Vacation rentals in New Bethlehem

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Bethlehem

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favorite
Home in New Bethlehem
5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Redbank Retreat • Waterfront • Hot Tub • Fire Pit

Redbank Creek Retreat is a newly renovated, creek-front escape featuring a hot tub, fire pit, room for up to 8. Savor peaceful mornings by the water, kayak or fish. It's just a short walk to hike, bike & explore the scenic Redbank Valley Trail. Two beautifully designed units in one stay offering comfort, style, and space to unwind. Located just 25 mi. from Cook Forest, it’s your cozy home base for adventure, special gatherings, or small-town exploring. Perfect for families, couples, or friends.

Top guest favorite
Home in New Bethlehem
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Countryside Comfort/ Spacious Home in Small Town.

Escape to Gaston's Getaway, a peaceful hilltop retreat just an hour north of Pittsburgh. This family home has been lovingly updated for guests with a king suite and luxurious master bath. Enjoy your morning coffee and amazing sunrises on the handcrafted porch. *Just added new 58" Roku TV on the porch for outdoor movies! * Perfect for families, couples or group getaways seeking small town charm with modern comfort. This 3 bed/2 bath home sleeps 8 with 2 kings, 1 full and full size air bed.

Top guest favorite
Apartment in Summerville
5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

The Henderson House - Apartment B

The Henderson House is located in the heart of Summerville, PA. Come to relax in a comfortable, cozy & clean 2nd floor two-bedroom apartment with many amenities in & around Summerville. Very short walking distance to the Redbank Valley Trail to enjoy biking, walking & cross country skiing. Redbank Creek to enjoy fishing, canoeing & kayaking. 13 miles from New Bethlehem, 8 miles from Brookville, 24 miles from Cook Forest State Park, 19 miles from Punxsutawney & 16 miles from Clarion.

Guest favorite
The modern kitchen features a large central island with a wooden countertop. White cabinetry contrasts with the rustic wood paneling on one wall. Appliances include a refrigerator and a stove, while ample natural light enters through a window dressed with dark curtains.
Home in Shippenville
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

Route 66 Rails to Trails Home

Welcome to a freshly remodeled family (and dog friendly) home that accommodates a large family on a budget! Conveniently located just outside of Clarion. Only a short drive away from Cooks Forest, within eyesight of Route 66 bike trail, and a 5.5 mile drive to the nearest Clarion River boat launch. This home has all the modern conveniences of your home, with a fully equipped kitchen, an outdoor fire pit with a spacious backyard, and lots of room to spread out, relax, and enjoy your stay!

Top guest favorite
A serene view features a small pond reflecting the pastel colors of sunset. In the background, a wooden structure is nestled among rolling hills, framed by trees in bloom. The landscape showcases a peaceful rural setting, enhancing the natural beauty of the area.
Home in Summerville
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Peaceful Country Home with Hot Tub

Beautifully maintained country home overlooking rolling hills with a natural landscape perfect for Leafers this coming season! Property is close to Summerville, Brookville, Punxsutawney & New Bethlehem. Conveniently located amongst many PA state game lands, the rails to trails & great kayaking & canoeing areas for outdoor fun. Walking paths along creeks and rivers just minutes from the home. Large backyard with hot tub for entertaining. Fire pit located on site as well as outdoor seating.

Top guest favorite
A well-lit living area features a comfortable gray sofa and an armchair, accompanied by a coffee table with magazines. A dining table with four chairs is nearby. In the background, a doorway leads to the bedroom, while wall art adds a touch of decor.
Apartment in New Bethlehem
5 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Inn-1 New Bethlehem Town Center

The updated historic 1915 building boasts a spacious 1 BR with individually controlled heat and AC and full kitchen. It is centrally located in New Bethlehem, PA fronting on the midpoint of the 51-mile Redbank Valley Trail just 65 miles from Pittsburgh via SR 28/66, 16 miles from I-80 Clarion exit 64, 18 miles from I-80 exit 78 in Brookville, walkable to many restaurants, with secure bike storage available and free parking on site. Self-service breakfast options are offered.

Top guest favorite
A private deck features a hot tub surrounded by wooden decking and a wicker-egg chair. String lights above provide a soft glow, enhancing the expansive views of the surrounding landscape at sunset.
Cabin in Brookville
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 198 reviews

Skyline Serenity (Hot Tub, Panorama, King Bed)

Welcome to Skyline Serenity, where heaven meets earth. This brand-new cabin was constructed on the side of Heartwood Mountain, overlooking the Pennsylvania forests for miles and miles. Huge panoramic windows open your eyes to gorgeous views every morning and evening, creating a peaceful environment for you to completely relax as you enjoy your stay. -Hot tub -Beautiful views! -Soaking tub -Fire pit (firewood provided) -Private deck -Laundry room -Great hiking nearby!

Top guest favorite
A charming guest house with dark brown siding is surrounded by autumn foliage. Large glass doors create an inviting entrance, while two outdoor chairs are positioned on the lawn nearby, offering a serene space to relax in nature.
Tiny home in Brookville
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

Guest House

The guest house is a 20 x 16 ft. studio which sits on 115 acres of woods and fields with great views just outside Brookville. It is approximately 20 yards from the main house and equipped with a queen bed, a sofa, full bath with walk in shower, and small refrigerator, toaster oven, microvave, and TV. The property has multiple walking trails and is situated approximately 5 miles from Route 80. It is also close to Cook's Forest, the Clarion River, and Punxsutawney.

Guest favorite
A classic RV is parked on a gravel area, accompanied by a wooden picnic table. Lush greenery and trees surround the space, while a blue sky filled with clouds creates a bright and open atmosphere.
Camper/RV in Templeton
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

Delightful 32ft Winnebago with two beds in country

Short on time?  Don't feel like spending half of your free time setting up camp? 32 foot Winnebago already set up and leveled so you can go straight to exploring the area. Come enjoy camping, hiking, boating, fishing, swimming and much more at this site nestled amongst game lands #287 and the Allegheny river. 2000 acres of game land to explore, half mile from the Erie to Pittsburgh bike trails. Stay for hunting season or launch your boat onto the Allegheny river.

Guest favorite
Home in New Bethlehem
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Remember When

Welcome to our historic, 1920’s era, charming, two-story, 3 bedroom, 2 bath home, located in the quintessential, small town of New Bethlehem, PA. Here in “New B,” small-town festivals and Friday night high school football games are just a part of our DNA. Our home is just seconds from Redbank Valley bicycle trail, and within walking distance to downtown shops and restaurants, as well as fishing in the Redbank Creek.

Top guest favorite
The open living area showcases rustic wooden beams and warm wood paneling. A dining table with checkered cloth is positioned near the kitchen, while a comfortable seating area with a dark leather sofa and side tables is visible. A stone fireplace adds to the cozy ambiance.
Cabin in Limestone Township
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 67 reviews

Timeless Trails Main Cabin

This cabin sits on a 95 acre property which is part of Timeless Trails Campground. The cabin is set off in a private location at the campground, making it a haven for relaxing, unwinding, and spending quality time with others. Guests have access to miles of maintained trails as well as the catch-and-release fishing pond, bikes for trail riding, and other common amenities such as a playground, pavilion and bathhouse.

Top guest favorite
A charming yellow facade of a two-story house is framed by a welcoming porch. Green plants hang from the railing, and blooming flowers line the curved pathway leading to the entrance. Sunlight highlights the well-maintained yard and serene landscaping.
Apartment in Knox
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Cozy quiet retreat

We live upstairs in a contemporary style house built in 2000 1 new Queen sized bed Queen sized air mattress if needed upon request We will have some small snacks and drinks provided for you upon arrival . The kitchen is fully stocked with anything for your cooking or baking needs. We are a quiet living family but as we are upstairs there may be some noise. However we go to bed early 😊

Popular amenities for New Bethlehem vacation rentals