Vacation rentals in Middlebury Center

The house was really spacious and very sound proof. We had two babies with us that never heard eachother crying. It was clean and we had no worries about the babies getting into anything with all the sliding doors between rooms. It was exactly what we were looking for and Denise was the perfect host.

Beautiful home in a peaceful, private location. We were so comfortable and felt right at home! The large open concept kitchen and living room were perfect for family cooking and visiting. Incredibly comfortable reclining couches in the living room. We really enjoyed sitting out on the deck in the evening, in the screened in gazebo. Perfect Airbnb for a fall get away! Thank you so much for sharing your home, Tammy and Guy!

This cabin was awesome! Main reason is location. Many cabins are too close to highway for good nights rest. We have stayed in some with no rest that night. This was best nights of sleep in Tioga ever. Thank you. we will return!

Dustin’s place was very clean, just as the description said. A great place to stay if you’re in the Wellsville area.

Had a last-minute business trip to Watkins Glen, and all of the decent hotels had limited availability. This place was perfect. We found a restaurant right down the street and ate there both nights. Dunkin Donuts was almost directly across the street, so we didn't even bother with the coffee maker in the morning. Hot tub was a nice bonus on the 2nd night!

Two senior brothers who appreciate the outdoors and God's nature selected Stacy and Tim's cabin for our annual spring fly fishing and photography trip destination. We hit a home run by selecting their cabin overlooking Beaver Lake and located adjacent to some of PA's finest state parks, streams and forests. The cabin's quality, comfort, cleanliness, unique architecture, and furnishings are exceptional in all regards that exceeded our expectations. Stacy's communications, support and responsive email replies were excellent. Very early morning coffee on the deck with fog on the lake highlighted by turkey gobbles was fantastic. Thanks Stacy and Tim for sharing your awesome retreat. Looking forward to being back, your place is truly the best.

This house was perfect for our needs. We had a wedding to attend, so we split the cost with family. Much better than staying at a hotel! I also loved being able to kayak! It was also stocked with just about anything you would need. If we were staying longer, and needed to make meals, we would not have needed anything. It was all in this house!

A lovely, quiet getaway spot for humans and dogs alike. The sunroom was amazing and the view out of the back was 180 degrees of green fields and an expansive Mountain View. My dogs just stared out the windows like it was “Petflix”. We were about 10-15 mins away from Ithaca, but on the way there was Robert Truman State Park and Buttermilk Falls, plus Ithaca Beer Co and South Hill Cidery. I would highly recommend all of those locations!

Agree with other reviewers - better on the inside than outside. Clean, comfortable. Just down the street from the main site with multiple cabins, the office, and direct creek access. Will consider staying at one of those cabins next time.