Vacation rentals in Lake Montauk

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Montauk Private Beach Bungalow

Beautiful secluded cottage tucked away at the end of cul-de-sac and surrounded by a nature preserve. Montauk’s finest waterfront dining and bars are less than a mile. The house has a large living room with a fireplace, king bed in one and a full bed with a twin in the other, a full bath, outdoor shower hot & cold, an eat-in kitchen. There is a large very private patio with a grill, dining table and lounge area. The private beach is stunning and a 3 minute walk from the house. Pets are welcome.

Superhost

A bright sitting area features a white shiplap ceiling with exposed beams. A light-colored sofa is adorned with decorative pillows, positioned near a coffee table. A telescope is placed by a window, offering views of the lush outdoor greenery visible through the glass doors.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Ditch Plains/ Chic ocean view beach retreat

Private magical 2 acre surf retreat a five min walk to the famed Ditch Plains beach. Nestled on a private road in the best area, this newly renovated airy 3 bedroom, 3 bath has luxurious lawns, sprawling nature, and stylish lounging areas indoors and out. Wolf & Bosch luxury appliances. Tasteful furnishings and linens. Listen to the waves and enjoy sunsets and ocean & lake views from several patios and balconies. Plus Weber BBQ, wi-fi. central A/C & heat, charming outdoor dining area & fire pit.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Montauk Surf Cabin with Deck on a Nature Preserve

Relax and enjoy the best Montauk has to offer at this peaceful, comfortable, and stylish cabin. With 4 BR and 2 BA (one en suite in the primary), everyone has space and comfort in this gem of a home. Out back, overlooking the nature preserve, you'll find a large deck with lounge seating, a huge dining table and an ice plunge and sauna. Only about a mile from Ditch, Town and the Dock, at the end of a private gravel road, this unique space is the perfect location for you and your friends or fam.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 76 reviews

A cozy bedroom features warm wood paneling and a spacious bed adorned with a colorful quilt. A vintage acoustic guitar hangs on the wall, complementing the inviting decor. Natural light filters through the window, illuminating the brick fireplace and enhancing the room's charm.

Vacation home in Montauk

Private Entrance to Duplex Apartment on Lush Acres

Private Exterior Entrance to QUEEN BED bedroom and private bath ONE FLIGHT OF STAIRS UP. 1 mile to Ditch, half mile to L.I. Sound. Quiet, Out-of-the-way 1900s house on Several Acres. 100% non-smoking both inside and out. Friendly DOGS WELCOME provided they do not chew, scratch, bark when left alone, are picked up after outside and are kept OFF furniture. NO UN-HOUSEBROKEN PUPPIES. WE ACCEPT DOGS ONLY. NO CATS OR OTHER PETS. NO EXCEPTIONS. Friendly Dogs & Chickens live on property. 2 NIGHT MIN

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

An open living area features a comfortable sectional sofa and a large area rug, with natural light streaming through multiple windows. A dining table is visible, accompanied by stools, and the kitchen area includes modern appliances and a view into the outdoor patio space.

Apartment in Montauk

Modern Montauk retreat with wood stove by Harbor

Scandinavia meets Montauk in this sophisticated, comfy, all-season getaway. • 950 sq ft, 2 BR, 1 bath, high-end kitchen, W/D, A/C • Wood stove, Solo stove, patio, outdoor shower, high-end linens, furnishings & decor, large private fenced yard • Steps to LI Sound & Harbor. 3 mi to ocean/Town • Owner is in a private space w/ own entrance in the house. No shared spaces! • Note: Nightly rates now include Airbnb guest fee • Ask about dogs & flexible rental periods CLICK "MORE" for IMPORTANT INFO!

An open living space is highlighted by large glass doors that offer views of the lake. A cozy seating area is complemented by a stone fireplace and contemporary decor. Natural light fills the room, enhancing the inviting atmosphere amidst greenery just outside.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 94 reviews

A Gorgeous Fall: Private Beach, Fireplace, Hikes

Enjoy your own private beach, large deck with amazing sunset views, Kayaks, SUPs, bikes and long summer days on Lake Montauk. Our beach front midcentury house has views from every angle. Swim in the lake or take a short bike ride to Gin Beach for sunset. Make fabulous feasts in our chef's kitchen and eat at the large outdoor table. Note: From mid-June through Labor Day: our rentals are 7-day periods from Saturday-Saturday. in May-mid June, we have a 3-night minimum.

Superhost

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Sea Ranch At Ditch Plains - Welcome To The Beach

Wake Up To Your Own Private Sea Ranch Retreat — Inspired by the California coastal design belief that human life should live harmoniously with the natural elements of the land & sea. With that we've crafted the perfect hideaway for anyone (you, your friends, the family) to relax / unplug / & enjoy a much needed escape to The End in a space designed to recharge. 4 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, 2 Streets Off Ditch Plains Beach - what more could you need!

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

An inviting living area is presented, featuring a white brick fireplace as a focal point. Comfortable seating includes light-colored sofas adorned with varying throw pillows. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, and double doors lead to the outdoor area.

Vacation home in Montauk

2 BR apartment near ocean in Hither Hills

Relax and enjoy a peaceful stay that is a 3 block walk to one of the most beautiful ocean beaches in the Hamptons! This apartment is located in a beautiful, wooded, quiet neighborhood. Town is 1.5 miles away. This apartment has an open concept living space with a fully equipped kitchen. There are 2 cozy bedrooms and one bath with a walk in shower. We prefer families and mature adults. We supply beach towels, chairs, umbrella and beach wagon.

The exterior of a contemporary home is presented, featuring a well-maintained lawn with a fire pit surrounded by several outdoor chairs. A hot tub is visible on the side, set against a backdrop of lush greenery and a clear blue sky.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

Stylish Montauk Village Escape for Any Season

Stylish Montauk retreat with 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and 2 half baths. Just minutes from beaches, shops, and restaurants. Soak in the hot tub, gather around the fire pit, or savor breathtaking sunsets from the private deck. Modern interiors, central air, and Wi-Fi make it cozy year-round. Spacious, elegant, and inviting, perfect for families, friends, or romantic escapes seeking comfort, luxury, and ultimate Montauk getaway!

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

An outdoor dining area is located beneath a wooden pergola, surrounded by a spacious lawn. A stone patio features a table with blue metal chairs. Lush greenery is visible in the background, along with a cottage painted in muted colors, accented by vibrant flowering bushes.

Cottage in Montauk

Secluded 1Br cottage on the lake, close to Ditch

This is the best of Montauk living, right by the lake, close to Ditch, and with an incredible, lush front yard suitable for outside dining or having a couple friends over for dinner. Walk down to the lake to enjoy the sunset, or stroll over to the Crow's Nest for drinks or dinner. No need to drive, it's well within walking distance. Join the many that have experienced the magic of our cottage at South Lake.

A bright kitchenette features modern cabinetry and a stainless-steel sink. Adjacent, a dining area with two chairs faces a spacious living room, highlighted by large windows allowing natural light and showcasing a comfortable sofa and wall-mounted TV.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Dockside 2BR - Marina - Dining - Charter Access Un

Any closer to the marina and you’d be swimming in the Atlantic. Our sweet little cottage sits right on Westlake Marina. From your front door, you can book a charter, grab a bowl of Westlake Fish House’s famous clam chowder, or walk to Gosman’s for a sundae and a sunset. Inside enjoy heated floors, plush beds, and a fully-equipped kitchen, making this a perfect place to land after all the Montauk fun.

A bright kitchen features a large island with wooden countertop and seating for three. Stainless steel appliances and open shelving provide ample storage, while large windows allow natural light to fill the space. French doors open to a deck area with views of the outdoors.