumpkin Show" in October. Great place for traveling workers who need mid-term or short term accommodations.

FamilyLocationIndoor spaces

Top guest favorite

Home in Lithopolis

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

Charming Craftsman Cottage

Enjoy a cozy retreat at this centrally-located cottage in the heart of historic Lithopolis, Ohio — a beautifully maintained 720 sq ft home that blends classic 1930’s charm with modern comfort. Perfect for a relaxing getaway, business stay, or small-town escape, this inviting space offers a peaceful atmosphere from the moment you step inside. Downstairs includes 2 additional queen beds. Space has lower ceilings and is kid-friendly with a 55” Roku tv, and PlayStation. New washer & dryer.

FamilyLocationAccuracy

Guest favorite

Home in Laurelville

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

Mayor's Manor: Hot Tub | Game Room | Fire Pit

Come stay in our quiet cozy home in Laurelville, OH, this cozy 4-bedroom house is perfect for families and friends exploring the Hocking Hills. It is centrally located within 10 miles of the Hocking Hills and Tar Hollow State Park. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, pool table, ping pong, hot tub, and a relaxing outdoor patio with a fire pit. The Mayor's Manor is located within walking distance to many local Restaurants, Pizza Shops and Grocery Store! Book now for your perfect getaway!

FamilyValueKitchen

Top guest favorite

A spacious kitchen is highlighted by a large central island with three wooden stools. A 48-inch gas range with an elegant hood and double ovens are prominently featured. Light cabinetry complements a gray stone backsplash, with ample natural light illuminating the area.

Home in Canal Winchester

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 74 reviews

Bellawood Farmhouse

Bellawood Farmhouse is a one of a kind Agritourism experience! This 1800’s French Country brick home is nestled on 82 acres of beautiful active farmland. The updated chef’s kitchen is equipped with a 48”, 6 burner gas range, double ovens, a pot filler and 7’ custom fridge. The large island, buffet and dining table make this home perfect for large gatherings! Outside you will find a secluded in ground pool, out door dining, lounge area and outdoor bar and grill designed for entertaining.

LocationFamilyHospitality

Guest favorite

Cottage in Lithopolis

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

Cozy *former* log-cabin, between Cbus & Lancaster

Cozy apartment in the quaint lil town of Lithopolis, minutes from Columbus & Lancaster. Are you homophobic or transphobic? Please don’t book with us, we don’t need your money. Local eateries & shops, plus nearby metro parks, groceries & other shopping make this a perfect place for business or leisure; overnight or long-term. We are safe for, affirming of, and welcoming to the LGBTQIA+ community. If your preferred dates aren't open message us and we'll see what we can do for you.

LocationFamilyKitchen

Guest favorite

The living area features wooden walls and high ceilings, creating a warm atmosphere. Two couches and an oversized chair face a gas fireplace, while a 55" smart TV is mounted nearby. Additional seating is offered by a wooden dining table accompanied by soft green blankets.

Cabin in Laurelville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

Cozy Creekside Cabin in the heart of Hocking Hills

Enjoy the best of both worlds! Our lovingly restored cabin is 15 miles from all of Hocking Hills' beautiful attractions on 2 creekside acres, with spacious porches, yard, fire pit, & newly installed hot tub and deck! Just at the outskirts of Laurelville-- half a mile from gas, groceries, diners, parks, & Laurelville Fruit Co. Enjoy the cozy living space, 55" smart TV, puzzles, games, & books. Full kitchen and 4 person dining table for making meals & memories together. 00726

FamilyValueComfort

Guest favorite

Cabin in Orient

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 92 reviews

Cozy Bear Cabin Hideaway - Hot Tub, Sauna, Firepit

FREE CANOE AND KAYAK PASSES (4) TO TRAPPER JOHN'S CANOE LIVERY TO BE USED DURING YOUR STAY. (Seasonal availability)Take a step back in time and snuggle up to The Cozy Bear Cabin. Built in the 1800's, this one-of-a-kind cabin sits tucked away on 6 secluded acres just south of Columbus. It offers a unique blend of outdoor adventure, total privacy, and proximity. Outdoors enjoy our state of the art hot tub, sauna, and complimentary canoe and kayaking adventures - details below!

LocationFamilyCheck-in

Superhost

A comfortable living area features a plush sectional sofa adorned with decorative pillows. A wooden coffee table sits in the center, accompanied by a reading chair. Light-colored walls and a decorative rug enhance the space, while a ceiling fan provides ventilation.

Home in Circleville

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Shady Pines

Welcome to this cozy townhome! This 2 bedroom townhome provides all the amenities to make your stay at this Circleville property very enjoyable! With a fully stocked kitchen, with a microwave, toaster, coffee maker, plus all the utensils. Each bedroom is furnished with a full size bed. TV and dresser.Private outdoor patio space at the rear of the property. Centrally located, within walking distance to Circleville, OH-Downtown restaurants, shops, and bars.

ValueLocationHospitality

Guest favorite

Cabin in Laurelville

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 278 reviews

Rustic Cabin| Secluded Retreat, HotTub, SunsetView

➤ Rustic Cabin: Secluded yet near the enchanting beauty of Hocking Hills. ➤ Indoors: Wood burning Fireplace, WiFi & Smart TV, Vinyl Record Player, Swing, Fully Equipped Kitchen ➤ Outdoor amenities: Hot tub, Charcoal Grill, Fire-pit, Swings, String lights, and Rocking chairs with sunset views. ➤ Located just 1-2 miles from convenience stores, grocery stores, and restaurants in Laurelville. ➤ Discounts on 3+ nights & Early Bird

ValueFamilyAir conditioning