Keuka Lake fishing vacation rentals

Jill's place was perfect for celebrating a special occaison! The location is picture perfect and there is everything you could ask for! Great communication and very clean and organized! We highly recommend for anyone travelling to Seneca Lake!

Everything was great - the home was clean and comfortable, the location is very convenient, and logistics were easy. We particularly appreciated that kitchen was stocked with coffee, spices, and condiments. Thanks for a great stay!

Drift away was a wonderful cottage right on the lake. Place was extremely comfortable. Beautiful views. We didn’t have the greatest weather which would have made the trip so much better, so we hope to plan a trip back soon.

Karen and George’s home was the perfect Finger Lakes getaway. The house was extremely clean, comfortable, and had everything we needed. It was super close to some of the best wineries, and they were just a text away—friendly, responsive, and incredibly accommodating. Highly recommend and would definitely stay again! 10/10!

The house was just as described! Comfortable with lots of space. There were two bedrooms and two living room areas with pull out couches. We went to a few of the wineries around; there was a lot to choose from! We loved sitting on the dock. Only things worth noting are the parking situation, where 5 cars are all that is allowed to be parked in the driveway. This wasn’t mentioned in the listing, but the owner messaged a few days ahead of time to let us know. This could be difficult if you’re having 12 people. There is an additional spot across the street where we were able to fit one more car, but it may not be enough space. Consider carpooling! My party didn’t care, but there were a LOT of dead bugs in the doorways, which could be hard to avoid at a lake house but felt like it was missed during cleaning. There were some dishes left in the sink and the dishwasher & the grill was pretty dirty, so it was also just missed during cleaning. Otherwise, our stay was great & we’d stay again!

With several beautiful wineries close by, the location was perfect for a weekend trip with my mom & sisters. Sarah and team were proactive in their communications and left a lovely welcome gift for us to enjoy during our stay. The house decor/aesthetic was welcoming and cozy as well — plenty of space for the four of us to relax and sleep comfortably!

This rental home is top shelf. It is exceptionally clean, neat and tidy, and while decorated tastefully, there is no clutter which might otherwise get damaged or interfere with people there temporarily. New carpeting (at least it looked new to us) with an exceptionally thick pad underneath. Comfortable furniture throughout this great home makes having breakfast or reading your favorite book a pleasure. Nice weather, move out onto the fantastic deck and have a seat at the outdoor table, or relax in one of the many chairs our hosts have purchased for comfort and convenience. Nice morning? Take your coffee out to the dock and plant yourself in a chair out on the end and enjoy God's creation. This home has a sturdy new dock with several places to tie up a boat. The picture of the dock in the listing shows a boat hoist, but that was not there during our visit and made tying up our pontoon boat great with the collapsable cleats on the dock. Way more to say, but no room to express it

Catharine was an amazing host - very responsive and could answer any question we had during the trip! The place itself was gorgeous and even nicer than the photos! Was here for a bachelorette and the location is perfect to get to the town of Geneva and local wineries! We had a great time. The house felt very private as well. I can’t say enough good things!

What a view! Beautiful and serene plus in walking distance to Keuka Springs Vineyard. The house was comfortable and clean. Perfect for my family who traveled to the finger lakes for a wedding. I would definitely stay here again.

Amazing surroundings and the A-frame design and architecture is so inspiring. We had a relaxing time staying at Martin place. The lake scene is stunning day and night!

The host was very friendly and accommodating when we had a bump in the road with our reservation. Everything worked out perfectly and we were very happy with our stay.

Beautiful view and nice, comfy home! We all enjoyed the pool table and punching bag in basement. It was really wonderful waking up to the view of beautiful Keuka Lake and we made some great family memories here. Thank you!

This guy takes it to the next level! If I could add a few stars, I would 👍🏽 Will be back often for the place and the confidence that my vacation with my family will have life long memories ❤️

The stay started with walking into an amazing open living room with large windows that looks out into the water. The feel, the space, and the view is even better than what the pictures try to capture. We had dinner right in town and it was just over 5 minutes away. The kiddos really enjoyed the paddle boards and littke kayaks, we went everyday, sometimes twice. Beautiful place, great getaway. Grateful for this stay, and would come back again!

We had a wonderful stay and really loved the house. I really loved that all bedrooms were lake front and had large windows to enjoy the beautiful views. The house was also very clean and well maintained. Diana was a great host and provided information in advance. I had one question when we arrived and she responded almost immediately. It was a great experience.

We enjoyed our stay and plan to come back next year! House was clean and comfortable. Lots to do in Geneva.

The house was exactly as described, not a speck of dirt could have been found upon arrival. We had an amazing time and are looking forward to returning!

Just stayed for a second time and loved it just as much as the first time! We love how at home we feel there and the amazing front deck. So relaxing! Also, we love that Seneca Farms is right around the corner so we could get great fried chicken and ice cream anytime! The hosts are so friendly and gracious! We would return again!

Beautiful lake Airbnb. Couldn't have a better weekend. Plenty of space to spread out!

We had a terrific stay! Phillip was proactive and responsive. Check-in and check-out were easy . There were personal touches, snacks and wine awaiting us upon arrival! The house is beautifully located on the lake with great sunrises and views. Close to Hammondsport and many great wineries. Highly recommend!

had a wonderful time. Beautiful surroundings. would definitely go back

The cabin was perfect for us and our two dogs, who travel with us often. We loved walking the trail and down the road and around the pond. My husband and I enjoyed the seating area at the pond and firepit. Communication was stellar with Danielle and Matt! We will return!

Very friendly, responsive, and proactive host - thanks AJ! Perfect location for relaxing and get away with stunning water view! Peaceful and tranquil neighborhood. Property has all amenities a large family need, with spacious rooms/baths, and lakeview! It was cold when we stayed, otherwise, would have gone out to the lake with the kayaks! Super-sized terrace with screen is perfect for staying outside without worrying about bugs and rains. Nice boat launching deck with crystal clear water and view of there the three lakes meet. Close to Corning Museums of Glasses that is a must visit if you are around! So is Cornell Campus in Ithaca - yes, I am biased as an alumni :) ). Highly recommended and will be back.

Great stay at Joel’s place! Super peaceful and gave us a lot of privacy with the location. Super close to Penn Yans boat launch with was a bonus. Would love to be back in the future!