Hotel vacation rentals in Lake Montauk

Clean and close to everything. The townhouse was especially roomy

I stayed at Chris’ place with my husband and 3 month old for 3 nights. Great location on Thames Street and walkable to restaurants, shops, Cliff Walk, and more. You can definitely hear the people on the 3rd floor, but the AC’s in each bedroom helped with that and was not a deal breaker. The place was spacious, beautifully decorated, spotless, and had ample TV’s and bathrooms which was great. We’d definitely stay here again!

Great location! This was close enough to downtown that we could easily walk to the waterfront or stroll along Thames. It was pouring rain on our first night, but not to worry — we were just a three-minute walk from delicious Italian food. Easy to grab morning coffee and pastries as well. We were also in a quiet enough zone that car shares arrived on time but there was no congestion or bothersome street noise by us. Inside the house was perfect too! Spotless and exactly as described. Beds were comfortable, water was hot, checkin and checkout was effortless. Last but not least, the price was right for our girls’ trip. We would definitely stay again!

Wonderful place....beautiful, clean, comfortable and so much more. Can walk to lots of restaurants, etc. Or Uber will pick you up on the corner which we did. Mansions close, too. The morning downstairs breakfast was much more than expected, delicious! The check in lady and everyone who worked there were polite and helpful. Much better than a hotel! I highly recommend.

Exceptional! Magical! Extraordinary! Single-handedly the best travel accommodation experience ever. Jay and his team are the best in the business. The location, the services, the accommodations and their extreme attention to every detail made this the place we never wanted to leave. We will be back again and again. Do yourself a favor…book this place if you can. It is …simply put AMAZING! Can’t wait to get back!

Kind staffs and clean place to stay!

Stay was awesome! Joe was very responsive and easy to deal with . Place and surroundings lived up to expectations.

Joseph saved me from a disastrous stay in Montauk. Incredible room, great property. Stay here & you’ll have a great time out east.

Great room near restaurants and activities! Really enjoyed the pool access, included parking and daily activities! Would definitely recommend ☺️

What a stunning location.

We had an amazing stay! The room was clean and they were flexible with check-in and also allowed us to park and use the amenities prior to check-in which allowed up to maximize our stay and time spent there! Walkable to all restaurants and shops and right by the beach! Would definitely stay again!

I recently had the pleasure of staying at the exquisite Marram, and it was an unforgettable experience. From the moment I arrived, the staff went above and beyond to ensure my stay was perfect. The check-in process was seamless, and I was greeted with a warm welcome. The room was beautifully decorated, combining modern amenities with a charming coastal vibe. The bed was incredibly comfortable, and I appreciated the thoughtful touches like high-quality toiletries and a well-stocked minibar. The view from my room was stunning, overlooking the pristine beaches and tranquil ocean. The hotel's amenities were top-notch. I enjoyed a relaxing afternoon by the pool, which was surrounded by lush landscaping and had plenty of comfortable loungers. The on-site restaurant offered a delectable menu featuring fresh, local ingredients. Each meal was a culinary delight, and the service was impeccable.

Excellent service

Great stay at Journey. Place was quaint and immaculate, bed was very comfortable, room was large and decorated beautifully, and the staff was wonderful.

Absolutely gorgeous! The view, the adorable cottage-like room, the easy access to town and the beach were some of our favorite parts of the trip. We loved our stay and can’t wait to come back!

A wonderful stay

Very nice overnight stay on our way to Maine. Peggy was very helpful with check in and very knowledgeable about the history of the place. Nice view from the balcony. Would definitely recommend and stay again our next time up that way.

10/10 stay. Will be coming back again. Thanks for all the recommendations and the stay!

We had a couple wonderful days in Mystic at the cottage. This is one of the best experiences with airbnb that I have had. A great location and a wonderfully designed space. Herman was one of the nicest dogs too. I would go back to to see him ;)

Beach Plum was awesome! We stayed for one night and everything was perfect. The location is amazing, it was clean and the views were beautiful. We will definitely be staying again!

The unit was spotless, comfortable and spacious. Beds were quite comfortable, had all the amenities we needed. The location was perfect and the view was fabulous. We hope to return for an annual trip.