Eleuthera vacation rentals

My husband and I stayed at Krista’s home for 5 nights with our two young daughters. This was one of the best trips we have ever taken. The house was beautiful and clean, we had everything we needed and more. The location is incredible, the beach is beautiful and we will absolutely be back. Location made it easy to drive to governor’s harbor almost every night for dinner and throughout the week as we needed things. We felt incredibly safe in the home and on the island in general. Lovely people in Eleuthera and a wonderful experience staying at La Concha.

Cozy and private place next to the beach with a great view. Perfect to relax. The house was equipped with everything we needed and Jon made a great and very helpful guide of the area and everything important to know. The road to the house is bumpy, but with a proper car and driving slow no problem. Loved our holiday there!

We stayed in the blue cottage for 6 nights and we loved it. Location is great, 5 minutes walk to the beach, 10 mins drive to Governor’s Harbour, very quiet. The cottage is a 1BD, furnished with all you need for a beach holiday (sun chairs, towels, etc), but also with a fully functional kitchen. A/C worked great, but we mostly did not need it because there was usually a nice breeze outside. Sarah was very helpful and super responsive and we were able to check in early which was super nice! We found the price of the cottage to be very fair compared to the value. Just note that there is no dishwasher or washer, but I would not say that was an issue. Super recommended!

Sara was a gracious host. Her house was exactly as she described. It had everything needed for a fun day at the beach- chairs, umbrella, floats and coolers. She accommodated the change in my travel schedule and also allowed an early check in. We had a fantastic 18 night stay. This property is highly recommended, and I anticipate a stay in 2026.

As described. Clean, close to beach, golf cart was a huge plus. Blair was always super responsive and helpful.

This was an incredible place for our anniversary trip! Clay and Michelle were super helpful and responsive. James was extremely nice and so much fun to be with. He made our trip extra special. This is a private vacation spot free from crowds and noise. Simply beautiful!

Perfect! Cobalt Cottage was everything and more! We loved every moment we spent inside the cottage. Our kids enjoyed catching hermit crabs and playing on the slide / swings! The screened in porch was the place to be, and was so peaceful. Adrian, the property manager, was so helpful and made sure we knew where to go and how to get there; he even help set up a boating experience, it was amazing. It was nice having him close by, always ready to help if needed! We felt safe the entire time, and everyone on the island were so nice. We used Chad and Hope’s guide a lot, it was so helpful and informative. Everything we did was based on this guide and it did not steer us wrong! We will definitely be back; our kids (4, 7, 10) were so sad to leave, so were we!

We only had a short stay in Eleuthera but our stay at Monkey Beach was amazing! The kitchen was very well equipped with everything we needed. The views from the property were amazing from each of the patios and our own private beach access was a nice perk. The house manager Romell was also very helpful and we were able to rent our car from him which was a seamless experience. I would highly recommend staying at this property.

We had a great stay at Shorebreak! It is such a peaceful place and a great place to unwind. The home is as described. We came in April and the private beach below was not present, available, or swimmable due to the season/tides, but we rented a car and drove to some amazing local beaches. (Rented with Robert Thomson and he was awesome) Highly recommend Rainbow Bay and taking a day trip to Harbour Island. There are pretty limited options for restaurants (mostly fried food) so make sure to plan to cook most of your meals. The house is very remote but if thats what you are looking for, this place is perfect. Mark was a fantastic host and we look forward to coming back one day!

Joy and Dom’s beautiful Airbnb was the perfect place for our family’s recent trip to Eleuthera. We have stayed in airbnbs around the world and this was one of our favorite experiences… for the coziness factor (we felt right at home), the charming location (we liked the mix of locals, tourists and chickens), walkable and drive-able. Our favorite nearby beach was Ten Bay. You have to see it! Our favorite morning coffee spot to walk to was Squire Cafe… and walking around the beautiful streets up there. We also loved Da Perk, another breakfast cafe you can walk over to. Joy and Dom are generous with their recommendations (including to send links and rental car companies as soon as you book). And while you’re on island they are responsive for any questions that arise. This made our stay so easy! Our favorite excursion they recommended was Island Charters with Capt. Sean! We hope to stay again one day! Thank you Joy and Dom.

My boyfriend and I had the most wonderful vacation staying at the Bungalow. It was clean, spacious and accurate in terms of what the listing had described. We made use of the kitchen accessories that were provided (plates, bowls, cups, utensils, minifridge, microwave, coffee maker ect.) which was helpful when picking up food in town with a car that was easily rented. It was extremely relaxing with our own private patio and various kinds of lounge chairs while also offering a more social atmosphere at the restaurant and bar. While we had seen a review mentioning a slightly uncomfortable bed, we slept comfortably every night. The views were amazing from the property, we felt extremely safe and at-home and spent a lot of time (frequently without seeing another person) on the beautiful beach just steps from the bungalow, as well as floating in the pool and taking advantage of the swim-up bar. I could not have asked for a more friendly and accommodating staff on the property and restaurant/bar as well (Mekell who welcomed us with a seamless check-in, Sammy at the bar, Pascal and Francesca at the restaurant and the younger staff helping to take care of the house and ground-keepings) not to mention - the food and drink at Pascal's was delicious!! Pam from the rental team was also extremely helpful with my Q&A's via email. While there is so much of the world to see this would be a spot I would return, knowing that there is such an amazing experience to be had.

There’s a reason Cay Casita has such great ratings! If you’re traveling to Spanish Wells, don’t hesitate to book here. It was perfect for our needs and centrally located.

The place is more than beautiful. The property is located on a beachfront lot. The beach itself is really serene, we’ve seen only 3 people on it over the 4 days we’be passed there…. And it was Christmas… The villa is spacious for our party of two and could ideally accomodate a family. You’ll have every accessories you need to spend 2-3 weeks vacation there. We wish we’d book for longer but decided to visit a couple of Bahamian islands on our 10 day visit. There are lots of good restaurants nearby but a car is really a must if you want to reabh them easily. We liked afternoon munches at Potlatch Club, dinners at Bougainvillea and, of course, relax snacks at Tippy’s. Barbara is a great host and did everything she could to accomodate our (belated by the airline company) arrival and departure. Her manager, Winifred, is also really pleasant to deal with and efficent. I definetly would go again and recommend the place.

We truly enjoyed our time at Casa Libre. The house's location is perfect, gorgeous views, and right by the water. Kitchen was equipped well and had everything you can think of. It was a very peaceful and relaxing stay for us and we highly recommend this house.

This is the perfect Eleuthera hide away youve been looking for. Beautiful home, well appointed, and right on a beautiful private beach. There’s even a sand bar beach a 10 minute walk from the home if you want shallower, more peaceful water. A corner store in walking distance had many items and friendly, helpful staff. Rent a car is my advice so you can see more of the island and go to restaurants and a bigger grocery store. We cooked in most nights. Just peaceful, serene and safe. We loved it.

We loved every minute at Stephanie's place! This home is pure paradise, very remote, relaxing and the pictures just don't do it justice. Easily the best stocked place we've ever stayed. The views from the decks are absolutely spectacular, we saw dolphins and sea turtles a few days. The pool is another absolute highlight, the water was just perfect! Stephanie was very quick to respond to any questions. We enjoyed preparing great meals most nights at the home with ease while enjoying the beautiful sunsets. We had so much fun exploring the surroundings and beaches. The only thing wrong with this place is having to leave! -Jill, Luke, Josh & Missy.

We just spent 2 weeks in Ray's Bahama Breeze villa. The location was great. Just a couple minutes from our favorite beach access on 12th Street. House was very cute, and it had everything you need for a nice vacation. Golf cart is a must when visiting Spanish Wells. Ray was kind to book it for us and he also arranged pack'n'play and a high chair for the kids. Spanish Wells is magical, and locals are so kind and welcoming. We enjoyed walking on the sand banks and looking on the seashells and starfish. We saw a couple of stingrays and turtles right at the beach. A couple of ideas if you stay here: Go to Bernard's fish dock for a fresh lobster that you can cook at the villa. He also has a friendly manatee in the water that looks adorable, and you can pet it and give her a snack. Papa's scoops ice cream every night 7-10 pm gives you the choice of 2 flavors. We always got a swirl of both flavors in the waffle cone upside down in the cup, so it doesn't melt till you get home.

I had a wonderful stay! The space was exceptionally clean, beautifully furnished, and very well maintained. Everything felt thoughtfully cared for, which made for a peaceful and relaxing experience. The hosts were responsive, making the whole process smooth from start to finish. I’d absolutely return; highly recommend!

Our family of 4 enjoyed our stay so much! The house was conveniently located near most of the shops & restaurants in Harbour Island. The home came with all necessary amenities and was surprisingly spacious. We especially enjoyed the beach chairs and towels. Sam was an amazing & responsive host. We were able to rent a golf cart through her and it was sitting in the driveway when we arrived.

The owners who live on the property are very kind and were available when we needed anything. They also gave us tons of space . The house is large with all amenities. The place does not have a washer and dryer which would have been nice for our long stay with two kids. ( they do state this in the listing). Other than that, it has everything else you would need. The internet was a spotty at times. However maybe to be expected on an island. Great location and good price for the island

Mark was a very responsive host. The golf cart was an amazing amenity and necessary to navigate around the island. We had a small issue where the golf cart died during a drive and he quickly arranged for us to be picked up and a new golf cart provided right away within minutes of letting him know what happened. The house was located in a convenient location, two blocks from the beach, a short drive to the grocery store and restaurants. Several beach chairs and beach toys were available for us at the house which was so useful! Spanish Wells is a small, safe island community and we enjoyed our getaway here!

Watercolour provided a lovely way to enjoy Harbour Island! The location was right in town, near docks and groceries. The various outdoor spaces provided plenty of options! Jessica was very helpful and responsive. The home had the charm of an old home, and we didn’t come expecting pristine, but everything worked well and it was a great value. We came with teens who loved having their own space with bathrooms.

**★★★★★ A Slice of Paradise in Eleuthera!** Our stay at the House of Love was nothing short of magical! From the moment we arrived, we were blown away by the spacious, immaculately clean layout and the warm hospitality of the host, who went above and beyond to ensure our stay was perfect. The house itself is a dream—generously sized rooms, a fully equipped kitchen, and an open-concept living area that made our group feel right at home. But the real showstopper? The *breathtaking views of the ocean* from nearly every room! Waking up to the sound of waves and sipping coffee on the deck while watching the turquoise water sparkle was pure serenity. The host’s attention to detail and quick responses to any questions truly made us feel cared for. Whether it was providing local tips or accommodating our requests, their kindness added an extra layer of comfort to our vacation. If you’re looking for a peaceful escape with easy beach access, stunning sunrises, and a home that balance

Stunning beaches nearby! Clean, quiet, cozy and peaceful. Wallace made arrival and departure from the airport a breeze and offered wonderful tips for a great experience on this unique island.