Vacation rentals in New Haven

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Haven

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A comfortable living area is showcased with a spacious gray sofa adorned with blue and green cushions. A round wooden coffee table is centered on a large area rug. Two tall windows allow natural light to fill the space, complemented by a small dining table and chair.

Bungalow in Evansville

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 395 reviews

Fabulous on Historic First St. Near Haynies Corner

Light and airy with 11ft ceilings and warm wood floors, this 900 sq foot updated downtown 1 bedroom is just right for your next visit to Evansville. Whether you are in town for work or for play, this is a great spot for you. Located in the same block as Haynies Corner, two blocks from the river trail, and very close to Main Street, Ford Center and Old National events Plaza this home provides a great spot for the active life as well as the night life. Fully equipped, stainless appliances.

Top guest favorite

A charming carriage house features textured red siding and a spacious driveway. Lush flower gardens with colorful blooms line the front, complemented by well-maintained landscaping. A single-car garage is visible, showcasing a clean and inviting exterior that blends harmoniously with the surroundings.

Home in New Harmony

5 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

The Angel Carriage House in New Harmony

Cozy and elegant, located in the heart of historic New Harmony, this 1920's carriage house was reimagined, expanded, and tastefully furnished as a stand-alone guest house in 2016. It includes a fully equipped kitchen, roomy bedroom plus queen-sized sofa bed in the living room, two full baths, hi-speed WIFI, three HD TVs, a private back porch with one of the best views in New Harmony, and heated & A/Ced garage. Relax and recharge, just one or two blocks from the town's key attractions.

Guest favorite

A bright and spacious living area features an orange couch, a neutral ottoman, and a dark leather chair. Two windows provide natural light, while a chandelier with antlers adds a rustic touch. A television is mounted on the wall above a wooden console.

Tiny home in Harrisburg

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Tiny Cabin in the Big Woods

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Enjoy being a few short minutes from Garden of the Gods and the Shawnee National Forest at this gated home. Adventure during the day and enjoy a calm evening at night in this well appointed cabin. This newly finished cabin contains all new furnishings and high end finishes. The kitchen is equipped to cook any meal of your choice. The home features a small loft bedroom. Prefer not to climb the ladder? A queen size air mattress is included

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Equality

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Private Retreat - 9 miles from Garden of The Gods

Welcome to our ultra-private, 9-acre hideaway located on a hill between Garden of The Gods and Highway 13. Overlooking the peaks of Shawnee National Forest and central to Garden of the Gods, Cave-in-Rock, Burden Falls, Rim Rock and all the popular hikes, Equality Hill House is truly the best base to experience Southern Illinois. Spend your days exploring or enjoy the large backyard with fire-pit, added June 2025, and pond added in Oct 2024. Host Guidebook provided upon booking! :-)

Top guest favorite

The front of the cottage features a welcoming dark blue exterior with a bright red door, flanked by well-maintained gardens. Potted plants and colorful flowers enhance the entrance, providing a charming first impression. A small walkway leads to the door, completing the inviting atmosphere.

Cottage in New Harmony

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 395 reviews

New Harmony Cottage

Open concept cottage w lots of space for one or two located in the Historic District of New Harmony. Free street parking, a sitting area and comfortable queen bed. Washer/Dryer and a small kitchenette (no stove or cooktop.) WiFi and and a Smart TV for your convenience. Bring your Netflix or Hulu passwords. Be our guest in your own space. Easy no contact checkin & checkout. Coffee/Tea bar or Black Lodge Coffee! *FYI check hours for shops & restaurants that you plan on visiting.

Guest favorite

The entrance to the cabin is framed by wooden siding, featuring a central door adorned with a seasonal wreath. Natural elements, including pumpkins, are arranged on a small porch flanked by rustic decorations and a wooden fence made of branches.

Cabin in Dixon

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 510 reviews

Handcrafted Cabin in Woodsy Heaven

PLEASE read listing before booking. Custom built wood cabin nestled in the rolling hills of western Kentucky. Cozy decor with vintage theme, handcrafted wood floors, and outdoor space overlooking wooded property. Rustic studio space full of modern amenities. Close proximity to 5450 acre Wildlife Management Area with hiking, horseback riding, fishing, hunting, and swimming. Perfect location to get back to nature. Great peaceful weekend or overnight getaway.

Guest favorite

A modern bathroom features a wooden vanity with a smooth countertop and multiple faucets. A large mirror reflects the space, while beige and grey tiles complement the decor. The shower area showcases a tiled wall with decorative accents, providing a clean and functional atmosphere.

Guest suite in Fairfield

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 221 reviews

Day of Rest

This place is in a private, residential neighborhood but only a few blocks from businesses, shopping and restaurants. There are two small parks for children to play at, nearby. There is plenty of parking for multiple vehicles or a commercial truck/trailer. Bright outdoor LED lighting provides a safe atmosphere. This property is attached to a small venue. The venue has a full kitchen area that can be rented for an additional fee.

Guest favorite

The house is framed by a welcoming front porch with white railings and a sloped roof. Lush, manicured shrubs line the pathway, leading to the entrance. Brick steps are bordered by flower beds, enhancing the garden's natural beauty. A clear sky adds to the inviting front view.

Home in Eldorado

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

The Paddock at 1208 - Simplicity, Style & Comfort

The Paddock at 1208 is a house that was built in the 1920's. Former owner was a pharmacist and racing horse trainer hence the name and decor. There is a sister house across the street, The Choisser Burnett House which sleeps six and is also on Airbnb.com. Twenty minutes minutes south is the Shawnee National Forest whose terrain spans woodlands, hills and lakes and it's wildlife includes bald eagles.

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area features a light-colored sectional sofa facing a round coffee table. The space is adorned with wooden ceiling panels and warm brown walls. A staircase at the back leads to additional levels, while a small kitchenette is visible in the background.

Guesthouse in Carmi

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 92 reviews

The Main St Carriage House - a charming cottage

This is a charming 1 bedroom 1.5 bath cottage located in the heart of Carmi. Enjoy the fully stocked kitchen, dining table for 4, high speed Wi-Fi, two smart TVs, 1 queen bed upstairs with a half bath, with a full Bath on the main floor, and a private parking spot. We also have a 25amp Level 2 charger available upon request for anyone needing to charge their EV while they stay!

Top guest favorite

A single-story cabin with wooden siding and a green metal roof is featured. A spacious front porch with railing provides outdoor seating options. Surrounding the cabin are patches of grass and gravel, with trees visible in the background, creating a natural setting.

Vacation home in Equality

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

JACS COUNTRY CABINS SHAWNEE 2

COZY 1 BEDROOM, 1 BATH CABIN AT THE EDGE OF THE SHAWNEE NATIONAL FOREST. LOCATED 10 MILES FROM GARDEN OF THE GODS AND & 1 MILE FROM GLENN O JONES LAKE. IT SITS BEHIND JACS PLACE (A BAR/CONVENIENCE STORE) AND 2 MILES FROM A LAUNDRY MAT IN EQUALITY. WE PROVIDE COFFEE BUT THE CLOSEST GROCERY STORE IS ROUGHLY 10 MINS AWAY IN ELDORADO, SO PLAN, PACK SNACKS/FOOD ACCORDINGLY.

Top guest favorite

The cozy living room features a combination of leather sofas adorned with colorful cushions. A coffee table sits in the center, surrounded by a patterned area rug. Retractable curtains frame the windows, allowing natural light. A desk area and decorative shelving add functionality.

Loft in Carmi

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews

The Main Street Loft

Artsy. Spacious. Exceptionally comfortable. Experience cozy hospitality in our newly remodeled 1920’s luxury loft. The loft is a private apartment on the 2nd floor. It has a separate outside entrance with its own keypad lock; fully-stocked kitchen, dining room, living room, smart TV, laundry room, bathroom, & 3 bedrooms. Each bed is covered in quality bedding.

Guest favorite

An indoor pool area features a long, narrow pool, surrounded by large windows that allow natural light to fill the space. The tiled floor is complemented by potted plants, and wicker chairs with cushions are arranged nearby for seating.

Vacation home in Evansville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

Nugent House

It's rare to find a place that's both historic and one-of-a-kind. Whole house to enjoy in downtown Evansville Indiana. Walking distance to arts district , bars , restaurants, casino , ford center , Evansville museum, Evansville riverfront and much more.,, Home was built in 1915 as a mansion by the Nugent family. No lifeguard on duty, swim at your own risk