Vacation rentals in Green Turtle Cay

Sea Salt Bahamas on Great Guana Cay

Your beach on Great Guana Cay is two miles of pristine, powdered-sugar sand and crystal clear turquoise water and other people are few and far between. From the moment you arrive at Sea Salt, island living will feel natural, comfortable, and easy. With the ocean just steps from the deck, a genuinely well-stocked home, and attentive local care, Sea Salt is designed to help you settle in quickly and enjoy Guana Cay at an unhurried pace. Every detail is intentional creating a calm, welcoming space.

Beach and Boaters Dream w/ Dock - "Dragonfly"

The perfect spot to lose yourself as you look out to the beautiful calm waters of the sea of Abaco and sandy Windward Beach. Hop on your boat from our dock to explore all that the Abaco islands have to offer. 2200 sqft w/open-air porch to relax and enjoy a morning cup or an evening cocktail. The master suite opens onto the relaxing waterfront porch. Steps away is a private outdoor shower. Paddle board less than one minute to the secluded beach for lounging and taking in amazing sunsets.

Tucked In on Eastern Shores, Marsh Harbour

Welcome to our little slice of heaven, located on Eastern Shores. Named for its' "Tucked In" feel, you will think you are floating on water when you wake up each morning in our studio-style cottage that can sleep up to 4, with a queen bed and pullout couch. Park your boat up to 40’ on the private dock or take the ferry to surrounding islands. Or just relax, enjoy the kayak or swim in the crystal clear waters of the Bahamas. The airport, grocery store and restaurants are just 15 minutes away

Lo key cottages, The Beehive

The Beehive is the most spacious & luxurious property at Lo Key Cottages — a brand-new 2024 two-story, 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom retreat in a private tropical garden with sweeping Coco Bay views, Green Turtle Cay, Abaco Bahamas. Sleeps 8. Open-plan living/kitchen downstairs opens to the bay; upstairs master suite has king bed, ensuite & private deck. Central AC, Starlink, generator, dishwasher, laundry & more. The newest & largest villa at Lo Key, built for those who refuse to compromise.

Breathe Deeply at Morning Star

Welcome to Morning Star! Our hope is that people who stay here will feel welcome, comfortable, and be able to enjoy the beauty of God’s amazing creation. Morning Star was built in 2003 - designed to be comfortable and family-friendly with no-frills. Our secluded beach has great shelling and snorkeling. The deep water dock on Black Sound easily accommodates most vessels. The Main House comfortably sleeps 6 or 7 with 2 additional Guest Quarters to sleep up to 4 more!

Aly’s Hideaway – 2BR Island Getaway + Dock Access

Spotless, spacious, and full of island charm! This 2-bedroom half-duplex on Black Sound offers ample room, comfort and style and includes a boat slip at the owners dock. Bedrooms can be set as kings or XL twins—your choice! The large, well-equipped kitchen makes meals easy, and you’ll stay cool with A/C and solar power. Wi-Fi and cable TV keep you connected. Perfect for relaxing, exploring, fishing or just soaking up the vibes and excitement of Green Turtle Cay.

Maranatha Cottage, Green Turtle Cay - Harbour View

Bright, breezy, coastal cottage located in the main village of New Plymouth. Originally built in the late 1860s but completely renovated and modern. Situated on the main shore road with a view of the beautiful harbour. Minutes away from restaurants, grocery stores and the beaches. Air conditioned throughout, main bed and bath downstairs, second bedroom (twin beds, air mattress or convertible to a King upon request.) with full shower and bathroom upstairs.

The Swamp

The Swamp is perfectly located in the middle of Green Turtle Cay with a 3 minute walk to the pristine white sand beaches. Built in 2024, this property offers a spacious open floor plan with a coastal organic vibe. 3 bedrooms that will comfortably sleep 6 guests and plenty of seating and space for entertaining in the dining and living area. This home is brand new construction that was completed in late 2024 and new to the rental market as of 4/2025.

Shipwrecked, your perfect seaside escape

This charming one-bedroom, one-bathroom end unit offers everything you need for a relaxing and memorable stay. Immerse yourself in the crystal-clear waters with some of the best snorkeling on Green Turtle Cay, or take a leisurely stroll along the pristine mile-long beach, where hidden treasures from the deep blue await. Fully equipped kitchen, a washer and dryer, and reliable Starlink internet. For added peace of mind, a backup generator

Sunset cottage on the sea of Abaco

Sunset cottage is located on the sea of Abaco in the historic settlement near bars , restaurants, grocery stores , liquor stores and churches . You will enjoy some of the prettiest sunsets out the front door you will see lots of sealife out the front door and off the dock . Our dock will accommodate outboard boats . New Plymouth settlement has fewer mosquitoes and noseeum's compared to anywhere out of the settlement.

"Pretty in Pink" Luxury Condo

This newly renovated condo awaits your dream vacation. With 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, guests can relax and enjoy the award-winning white sand beach. Amenities include 2 restaurants, 2 swimming pools, beachside lounge chairs, watersports equipment (SUPs, kayaks, surfboards, etc), a fitness center, and a boutique. In-condo amenities include a washing machine, WiFi, AC, and an oceanfront porch.

Sawyer’s Seabreeze | Waterfront | Private Dock

Newly added to the short-term rental market, Sawyer’s Seabreeze is a spectacular 3 bedroom, 2 bath waterfront home. The property is located in the heart of Green Turtle, across the harbour from New Plymouth. Enjoy many views of the water on the covered front porch or private dock. A full house, automatic generator has been added.