Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Fair Haven

Absolutely incredible views. We had an incredibly memorable two nights here, and Erin was always willing to provide pointers and help when needed (even at late nights). We appreciate the host and the location greatly and would definitely recommend this place to family and friends.

We couldn’t have asked for a better stay! Mara’s home was beautiful, clean and the perfect place to stay for a relaxing long weekend away. We’d love to stay there again and will definitely be recommending!

Highly recommend this location - for any time of year. This old lake house has been meticulously updated and was perfectly in between the lake towns our family wanted to explore around Christmas time. Dennis was very proactive, friendly and shoveled+salted the driveway for us. He gave us great recommendations on where to eat and short walks. Even though on a main road, with active train tracks behind the house, the house was still relatively quiet. 5/5 will be returning here in the future

This home exceeded my expectations. The home was very clean and fresh. The beds were extremely comfortable which helped me get a restful night's sleep. I felt very comfortable and safe during my stay. The location is central and close to downtown Geneva which was few minutes of a drive. I appreciate the attention to details the host have for the home. They provided all necessities needed for a short term stay like coffee, pots/pans, dishes, soap, shampoo/conditioner and they even provided a basket of snacks which was a nice gesture.

Great spot for a small fishing trip with the guys. James was a great host. Will 100% be back next year.

Such a wonderful cottage stay. The shared lake access was so easy and wonderful. The cottage is only about a 10 minute drive from the downtown area, which we explored everyday during our stay. Would definitely come back.

Our stay here was wonderful! The house was beautiful and well appointed. They literally thought of everything. It felt like walking into home. The location was so serene and peaceful! We highly recommend!

Beautiful home on Sodus Bay. Amazing views, great location, very clean. We would definitely consider renting here again!

“An exceptional retreat with everything you need for a relaxing stay. The kitchen is fully stocked with all the essentials to actually cook, and the thoughtful design extends to the outdoor patio, where we enjoyed using the grill. The hosts were absolutely wonderful—attentive and welcoming—and the location is perfect, right in the heart of the entertainment district. I stayed here with my 13-year-old twins, and we found it to be incredibly quiet and peaceful. We’re truly grateful for such a fantastic experience and would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a high-end stay.

The apartment was lovely: had everything we needed, beautiful view of the lake, comfortable private space. The hosts were helpful and responded quickly to communications. Highly recommend staying here.

very responsive. only stayed a night but i had no issues

Here’s a positive review you can use for the Airbnb apartment on Cayuga Lake: --- We had an amazing stay at this lovely apartment on Cayuga Lake! The place was incredibly comfortable and spotless, with all the amenities you could possibly need – from kitchen appliances to thoughtful extras like coffee and even toothpaste. The highlight of our stay was the adjustable bed – such a pleasant surprise! After a long day of hiking, it was pure bliss to put our feet up and relax. The lake is just 100 feet away, with a beautiful park that’s perfect for a peaceful stroll. The neighborhood is quiet and feels very safe, which made our stay even more enjoyable. We can't wait to come back again soon

We had a wonderful stay at Scott’s beautiful lakeside home at the Finger Lakes! We stayed for three days to celebrate my wife's birthday, and this serene spot made it truly special. The house is peaceful and perfectly situated by the lake, providing a perfect escape. Scott was incredibly responsive and proactive—he made sure we had all the instructions we needed in advance, and the home was equipped with all the necessary amenities to make our stay comfortable. It was clear he put thought into ensuring a smooth experience for his guests. We highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a relaxing and memorable stay!

We really enjoyed the space! Clean, inviting, with great amenities and lots of unique touches. Would love to stay again sometime.

We enjoyed being able to come and go while taking in the historical and cultural offerings of Auburn. We’ll be back!

I can’t say enough good things about Margaret’s Airbnb! We were in town for a wedding, and Sodus Point is absolutely beautiful. Walking distance to the little town, it’s in a great location. Margaret was so friendly and kind, and we were so glad we had the opportunity to stay here. I would love to come back and stay again, everything was wonderful about our stay.

Went up with a friend to go fishing for the weekend. Cabin was awesome and super clean. Had everything you would need as far as pots and pans, and things like that. We had a little issue at first with the key but we called the host and he helped us figure it out in like two minutes. The host told us that the fire wood stacked there was free so that was pretty great too, and there was little bags of chips and stuff already in there. Bathroom was good. Shower was good but the hot water doesn’t last too long. The listing kinda confused me and I thought that it was one bedroom, and then the upstairs part. But it was two bedrooms and the upstairs part. So it was four beds not 3. Great place tho 10/10 would recommend.

We enjoy staying at William's place because we are very close to our family that live in the area.We hope to stay again soon.This is our 2nd time staying at the cabin in the pines.

Nancy’s cottage was perfect for our little family of 4. We enjoyed card games on the back porch, meals al fresco w a beautiful lake view, and of course roasting marshmallows in the fire pit at sunset. The cottage was intimate and cozy and we hope to return on a regular basis. Thank you Nancy for being inviting and more than accommodating.

Amazing cozy cabin, will be returning!

Trevor’s place was amazing. Well worth the money. Cupboards were well stocked as well as the bathroom necessities. Very responsive with answering questions back quickly. The hot tub was wonderful to relax in. We played pool and darts and had a blast. Would definitely visit again….

We had the best stay! It was very beautiful and relaxing. Ed was extremely kind and reasonable. We can’t wait to return and try out some of the on-site activities. Ed gifted us with some of his own maple syrup and it’s clear he and his wife are dedicated to what they do. Very much recommend :)

Great little spot. Everything is super well labeled and easy to follow. They had everything we needed to make a pizza which was a surprise to us both. I also really needed q tips for like a week and all of the other Airbnbs hadn’t had them and then when we got here, they had them! Heroes. They’ve thought of all of the little things and that’s what makes them great!

This place is beautiful looks even nicer in person than on the pictures . It’s very peaceful and fairly easy to find they left little notes around the house to find extra linens toilet paper etc which was a very cute touch . has a lot of stuff to do outside and inside it is the perfect little get together cabin the host is very nice helpful and attentive with any questions you may have through the stay definitely recommend