Vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favorite
A well-maintained cottage is set against a backdrop of trees, featuring a distinctive sign displaying 'Kisner's Kottage'. A pathway leads to the entrance, flanked by a grassy area. A lamp post stands beside the entryway, softly illuminating the surroundings.
Cottage in Duncannon
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 91 reviews

Kisner's Kottage

Waterfront on the Sherman's Creek at the confluence to the Susquehanna River and directly on the Appalacian Trail - Take it easy at this unique and tranquil cottage in the quaint town of Duncannon, PA. Close to Hershey Park, Harrisburg, PA Farm Show Complex, Carlisle, Carlisle Fairgrounds, Lancaster, and Gettysburg! Take a trip into Pennyslvania's Capitol City or spend time in nature hiking to Hawk Rock on the Appalachian Trail or kayaking on the Sherman's Creek. Your options are unlimited!

Guest favorite
The interior of the cabin features wooden walls and a cozy layout. A full-sized bed is positioned in the foreground. A plush, round ottoman is visible near a workstation, which includes a coffee maker and refrigerator. Light filters in through large windows, illuminating the space.
Cabin in Richfield
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Rustic Escape in the Woods

Nestled in the picturesque hills of Juniata County, The Green Tree Grove offers a tranquil cabin retreat. This cozy studio cabin boasts a full-sized bed and futon. kitchenette provides a water dispenser, microwave, fridge, and Keurig coffee maker. a propane grill is on the covered porch No water Outdoor shower Outhouse bring water towels soap cookware utensils plates cups paper towels

Guest favorite
The cabin features a charming exterior with a green metal roof and wooden accents. A welcoming porch offers seating for relaxation, surrounded by lush forest. Soft lighting enhances the cabin's warm presence, while a gravel driveway provides access.
Cabin in Millerstown
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

Cozy Cabin in a Private Wooded Hollow

Welcome to Hidden Hollow Cabin! Nestled in a private, wooded hollow, nature abounds in this forest retreat. Surrounded by ferns, pines and endless woodland views, escape to your own cabin getaway. Soak up nature as you sip your morning coffee on the deck, or relax around a crackling fire as the stars start to appear. Easily accessible & only minutes off of Route 322 in Millerstown. Within a mile of Sweet Water Springs Wedding Venue. For more of our story, find us on insta @hiddenhollowcabin

Top guest favorite
A serene landscape is showcased with a winding path leading through lush greenery beside a calm river. In the distance, a large hill rises, providing a backdrop to the flowing water, while a stone arch bridge can be seen spanning the river.
Home in Harrisburg
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Fort Hunter Charm!

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil waterfront getaway. Enjoy lovely historic Fort Hunter Mansion and Park, just a short walk away with a beautiful view of the Rockville Bridge, the worlds longest stone arch bridge along the Susquehanna River ! You will be just a few hundred yards away from the Fort Hunter boat launch where fisherman from all over come to enjoy the muskie and walleye fishing. The Pennsylvania Farm Show Complex is just 6 minutes away! Hershey Park 20 minutes, Carlisle 20!

Guest favorite
The exterior of a spacious house is visible, featuring a stone façade and a large garage. A well-maintained yard includes colorful flowering bushes and green grass, with a concrete walkway leading to the front entrance. Window details highlight the welcoming atmosphere.
Guest suite in Harrisburg
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 616 reviews

Hill View Home

This is a spacious downstairs apartment in a beautiful newer house in a quiet neighborhood. The apartment has private entrance and a yard. There are two bedrooms. If your party has more than two people, or if you need two separate beds, there is an additional $20 charge for the second bedroom per night. The house is located close to I-81 and highway 322 less than 10 minutes drive from the state capitol and the beautiful Susquehanna river and 25 minutes from Harrisburg International Airport.

Guest favorite
The historic 'Carpets and Draperies' building, originally built in 1922, features a modern exterior with large windows and a welcoming entrance. The iconic marquee sign is illuminated, highlighting the building's architectural details.
Apartment in Midtown
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Updated Apt in Historic Building—Free Parking!

Modern Midtown Retreat: Discover our cozy 1-bed apartment, the perfect home base for exploring Hershey and Harrisburg. Located in Midtown, Harrisburg’s coolest neighborhood, you’re within walking distance of Downtown, the State Capitol, breweries, and more. Situated in the historic “Carpets and Draperies” building, originally Gerber’s Department Store (1922), this fully restored unit offers modern comforts, including free off-street parking, a fully stocked kitchen, and in-unit laundry.

Guest favorite
A bright office space features a modern desk and a comfortable chair. A large black and white photograph adorns the wall, while a red decorative pillow adds a pop of color to the chair. A decorative rug and potted plant enhance the inviting atmosphere.
Apartment in Midtown
4.82 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Newly Remodeled Midtown Apartment

Newly renovated Boho style apartment in the heart of Midtown. This cute and comfy apartment finds itself within walking distance to all Harrisburg has to offer. Including Midtown Cinema, Front Street’s walking path with a river view, City Island ball field and recreation, PA State Museum, the Capital, the new Federal Courthouse, Midtown Market, and unique places to eat, drink, and socialize. This special place is a short drive to Hershey, Gettysburg and other tourist attractions.

Top guest favorite
A modern living area is furnished with a light-colored sectional sofa and stylish accent chairs. A round coffee table sits at the center, complemented by a textured area rug. The space features a mix of warm wood and neutral tones, with artistic wall decor enhancing the setting.
Home in Midtown
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 592 reviews

Modern, Fashionable Uptown Harrisburg home

Modern and fabulously decorated single family, brick row home in the "Olde Uptown" neighborhood of Harrisburg. Personal touches are found throughout with complimentary snacks and beverages, continental breakfast, incredibly comfortable beds, and professionally designed interior decor. You can walk to the fantastic Broad Street Market, local cafes and coffee, and the beautiful riverfront trail. One dedicated off-street parking spot is assigned to the home so parking is a breeze.

Guest favorite
A cozy room features exposed brick walls, adding character to the space. A large television is mounted above an ornate fireplace, while a small desk and a chair provide a workspace. Natural light enters through the large windows, dressed with elegant shades.
Apartment in Downtown Harrisburg
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 447 reviews

Harvest Moon Suite @ Walnut Place

Entire apartment in the heart of Downtown Harrisburg central business district. The unit overlooks capitol park. Access to a shared private courtyard. Neighboring buildings include Strawberry Square/Hilton, Gamut Theatre, Harrisburg University, Temple University PA Chamber of Business, Rachel Carson building. Very safe location. **Strictly non-smoking inside the building. A $500 fee will be applied for any violations.** Detailed parking information can be found in the photos.

Top guest favorite
The ranch-style home features a welcoming front porch with three chairs, surrounded by a neatly maintained lawn. The driveway leads to a gravel path and two garages. Lush greenery and trees provide a serene backdrop to the property, enhancing the secluded atmosphere.
Home in Halifax
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 196 reviews

Peaceful Getaway, with hot tub & fire pit.

Escape to Peaceful Getaway, where cozy comfort meets countryside charm. Nestled among the trees, this home invites you to slow down and enjoy life’s simple moments. Sip morning coffee on the deck as birds sing, spend the day exploring Lake Tobias or hiking the Appalachian Trail, then unwind in the hot tub or make s’mores by the fire pit under the stars. Whether for a romantic escape or family adventure, Peaceful Getaway offers the perfect blend of relaxation and connection.

Top guest favorite
A spacious bed with white bedding is positioned against a pale green wall. A framed artwork featuring a butterfly collection is displayed nearby. A wooden nightstand holds a lamp and essentials, complementing the serene atmosphere of the room.
Guest suite in Carlisle
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 1,064 reviews

Pup Friendly Private Space

Welcome, I am Debbie a busy Mama/Grandma with a bunch of millennial children (plus five grandchildren and 5 granddogs). I am excited to be able to offer my beautifully designed space close to Dickinson, the War College, Carlisle Fairgrounds, Appalachian Trail, Harrisburg and Gettysburg. You have your own off-street parking, private entrance and a large bedroom/sitting room with full private bathroom and a microwave/ mini-refrigerator for your convenience.

Top guest favorite
A cozy living room features a modern couch with decorative cushions, a coffee table with plants, and a flat-screen TV mounted beside a fireplace. Natural light enters through large windows, illuminating warm wooden flooring and light-colored walls.
Apartment in Midtown
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 288 reviews

Unique Private Balcony and Fireplace in Midtown

Newly renovated and fully stocked! Enjoy a "city" sunset from the 1920's gazebo-style balcony. Relax in front of the fireplace while enjoying comfortable modern amenities. ✔ Off-street parking ✔ Under 30 minutes to Hershey and Carlisle ✔ Walking distance to riverfront, shops, restaurants and bars ✔ Minutes to the Farm Show Complex, downtown and the Capitol ✔ Under 1 hour to Lancaster and Gettysburg ✔ Premium cable, Netflix, HBO Max & Disney Plus

Popular amenities for New Buffalo vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Pennsylvania
  4. Perry County
  5. New Buffalo