House vacation rentals in Elkhart Lake

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Quick stats about house rentals in Elkhart Lake

Total vacation rentals
Explore 30 vacation rentals in Elkhart Lake
Nightly prices starting at
Elkhart Lake vacation rentals start at ﺩ.ﺇ 294 per night before taxes and fees
Verified guest reviews
Over 570 verified reviews to help you choose
Family-friendly vacation rentals
20 properties offer extra space & kid-friendly amenities
Rentals with dedicated workspaces
10 properties have a dedicated workspace
Wi-Fi availability
30 of Elkhart Lake vacation rentals include wi-fi access
Popular amenities for guests
Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Elkhart Lake rentals
4.9 Average rating
Elkhart Lake stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!

Top-rated house rentals in Elkhart Lake

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

A rustic modern home is showcased, featuring a spacious wraparound deck surrounded by lush greenery. An inviting hot tub glistens in the sun, and an arcade room with various games is displayed, offering entertainment options for guests.

Home in Elkhart Lake

The LODGE in Elkhart Lake. —-Hot Tub & Arcade—-

Rustic modern home w/ hot tub, arcade & fireplace right on the edge of Elkhart Lake. Road America, great golf, The Ice Age Trail, & the Kettle Moraine are all at your doorstep. This cozy home is 4 blocks from the downtown of Elkhart lake. Yet it still has an acre to explore & enjoy nature. Only 4 miles from Road America. 2 bedroom w/ 2 extra sofa sleepers & 2 baths. Perfect for racers or romantic getaways. The arcade/Pinball room has over 10 games. Perfect base camp. We got your bases covered

FamilyValueBackyard

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 301 reviews

Top guest favorite

The kitchen features dark cabinetry with artistic landscape designs and a large white countertop island. Stainless steel appliances include a stove and dishwasher, while a coffee maker is positioned on the counter. Natural light enters through a nearby doorway, illuminating the warm wood tones of the floor.

Home in Plymouth

The 2400 sq ft Plymouth Paddock near Road America!

This charming two story, 2400 square ft colonial house is the perfect respite for families looking to connect, or race fans looking for a home during race weekend. Only 4 miles from Road America the location is close to all of Sheboygan County's finest attractions. Located two blocks from downtown on a quiet street, its up to you how you want to spend your evening. You could walk downtown for a bite, have a campfire, make a meal, or just spend time together. Welcome to your home away from home!

FamilyLocationGrill

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 207 reviews

Top guest favorite

The two-story home features a beige exterior with multiple windows, surrounded by a grassy yard. Two chairs are positioned in front on a small patio area. Large trees provide shade, while a view of the countryside and other structures is visible in the background.

Home in Glenbeulah

Stay at Sunrise LLC, Like being at Grandma's

Welcome to Stay at Sunrise LLC. We offer a clean and comfortable home for your vacation enjoyment. We are in a rural area, recreation trail head is 3 miles east of us as is the Wade House, 7 miles from Road America. Large yard, Fire pit, picnic table, child swing set. Garage parking on site if arranged in advance. We do not have WIFI Phone reception for Internet is good. No Cable or Satellite TV, Over 32 antenna channels. Smoking is allowed outside of the home. No pets allowed.

ValueFamilyDecor

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area is filled with neutral-toned furniture, including a large sofa, accent chairs, and a circular coffee table. Natural light filters in through large windows, highlighting the wooden floors and a decorative area rug beneath. Soft green accents are present in the lamps and curtains.

Home in Sheboygan

House Near the Lake

Get out and enjoy nature, then return to a quiet mix of modern and retro in this family home only a block away from Lake Michigan. There are three parks and two beaches within a mile, as well as Terry Andrae State Park about 10 minutes away. If the outdoors aren't your thing, downtown Sheboygan hosts the Kohler Art Center, The Weil Center, Blue Harbor, and the Children's Museum, with Road America only 30 minutes away. Located between Milwaukee and Green Bay, this home has all the conveniences.

ValueLocationSleep quality

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Top guest favorite

An aerial view of a spacious home is surrounded by mature trees, showcasing a private sandy beach alongside Lake Michigan. The property features a pathway leading to the house, emphasizing its secluded setting amid natural greenery.

Home in Oostburg

Lake Michigan Beach Home by Frank Lloyd Wright pro

Beautiful view and sand beach on Lake Michigan, completely private, surrounded by mature white pine trees and cedar trees. The spacious home is fully equipped with an "eat in" kitchen, dining room, and living room entertainment space, den with a see-through log-fired fireplace, screened-in porch to accommodate additional eating space, large outdoor deck with grill and fire pit. A canoe and a row boat are available for the boating enthusiast, with life jackets and other floating devices.

ValueFamilyAmenities

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Sheboygan

LUXE Manor With Modern, Elegant Vibes - 4,500 Sq

Modern chic blends with classic sophistication in this late 1800s Historic Manor, The Herman Hayssen House. Enjoy 4,500 sq ft of elegance and character that adorns this well-appointed home. Complete with 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and 1 half bath, many different areas for entertaining, both inside and out. The neighborhood is of the most elite in Sheboygan, situated between the lakefront and downtown and is a short drive to Whistling Straights and within an hour of Milwaukee and Green Bay.

ValueFamilyLayout

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 248 reviews

Guest favorite

A historic lighthouse stands at the water's edge, illuminated by the vibrant colors of sunset. Smooth stones line the shoreline, reflecting the serene lake. Lush greenery is visible in the background, creating a peaceful coastal setting.

Home in Fond du Lac

Woltring Waters Waterfront Home + Hot Tub

Wake up to a beautiful view of Lake Winnebago, and enjoy you cup of coffee with the sound of crashing waves off the back porch. You will have breathtaking sunsets with the historical light house backdrop that is in viewing distance from the property. From dining to convenient stores everything you need is in walking distance. Take a peaceful stroll around the marina or take the kids to Lakeside Park, offering a petting zoo, carousel, train, jungle gym & splash pad. Everyone will enjoy!

ValueFamilyBiking

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 132 reviews

Superhost

Home in New Holstein

Growe's Guest House - just like Grandma's!

Our beautiful private home is available for you! We'd love you to experience the peace and serenity we so much enjoy. We'll answer all requests AS SOON AS possible, hoping we can accommodate your needs. Come; be our guest; night, week, or month! Please note: there is NO overnight street parking Dec. 1- March 1. The private lot behind the house MAY provide permission on an as need basis. Please indicate # of cars and dates before reserving, so accommodations can be arranged.

ValueFamilyIndoor spaces

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

Top guest favorite

A sunlit sunroom features a cozy seating arrangement with two wicker armchairs and a spacious sofa adorned with blue and white cushions. Large windows provide multiple views of the surrounding greenery and the lake, allowing natural light to fill the space.

Home in Plymouth

Lake House-Kayaks/Paddle Boards/Private Pier

🛶 Private Pier + Kayaks, Paddle Boards, & Lily Pad Raft 🏖️ Direct Lake Access with Crystal Clear Water ✨ Fully Renovated (2025) 🛏️ 4 Bedrooms with Premium Mattresses & Hotel-Quality Linens 🚿 2.5 Modern Bathrooms + Laundry Room 🍳 Chef-Friendly Kitchen with High-End Appliances ❄️ Central A/C, Fast WiFi, and Ample Parking 🏁 5 Mins to Road America | 20 Mins to Kohler Golf & Spa 🧭 Under 1 Hour to Milwaukee & Green Bay Attractions 🛟 Life Jackets & Water Toys Provided

FamilyLocationIndoor spaces

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Guest favorite

Home in Plymouth

Oak Haven | Theater • Game Room • Sauna • Firepit

Welcome to Oak Haven, a private 4,300 sq ft retreat surrounded by oak trees and peaceful Wisconsin beauty. 🌿 • 12-seat movie theater with plush recliners & surround sound 🎬 • Game room with pool, ping pong, shuffleboard & poker 🎱 • Infrared sauna + two outdoor fire spots for perfect nights 🔥 • Gourmet kitchen & dining for twelve 🍽️ • Minutes to Kohler golf, Kettle Moraine & Road America 🏎️ ✨ Oak Haven—where relaxation, laughter, and connection come naturally.

FamilyValueBeach

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area is highlighted by large windows allowing natural light to fill the room. Comfortable seating includes a sectional sofa and two armchairs, arranged around a stylish fireplace with intricate tile work. Light-colored curtains complement the modern decor.

Home in Sheboygan

The Suncatcher -Steps from Lake - Fenced Yard

Welcome to the Suncatcher. Our cozy and bright Midwest retreat just a block away from Lake Michigan . Step into our lovingly remodeled 1930's home where modern comfort meets timeless charm. As you enter you will be greeted by the inviting warmth of exposed brick walls and abundance of natural light that fill every corner. With three bedrooms and two bathrooms, our spacious retreat is perfect for families, friends, or golf enthusiasts seeking a relaxing getaway.

LocationValueLayout

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Top guest favorite

A spacious lakefront home is set against a backdrop of lush greenery and sandy shore. Gentle waves lap at the beach, while a pathway leads to the property, highlighted by the natural beauty of the surrounding landscape.

Home in Oostburg

Outdoor Sauna | 6-BRs | Kohler-Andrae

🏖️ Private Sandy Beach on Lake Michigan 🔥 Waterfront Fire Pit for Cozy Evenings 🧖‍♀️ New Lakeview Sauna 🪟 Open-Concept Living with Wall-to-Wall Lake Views 🛏️ 6 Bedrooms – Sleeps Large Groups Comfortably 🍳 Fully Equipped Kitchen & Spacious Dining Area ☀️ Expansive Deck for Coffee, Sun & Scenic Relaxation 🌲 Wooded, Tranquil Neighborhood Near Kohler-Andrae State Park 🚗 Minutes to Sheboygan, Kohler, & Road America 🔐 Private Home with Seamless Self Check-In

FamilyLocationGrill

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews