Cottage vacation rentals in New Paltz

We had a wonderful stay at Alexis' cottage! Our boys had a great time playing on the jungle gym & trampoline, playing basketball in the driving, exploring the woods, and we all took advantage of the hot tub and fire pits. The cottage was cozy and felt like home. We spent all of our time outdoors, and it was the perfect family getaway and we can't wait to come back!

My family had a wonderful stay in Danny and Travis' house. The interior was clean, beautiful, and matched the photos in the listing. The yard was lovely and quiet. We felt away from it all, while still being close to great hiking trails and dining options. Danny and Travis had very clear instructions for how to get in touch with them if we needed anything, but it wasn't necessary. It's clear they put a lot of thought and care into making the process easy for their guests, and we didn't have any issues. The only thing I will caveat is that the house is located off a gravel road, which was quite bumpy when we visited (mid-April). This wasn't an issue for us, but would be a good thing for potential guests to keep in mind.

We had a nice, quiet stay at the cottage. Bilen was a responsive host when we needed to reach out during our stay. The cottage was clean with basic amenities, but if you plan to cook then make sure you bring/buy everything you need as basic pantry items (aside from cooking oil and salt/pepper) are not provided. We enjoyed using the hot tub, which was conveniently located on the back deck. Highly recommend stopping at the Monticello Bagel Bakery at least once during your stay for delicious NY bagels!!

We will go back for the summer!! They are absolutely the best! I felt like home!! They didn't make us feel uncomfortable!! We felt like that was our home!! Thank you so much for all!! You guys are absolutely the best!!!

We always stay at Little Willow when we go skiing at Belle Ayre. I think our three years and running relationship with the house tell you all you need to know about working with the Little and Littler gang and their spot.

We loved this house! The location is beautiful with a lovely view of the stream. The house was super clean and very nicely decorated. Dan gave us very specific directions for everything. The hot tub was a nice plus. The house is in a neighborhood, but it is nice and quiet. Having only one bathroom on the first floor was a slight inconvenience, but that would be the only negative I can think of.

We had a wonderful stay at Diane’s. We were looking for a weekend away without the kids to recharge. We were able to do just that. We enjoyed the hot tub, and curling in front of the fire with a book. It was a snowy weekend but that just added to the charm. Diane’s scones are also amazing!! Diane made sure to communicate clearly and we were given all the info we needed to have a great time.

We had a lovely time staying at Jo and Sean’s place even though it was the off season. One big thing for us is that our 3 dogs were welcomed with no restrictions. We enjoyed the deck being enclosed and having the dog run accessible. The views of the lake were stunning and peaceful. Our hosts were the most responsive we’ve ever had. Before we came, they provided lots of ideas for places to visit and things to do. We hope to come back again!

I booked Nidhi's place for one night for myself and a guest to attend a show at Bearsville. The placement of everything, inside and outside, created an intentional sense of comfort. My guest arrived after me - without a thought, we ended up at the kitchen table talking for hours before the show. Again, the placement of this conversation spot felt intentional, but only after we found ourselves engaged in it. The outdoor surroundings are utilized to not only accent, but to enhance the indoor setting. The whole experience felt private and safe, and allowed us to share a really precious window of time for reconnection and decompression. In addition to the appealing aesthetics (the chosen blue for that kitchen!), the bedding was a treat to come back to at the end of the night - so inviting and equally comforting to find yourself wrapped up in in the morning. Nidhi so kindly messaged me out of concern for the very high winds we were experiencing (prepared with a generator), but no issue.

Adorable cottage absolutely ideal for unplugging and relaxing

House was great location, very comfortable- Kimberlie was awesome, thanks for your kindness. Lauren N

Nice little getaway during the cold season. The hot tub was excellent and about 100 degrees so perfect even with the cold temperature. It was still possible to put together a meal with the propane grill and warm things up in the microwave or store them away in the fridge. The heat was excellent in the space. Seems like it would be a great place to stay in the summer as well!

Darla’s cottage was such a sweet spot for a weekend getaway. Super cozy, clean, and peaceful—exactly what we were looking for. It felt tucked away in the woods but still really easy to get to, and just a few minutes down the road from Rough Cut Brewing, which was a big plus. We loved being able to grab some beers, then come back and relax inside. Darla was a great host—friendly, but gave us plenty of space. Would totally stay again next time we’re in the area!

"This feels like home already." That was my 8-year-old's response to this sweet Kerhonkson cottage, just one hour after we arrived. I could end my five-star review there but I'll add some perks listed and not listed, which we really enjoyed. Prime location. The cottage is within a 20-minute radius of so many wonderful spots. We come for the Bonticue Crag rock scramble but stay for Saunderskill Farm, Upstate Taco, Bluebird Wine and Spirits and so much more. The creek. My kids walked there barefoot and sunned on the rocks. If you're lucky: farm fresh eggs are sold on the honor system on the main road just past the creek. The shower. You'll see. Smaller perks: The back deck gets great sun. So much closet/drawer space to organize your stuff. Lighting options galore, and almost all of them on dimmers. Sonos sound system and a charging station. The cozy office space, in case you have to "check in" or if you just want some alone time. Thank you, Consuelo! We'll be back.

Nice house in an excellent location equidistant from Milford and Narrowsburg. Olga was attentive and responsive. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay.

Loved our stay in this beautiful cottage, perfect for the 2 of us. Extremely clean and beautifully decorated with a TV that had all the movie channels. The kitchen was well equipped with everything needed, including delicious coffee . The bed was incredibly comfortable, slept like a baby. Pillows and blankets added to the comfy feel of home. Mark is a wonderful host who insured that the driveway was free of snow and ice prior to our arrival Highly recommend visiting.

We loved this little cottage tucked away in the woods. The location is perfect, making it easy to access many of the Catskills popular trails, and also close access to Tannersville for those nights when you just don't feel like cooking. The cottage was clean, tidy, had a beautiful rustic/ classically modern aesthetic, and the kitchen was impressively well stocked with well maintained cookware for the nights when we did want to cook. I cannot say enough good things about this place, I already have another trip here booked, and I'm looking forward to many future trips back! Don't sleep on this place- it is darling!

We loved our time spent at Michael’s this weekend! We immediately felt at home in the cozy space and the outdoor amenities were exactly what we were looking for! I’ll definitely be back.

We had a perfect long weekend at Steven's cottage. It is bigger than it looks in the photos and was immaculately clean when we arrived. Steven was extremely responsive to all our questions and needs. The place is incredibly peaceful, a 2 min walk from the lake, on a private road where Steven owns all three houses. It was so relaxing and rejuvenating to spend time at this oasis with my partner and our best friends. There's a lot to love, but the best part is that the house comes with a private deck and dock, and unlimited access to various boats, to make your lake weekend whatever you want it to be. We loved that we could take our dogs to play fetch off the dock and not worry about getting in anyone's way or having to share any space. It was a great stay and we hope to go back!

We had a great time (and so did our French bulldog!) - this cozy, welcoming home was exactly what we were looking for to spend a quiet, peaceful winter getaway. The cottage was very clean, the fireplace added a wonderful touch to the ambiance and the beautiful surroundings were perfect for long walks. Brian was always super responsive and even suggested local events for us. We can’t wait to be back!

Beautiful, comfortable home. Went up for a few days of peace and quiet and got exactly what we were looking for. The cottage is well stocked, clean, and cheerful. Clear instructions made check in/out and getting around the area a breeze. The stream out back burbled like something out of a fairytale and was the perfect background noise for a countryside getaway.

We had a lovely stay at Monica’s place. It was a cozy getaway from the city and we had a wonderful weekend trip to the nearby towns. The space is exactly as listed and even cuter in person. Highly recommend!

Perfect home base for hiking! Located near numerous recreation areas. The backyard is fantastic to sit outside and unwind to the sound of the creek. Lots of stars at night visible. Couch was super comfy and nice big tv. Don’t forget to try the pancakes at the diner down the road!

We were expecting a peaceful, rustic, laid-back experience, and that's just what we got...and more. The cottage is situated in a lovely setting surrounded by trees, right at the edge of a picturesque brook. The inside was all we could ask for and more. So inviting and clean. Oozing warmth and charm. Every time we needed something, we could find it already supplied. The hosts clearly have thought of everything. We also loved the surrounding area. We spent lots of time in local eateries, checking out the nearby towns, and visiting the dozens of antique shops nearby. We had a wonderful time.