Vacation rentals in Lyndonville

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Lyndonville

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favorite
The spacious kitchen features modern stainless-steel appliances, including a refrigerator and oven. Ample cabinetry and a large countertop provide plenty of space for meal preparation. A window allows natural light to brighten the area, highlighting the rich wood flooring.
Home in Waterport
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Beautiful Home Minutes From Lake Ontario fishing

Freshly remodeled, fully furnished, four bedroom home in a country setting close to Lake Ontario's famed fishing locations. Two story, open floor plan. First floor Kitchen, living room, dining room, bathroom, three bedrooms. One bedroom upstairs. Private large country yard. Only minutes away from Lake Ontario, Lake Alice, and the Oak Orchard River. Great for fishing, boating, kayaking, leisure. Ring video security sys. We are located half way between Rochester and Buffalo/Niagara Falls.

Guest favorite
The kitchen features wooden cabinetry and a spacious dining table surrounded by six wooden chairs. Natural light enters through a glass door, while a colorful light fixture hangs above the table, adding a warm touch. A modern gas stove and a laundry area are also visible.
Home in Medina
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Modern, Amish-Built Farmhouse, 3 bedrooms sleeps 6

Experience rural living in this exquisite 3-bedroom Amish-built home, with custom craftmanship, beautiful woodwork and Amish-built furniture. Perfect for a quiet getaway with gorgeous views of woods, meadows, & farmland, a few miles from restaurants & local attractions. Outdoor enthusiasts: minutes from kayak launches, fishing, apple picking, nature trails, & more. Cozy fireplaces, 3 bedrooms w/ walkout basement for easy access + room to stretch out. Porch + deck to enjoy sunrise + sunset!

Top guest favorite
A spacious living area features a cozy sectional sofa and a plush white couch, complemented by a decorative rug. Natural light streams in through skylights and windows, highlighting a modern electric fireplace beneath a simple mantel.
Home in Albion
5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Lakefront property

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. This place is a gem you don't want to miss! Very spacious, comfortable and peaceful. You have your own dock to fish off of, go kayaking or pedal boating. at night relax on a very large porch or roast some marshmallows by the firepit. Close by there are farms you can pick your own fruits/veggies and can shop at local and Amish markets. Only 15 min away is Medina, a charming town with unique attractions to visit. This is the place you want to be!

Top guest favorite
Home in Waterport
5 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Quiet cottage

Unwind in this calm, stylish home. Perfect for solo travelers, couples, and small families. Cozy, modern, functional spaces for all to enjoy. This cottage is newly renovated and upgraded with numerous amenities. Tucked away property with a number of interior accommodations. Located in a private, tranquil area with lots of outdoor space and privacy. Close proximity to Lakeside State Park and local fishing marinas. Reasonable distance from prime locations including Lake Ontario and Point Breeze.

Guest favorite
An open-concept living space features a large sectional sofa in black leather, accented with red pillows. A rectangular dining table is set for six. Light wood flooring complements a patterned area rug, while large glass doors invite natural light and offer access to the outdoors.
Home in Gasport
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

Elegant Country Retreat

This Sprawling Country getaway , open floor concept for the entire family . Spend time outside at the Beautiful Gazebo savoring the peace and quiet of the rustic setting. Minute away from Famed Becker Farms and Vizcarra Vineyards. Take a relaxing and informative boat ride on the Erie Canal Cruises in nearby Lockport NY or walk across the street and take a Stoll down the Historic canal on foot. 4 bedroom and 2 full baths there is plenty of space for the whole family to make lasting memories.

Guest favorite
A serene view of a cottage nestled among trees along a calm shoreline. The still water mirrors the blue sky and lush greenery, creating a peaceful atmosphere. The stone waterfront leads to vibrant landscaping surrounding the home.
Home in Lyndonville
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

North Star Cottage

Immerse yourself in nature at this rustic getaway just steps from Lake Ontario. Centrally located between Buffalo, NF, and Rochester, this beautiful cottage offers panoramic views of sunrises and sunsets! Enjoy the spectacular night skies with no light pollution and breathtaking views of Lake Ontario’s stunning blue waters! Gourmet kitchen, newly renovated bathroom, and open floor plan! Master bedroom has panoramic views of the lake! Cottage was featured in Buffalo Spree Magazine Nov. 2023

Guest favorite
A wooden cabin is nestled among bare trees, showcasing a wrap-around porch that offers a view of the surrounding landscape. The scene reflects a winter setting with patches of snow visible on the ground, complemented by the muted tones of the forest.
Cabin in Waterport
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

The Cabin on Oak Orchard River

Rustic secluded lodging on Oak Orchard River, a 1/2 mile from the dam and world class fishing. This unit is nestled in the woods on the river bank and has 4 single beds in two bedrooms. The wrap around porch on the river edge makes you feel like you're right on the River. This unit has A/C, WiFi, microwave, no stove, refrigerator, TV, Keurig and drip coffee machine (bring your own coffee). Our units are basic accommodations used primarily seasonally by avid fishermen but all are welcome.

Top guest favorite
A charming cottage is set against a backdrop of lush green grass and trees. The outdoor deck features white lounge chairs and a large umbrella. Light filters through the trees, enhancing the cozy and inviting appearance of the home.
Home in Lyndonville
5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Megaritaville

A charming waterfront cottage , the perfect place to relax. Located near the Niagara wine trail. Perfect for a ladies retreat. Very close to spectacular charter fishing and the world’s famous Oak Orchard river, a fly fisherman’s paradise. Situated near the historic Erie Canal and the historic town of Medina. 50 minutes from Niagara Falls.The cottage is equipped with outdoor games, a fire pit, two bicycles and an outdoor deck and furniture. Let the sounds of the waves calm your soul.

Guest favorite
A charming blue cottage is set amidst a lush green lawn, bordered by a stone arrangement. An outdoor seating area with a picnic table is visible, along with a fire pit surrounded by logs. Nearby trees offer shade and natural beauty, with the waterfront visible in the background.
Cottage in Lyndonville
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Cozy water front cottage

Relax with family or friends at this peaceful place to stay. Enjoy a 480sqf. Studio cottage on Lake Ontario. The cottage consists of an outdoor area, a queen size bed, a pull-out sofa, a 40inch TV, dining area, full bathroom, and a kitchen. Enjoy the view, a nice swim, have a fire, or use the grill. You can bring yard games to play in the yard, or there is a small natural boat ramp to put in your own kayaks or canoes. There are friendly dogs free roaming the area.

Top guest favorite
A serene sunset view is captured over the lake, with the sun casting a golden glow on the water. The image features the edge of a spa tub in the foreground, with gentle ripples of water visible. A blue chair is positioned nearby, inviting relaxation.
Cottage in Barker
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Lake Front Vista & HotTub

Enjoy Spectacular Lakefront views. Relax at your own pace. Take a dip in the spa tub or just enjoy the scenery Very quiet road Speedy internet Fire-pit Enjoy the Niagara Wine Trail 2 Bdrm 6 min to Golden Hill Park 12 min to White Birch Golf course 15 min to Olcott/Burt (fishing charters) 20 min to Waterport/Kent (fishing charters) 50 min to Niagara Falls *Promo: 3rd night or more, will be discounted ~25% (no discount on cleaning and fees, excl 06/23-09/10)

Top guest favorite
A cozy living area is featured, showcasing a plush sectional sofa and a wooden coffee table. Two vintage oars are mounted on the wall, enhancing the rustic charm. A stand lamp and a small wooden chair complement the space, which is illuminated by natural light through nearby windows.
Apartment in Albion
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 187 reviews

Lagom Living Not too little ~ Not too Much

Our Airbnb is an entire two-bedroom apartment in an 1800s home in Albion, NY. You’ll have plenty of room to settle in and stretch out here. We can sleep five people in one queen, one double bed and a couch. The comfortable living room is stocked with board games and our full kitchen has all the appliances and kitchenware you need to make your own meals. With onsite parking, a private entrance, and washer and dryer, you can really make yourself at home.

Guest favorite
The exterior of a vibrant blue house is framed by lush green trees, with a well-maintained lawn leading towards the lake. A spacious deck is visible, adjacent to the water, providing a serene setting for relaxation and outdoor activities.
Cottage in Albion
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 238 reviews

Lake Front: Beautiful Cottage on Lake Alice

Lake front designer gem has Main House, Boat House and Bath House. Boat House is an additional fee and offered seasonally : see details below. Gourmet kitchen, rock fireplace, expansive deck, stairs to lake with dock, swim platform, fire ring, beach chairs, 4 kayaks and a canoe for your use. Just a day trip away to Niagra Falls or Toronto and 5 min to Oak Orchard River which hosts World Class Fishing.

Popular amenities for Lyndonville vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Orleans County
  5. Lyndonville