Boutique hotel vacation rentals in Lake Ontario

For the location, comfort, walkability, availability, utility and John's responsiveness, safe-accommodations and value/price...almost unbelievable & unbeatable! If you need a place to crash or you need to stay comfortably for some time (i.e. weeks) in Rochester, this is going to be one of, if not, your top option. For multiple people (more than two), it would be a little close quarters to stay more than a few days--like if you will have any others over or stopping by. For my purposes, being in town for two nights for a sporting event, John's place was 100% perfect! Gave me the feeling that my college dorm room (which I loved and re-requested multiple years) had been upgraded to a way better adult format! And with a very nice, immaculate bathroom, retro-design little refrigerator and everything I needed/wanted. Side note: Walk to Ugly Duck Coffee for the best in-town experience!! (Though there is good coffee & maker in the room.)

Great place to stay, responsive host. Made a request to extend my stay for a day and they were very accommodating. Highly recommended.

Cozy little place that was perfect for my one night in Rochester. Close to a lot of night life, I will need to plan ahead next time and explore!

We were in town for my daughter’s wedding. We rented the entire Inn and had plenty of room for our large family to spend time together. Had everything we needed to prepare meals while we were there. I would not hesitate to stay here again. We really appreciated being able to check in a little early too.

Great place; perfect location!

Great spot in Niagara area with clean, comfortable rooms, nice walkability to the river, and friendly staff. Would definitely stay here again!

This was a great place to stay for our getaway. We visited the Badlands and Belfountain Conservation area both of which were close by. We wished we had planned to stay for longer as there are more beautiful conservation areas to see and also a sunflower farm. The Room (Badlands Suite) is on top of the General Store. It is a beautiful historic building. There was a window air conditioner in our room so we were very comfortable. The bed was great. The woman running the store downstairs was super friendly and helpful. There is a nice patio out back and chairs by the river for relaxing. We will come again for sure. Thank you Glen!

Loved the location am fan of Best westerns so this signature addition was awesome

We had a truly wonderful stay at this charming Airbnb in Wellington, Prince Edward County. The space was cozy, stylish, and thoughtfully put together—perfect for a relaxing getaway. Our host was incredibly welcoming and kind, making us feel right at home. Don’t miss Cliffside Cafe just below the suites—it's an absolute gem!

Cozy room in a great location next to bars, shops, and restaurants. It was really easy to drive to the local wineries and it was a quick drive to hiking spots too.

We stayed in a room at 16 Elm for our anniversary. The room and house were exactly as described - beautiful, clean, and quiet. The location was great, perfect for walking to get a cup of coffee in the morning. It was convenient to the wineries, Taughannock Falls, and Ithaca. We took advantage of many of Jes' suggestions for things to do and places to eat. We would definitely come back here and highly recommend 16 Elm to anyone looking for a romantic retreat in the beautiful Finger Lakes!

Lovely place, comfortable and stylish, love their environmental ethic! They accommodated my late check no problem.

My daughter and I enjoyed our girls' trip to NOTL in the Lillibet suite. The host provided clear instructions and check in was a breeze. Sleeps 2 so comfortably. She had all the little amenities there to make one feel right at home, including kitchen essentials, slippers, and bathroom supplies such as makeup wipes and toothbrushes! I've never stayed in such a well thought out air bnb. We enjoyed the Irish pub downstairs for its live music. Everything is close by. thank you, we will come back soon.