Cabin vacation rentals in Penn Yan

Absolutely Perfect Girls’ Getaway! We stayed at this cabin for a girls trip and couldn’t have asked for a better experience. The location was peaceful and secluded, yet close enough to everything we needed. The cabin was spotless, cozy, and stocked with all the essentials! The hosts were super responsive and made us feel welcome from the start. Honestly, we didn’t want to leave. Highly recommend for a relaxing, fun, and memory-filled escape.

fire place ngl

This has to be the best airbnb I've stayed in, absolutely beautiful place, had anything you could need on a trip. My girlfriend and I loved staying here and enjoyed our time immensely. Highly recommend staying here, very peaceful private place if you need quiet place to get away.

Great place to visit. The host was super responsive and generously left fresh farm eggs for us! The place is cute and comfortable and on a farm. We booked this super last minute and they were beyond accommodating! Allowed flexible check out and was really helpful with local recommendations. The bed was really comfortable and the place was spotless. Only a 5 minute drive to Watkins glen! Highly recommend!!

Our stay here was wonderful. The accommodation for the dogs was outstanding! I highly recommend to read through the house book. There are a few things we needed guidance on and the book helped us. The host is very responsive if you need anything. We left our custom leashes there. Fortunately, they found them and offered to mail the leashes back to us. Highly recommend!

Jonna was so welcoming and her house had a beautiful view. We pulled up and saw horses that she owns they were a great surprise to our trip. She welcomed us with some wine and flower along with a Birthday sign for us. She had lots of amenities + more. Everything you could think of "or forgot" she had extra for you. Jonna made sure we checked in alright and enjoyed our time with wonderful recommendation. The hot tub was the cleanest hot tub we have ever been in. We will for sure be coming back next year!

Great Stay Great Cabin! Everything was clean we felt comfortable there. The hot tub was great after the 2.4 mile walk at Watkins glen. It was too cold for us to kayak but it was nice sitting by the water and chilling. Loved the sound of the water at night.

We loved our stay here! The stay was so peaceful and private. We absolute LOVED the hottub! Great for a weekend getaway for two in the finger lakes!

Friendly and responsive host, very clean, comfortable and easy bisque cabin, we will be back again next year for our third time!

Mitchell’s cabin is better than describe. As a fellow five star super host Mitchell does an amazing job. My wife and I had a small family issue that we needed to take care of and Mitchell was very understanding with us. I cannot say enough about the place and the host you want to stay here.

This cottage is such a gem! Cozy, welcoming, and thoughtfully designed, it was the perfect home base for our trip. It is private and peaceful while still being conveniently close to town (Hammondsport) and lots of wineries (Keuka Lake/Seneca Lake). The little touches—vintage record player, some fun DVDs, and a fire pit, for an evening under the stars—made our stay extra special. The hosts were so kind, and very quick to communicate. They were also very helpful and provided wonderful recommendations for wineries, restaurants, and local services that helped us make the most of the region. Will absolutely be staying here again!

Thank you so much. It was the perfect weekend getaway to celebrate my girlfriends birthday. The house and location were gorgeous, peaceful, and the house was unbelievably well stocked. Thank you for being dog friendly, they had a great time too. Thanks Jackie!

My siblings and I had a great weekend away with each other in this beautiful cabin. Friendly host and accommodating. 😊

Genuinely a great place. Me and my family visited here over memorial weekend and had a blast walking down the trails or fishing down at the pond with everyone. Place is very clean and the view is even better in person than in the photos.

Our stay was great! So so quiet you can hear a pin drop. Being by the river was great, we got to see new baby goslings and watch people go by on kayaks. The place is very peaceful, and right down the road from a few different winery’s! The neighborhood wasn’t the most vibrant part of town, but it had its own atmosphere and views on the drive were breathtaking. Also good thing to note—the next door neighbor has a beautiful Great Dane who likes to pace the dividing fence and sometimes barks pretty loud and gets excited. Great dog, on an electric fence, but just for anyone who has reactive dogs or sensitive dogs, definitely something to consider.

Had a great time! Our 2nd time there for a quick getaway. Love the location! Has all the amenities you would need. Thanks again.

This off grid property was what I was looking for when needing a place to wind down and relax. I will definitely be keeping this place in mind for all future visits to the area.

Great cabin in Watkins Glen! Peaceful and quiet area, ideal to get away and relax in nature, and just a short drive to town and the park. The cabin is very cozy and has everything you'll need. The bathrooms are a short walk away but they are private and also clean and well stocked. Overall a great experience and I would definitely stay here again.

Ethan’s RV On a November weekend is very cozy and a home cooked meal can be made. The RV is just the place you need to feel outdoorsie. Extremely convenient for a day hike or some winding down at one of the closest Wineries around. He’s a very responsive and kind host, thank you.

I can’t say enough about Kathi & this cabin! She’s everything you’d want from a host - lovely, knowledgeable & gave the best tips! She was extremely accommodating, responsive & just an excellent host. The “cozy cabin” on Wells is just that & such a special place. The property is beautiful, peaceful & so inviting. We thoroughly enjoyed having breakfast on the pergola overlooking the pond in the morning & relaxing by the fire at night. You could do nothing else & have the time of your life but you’re also close to lots of lakes, waterfalls, wineries & quaint towns with cute shops so there is plenty to keep you occupied should you want to keep busy. Besides being picturesque, the cabin was spotless & had all the amenities you could ever need. In fact, they even supply extra toiletries in case you forgot something & wine if you’d like to partake. Such thoughtful touches! This was a bucket list trip for us & a much needed recharge. We were sad to leave but can’t wait to go back!

We had a great time. Host was attentive and responded to every question I had in a timely manner. The place was spotless and more beautiful than we expected. It rained at night but it didn’t matter because that window next to the bed is everything. We will definitely be back again with family to rent all them out!

We had such a great time here! Heidi’s place was clean and in a great location. We loved utilizing the dock and really appreciated all the personal touches that Heidi left for us!

This stay was incredible. We felt very at peace and well treated. I really enjoyed the privacy fence and use of the air conditioner as needed, not to mention we were just outside of town where it is quiet and peaceful but close enough to downtown Ithaca to go and grab some great food. Overall an excellent stay!

Was exactly as described. Private and peaceful with up-to-date amenities. Very close to countless wineries and breweries and a short drive from Geneva, Watkins Glen, or Penn Yan. I only wish I had booked for a day or two longer.