Hotel vacation rentals in Lake Montauk

Find and book unique hotel rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated hotel rentals in Lake Montauk

Guests agree: these hotel rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A waterfront view showcases a series of suites with large windows overlooking the water. A sun deck is visible, featuring lounge chairs and umbrellas for shade, with the shoreline and beach area just beyond.

Resort in Montauk

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews

Montauk Waterfront AtriumTwo-Room Suite

This deluxe two-room suite (main great-room with sleeping area, full kitchen and full bathroom) with attached atrium room (no sleeping available in atrium room) provides panoramic waterviews & spectacular sunsets. Heated pool, & free on-site parking. Located on Block Island Sound, walking distance from the harbor, a small beach, Gosman's dock, shopping, restaurants, bars, marinas, liquor store, deli, Block Island ferry parking, fishing charters, jet ski /boat rentals, and bicycle rentals.

Guest favorite

A welcoming entrance to a rental unit is highlighted by a vibrant blue door and contrasting dark gray exterior. A small outdoor seating area features a wooden table and two green chairs, providing a cozy space for relaxation amidst well-kept shrubbery.

Hotel room in Stonington

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Bright Updated Stonington Space

Enjoy a peaceful stay in this charming 1-room motel in Stonington, CT. This rental unit features a queen bed, private balcony, kitchenette with fridge, sink, and microwave, and a full bath. Stay cool with AC or relax outside in the shared grill area. Just minutes from downtown Mystic and downtown Westerly it's perfect for a quiet getaway. Whether you're here for business, weddings at nearby vineyards, or a longer stay, this renovated rental provides the perfect home base in Stonington, CT.

Superhost

A cozy room features a queen bed with white linens and multiple pillows. Beside the bed, two bedside lamps provide soft lighting. A TV is mounted on the wall above a dark wood dresser, which has multiple drawers for storage. Natural wood panels line the ceiling.

Hotel room in Madison

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Queen Room Cristy’s Madison #5

Smaller room with queen bed. Private bathroom, free cable/Roku, WiFi and beach access. We are a one minute walk from 2 beaches, and minutes from center of town, shopping and various weekly town events. Common area with coffee and water, downstairs is a full restaurant with breakfast, lunch and dinner. Maid service not provided. THIS ROOM IS LOCATED ABOVE A RESTAURANT AND BAR ON THE 2ND FLOOR, ACCESSIBLE BY STAIRS. THERE IS POTENTIAL FOR NOISE, ESPECIALLY ON THE WEEKENDS.

Superhost

A spacious bedroom is illuminated by natural light, featuring a large bed with a crisp white duvet and a decorative teal pillow. A minimalist design is complemented by light wood flooring and subtle wall art. An area for refreshments is visible in the background.

Hotel room in Hampton Bays

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Hampton Bays Hotel, King Suite - Adults Only

Hampton Bays Hotel on Main is a boutique hotel in the heart of town, featuring comfortable, affordable rooms above the Rod and Reel and Bub's Tavern. Enjoy a contactless stay with online check-in and secure smart locks with personalized access codes, designed to ensure guest privacy and convenience. Located close to beaches, dining, and nightlife, our hotel provides a high-quality experience at the center of it all, perfect for exploring the vibrant charm of the Hamptons.

Superhost

An expansive view of the ocean extends towards the horizon, with gentle waves lapping against the sandy shore. A clear blue sky is showcased above, enhancing the serene beach atmosphere.

Hotel room in Montauk

4.54 out of 5 average rating, 529 reviews

Ocean Front Resort Private decks Pool & Beach

The sun, the sand, and the surf meet at the Wavecrest Resort to offer a magical holiday to our guests. Studio rooms offer EITHER 2 Queen size beds OR 1 queen bed and a sleep sofa. All have a kitchen efficiency, Private deck and Ocean View. On site food truck for Breakfast, Lunch & Snacks, Media/ Game room available, Heated Pool, BBQ's, Beach bon fires, Complementary Beach Lounge Chairs and Umbrellas, Free Shuttle to town July thru Labor Day. Perfect Place to Relax!

Superhost

A private balcony is displayed with a wooden folding chair and a small side table. A bottle of water rests on the table, alongside a straw hat. The view overlooks the tranquil water, enhancing the outdoor space's inviting nature.

Hotel room in Greenport

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

Harborview King with Balcony at Greenport

Welcome to Harborfront Inn at Greenport Paying tribute to the waterfront boarding houses of the past, The Harborfront Inn rests in the heart—and soul—of historic Greenport Village. There’s plenty to explore in and around this quaint village surrounded by water and nature. When you stay with us, you’re part of the community and also enjoy exclusive access to the Private Beach, Pool and Restaurant at our sister property Sound View Greenport.

Superhost

A well-appointed room features a spacious bed with crisp white linens, flanked by modern nightstands with reading lamps. A large piece of artwork in calming hues hangs above the bed. Natural light brightens the hardwood floor, complemented by a minimalist dresser adorned with decorative elements.

Hotel room in Westhampton

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Three Ducks Hotel Westhampton

The new Three Ducks Hotel has just opened in Westhampton just in time for Summer 2025. We are launching the hotel on AirBnB first to create a buzz around this new chance to stay in the Hamptons for less. The hotel is one mile from Westhampton Village and two miles from Westhampton Beach. Each newly remodeled room has high speed internet access, a tv, a private bathroom, and a private garden space to relax.

Guest favorite

A private bedroom features a queen-sized bed dressed in white bedding. A bedside table with a lamp stands on one side, and a framed black and white photograph of waves is mounted above the bed. Bright light enters through a window adorned with a lace curtain.

Hotel room in Montauk

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

One Bedroom At Boutique Complex Adjacent to Ocean

Enjoy this one bedroom one bathroom unit located at the Plum in Montauk! The unit features a queen sized bed in the private bedroom, a full-sized sleeper sofa, kitchen, complimentary wi-fi, and an outdoor deck. The property features an outdoor heated pool, outdoor shower, daily housekeeping, walk to the beach, and a walk to Downtown MTK!

Guest favorite

The image captures a serene view of a sandy beach meeting the ocean, with soft waves gently lapping at the shore. A wooden barrier is visible, suggesting separation between the beach and the grassy area behind it. The sky is clear and blue, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere.

Hotel room in Montauk

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Montauk OceanEnd 5

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Ocean front 1 bdrm apt with gorgeous furnishings. Space was completely renovated with no expense spared. Ocean front and a few blocks to the heart of town. This unique spot will make you feel like you’re in another realm. Come and grab your slice of heaven!

Guest favorite

A bright and airy room features a spacious bed with white linens and colorful accent pillows. A woven storage basket sits at the foot of the bed. A wall-mounted television is positioned in front of a cozy seating area with a wooden chair and potted plants.

Hotel room in Narragansett

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Cozy Hotel, Room #2

This room is a guest favorite, with a queen bed and a generously sized, tiled shower. The room includes a cozy sitting area with two chairs, perfect for lounging, and a record player to set the mood. Retro-inspired artwork, including tasteful historic postcards, adds a charming touch to the room’s ambiance.