Vacation rentals with a pool in Cayuga Lake

Find and book unique homes with a pool on Airbnb

Top-rated rentals with a pool in Cayuga Lake

Guests agree: these homes with a pool are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favorite
The interior of the A-frame features high wooden ceilings and an open layout. A spacious seating area is arranged with a large sofa and matching chairs, while a dining table sits beneath decorative wall art. A staircase leads to a lofted sleeping area with a railing.
Home in Newfield
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 198 reviews

Camp S’mores- Modern A-Frame with Pool

Welcome to Camp S’mores- this revitalized luxury A-frame has all the modern amenities you need for your Finger Lakes adventure. We just brought new life into this house from top to bottom. The home features three bedrooms and a Murphy bed in the game room on the lower level. EV charger. It wouldn't be camp without a pool so our home has a large HEATED in-ground pool is open May 15th - Oct 1st. The house is located outside of town on 2+ private acres. Dog friendly, sorry no cats or other pets

Top guest favorite
A remodeled country home is situated amidst lush greenery, featuring a gravel driveway leading up to the house. A silver metal roof covers the attached garage, while a camper is parked beside the garage. Trees provide natural shade around the property.
Home in Ithaca
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 212 reviews

Haven Woods, quiet house, minutes to Ithaca w/ AC

"Haven Woods", Quiet country remodeled home on 36 acres, 10 minutes from Cornell University and 12 Minutes from downtown Ithaca and Ithaca College. 5 minutes from Ithaca airport. Many restaurants nearby. 3 bedroom, 2 bath remodeled home, fully equipped kitchen, game room, fields and woods & pond. No neighbors nearby, very quiet and peaceful. Close to nature. Wild turkey, deer, coyotes, fox. Close to state parks and numerous falls and gorges. Finger Lakes Wine Trails. Many hiking trails nearby.

Top guest favorite
A welcoming seating area is presented with two soft blue armchairs positioned on a decorative rug featuring floral patterns in shades of blue and cream. A small table with a lamp is situated between the chairs, and natural light enters through a large window overlooking a grill area.
Home in Pittsford
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Charming Pittsford Home-Indoor Pool-4 bedrooms

My home is in the Bushnell's Basin/Perinton part of Pittsford. .5 miles to 490, 4 mi to I-90 and 15 minutes to U of R. Erie Canal is a short walk away. The 17 mi Crescent Trail head is 100 yards away. Fantastic restaurants. The large indoor pool is open year round with new filter and pool heater. A stream is in the fenced backyard. 50 trees provide privacy and shade. The 4 bedrooms are spacious and 21/2 baths ensure no waiting! 2 decks. Golf, Finger Lakes, wineries, & breweries are close.

Guest favorite
A two-story home features a welcoming front porch, adorned with seasonal decorations. A bold red door stands prominently against the light-colored siding. The driveway is paved and leads to a spacious two-car garage, while well-maintained landscaping complements the entrance.
Home in Clay
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 205 reviews

Beautiful House in the Best Area to Stay!

Be ready to be amazed this fully renovated luxury home truly has it all plus more. A beautiful heated pool ,hot tub in a private backyard with a lots of privacy. Enjoy a game of pool a full size pool table or watch a movie on the 85 inch Sony ultra hd tv with sound system. Sit back and relax on the movie style automatic leather recliners while the gas fireplace sets the mood Cook yourself a feast with a fully stocked kitchen with everything you could possibly need including a coffee bar.

Top guest favorite
A spacious wooden deck is presented, featuring a circular above-ground pool surrounded by greenery. A shaded area is provided by a red umbrella over a dining table. Soft evening light filters through the trees, enhancing the serene outdoor space.
Apartment in Seneca Falls
5 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Luxury lakefront apartment - and a private pool!

This new apartment on Cayuga Lake is in the middle of New York's famous Finger Lakes. Seneca Falls is a quaint, quiet community surrounded by dozens of wineries, trails, parks, boating, fishing and more - a vacation paradise, and home to the National Women's Hall of Fame. Your private deck overlooks the lake, plus there's a private pool, deck and grill. 2 bedrooms, full tiled bath, huge modern kitchen, and hi-def TVs in the living room and bedrooms w/free Netflix, Prime Video, Hulu & Disney+.

Top guest favorite
A spacious home is set within a lush, wooded landscape, showcasing rich autumn colors. The structure features large windows, providing natural light, and is framed by verdant trees and shrubs. An expansive lawn extends in front, inviting outdoor activities.
Home in Canandaigua
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Foster Hideaway - lake views, pool, hot tub.

Secluded, spacious home, overlooking Canandaigua Lake on 6 wooded and park-like acres. Breath-taking Panoramic views. Surrounded by forest and bordering a winding gully for year-round hiking. In-ground pool, 4-season hot tub on enormous deck; lovely glamping tent in woods with natural fire-pit. Gas grill and chef's kitchen for after a long day of skiing at Bristol Mountain, 12 miles away. Full gym. Wine / beer-tours, boating, golf, nature, right outside. Relax and enjoy this "Chosen Spot!"

Top guest favorite
A bright living area features an orange sectional sofa accompanied by a green armchair. A glass coffee table rests on a textured rug. Natural light filters through tall windows with wooden frames, illuminating a stylish piece of wall art and a leafy indoor plant.
Apartment in Auburn
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Contemporary and cozy flat, w/ fireplace & balcony

This contemporary 1-bedroom is located in an 1880 Victorian in the historic district of Auburn, NY. From here, you can walk to the Seward House Museum, the beautiful Seymour Library, the NYS Heritage Center, and the Harriet Tubman Home. A 5-minute walk to Wegmans grocery store, downtown shops, cafes, and great restaurants. Whether you're coming to enjoy the historic charm of Auburn, or using this as a base for exploring the Finger Lakes and all they have to offer, you won't be disappointed.

Guest favorite
The entrance to 'The Hobbit House' is framed by lush greenery and features a distinctive wooden door in deep red. The charming exterior showcases a combination of shingled textures, with a shaded porch adorned by a wooden pergola and decorative string lights.
Farm stay in Brooktondale
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Farmstay Scottland Yard-Hobbit House dogs welcome!

Scottland Yard farm stay, 'The Hobbit House' Come enjoy our little piece of paradise. We are located 10 easy miles from Ithaca NY in the beautiful Finger lakes region! we are less than 1/2 day trips from NYC, NJ, PA, Rochester and Buffalo. We have consistently been Airbnb super host for 6 years! We have seasonal glamps and cabins, but are now offering our favorite little hideaway year round! Enjoy the gentle peaceful flow of life just breathing the sweet air here at Scottland Yard Farm.

Guest favorite
A bright living area features a spacious gray sofa paired with a comfortable armchair. A decorative coffee table sits atop a light area rug, and a wall-mounted TV is visible opposite the seating. Natural light fills the room through large windows, enhancing the wood flooring.
Home in Elmira
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

Comfy Ranch House 3BR/2BA

Welcome to our cozy Upstate NY retreat! Perfect for traveling workers or family vacations, this newly renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom house offers a comfortable stay. It features a stocked kitchen, laundry room, and spacious, furnished rooms. In the summer, enjoy our 24-foot round pool with a deck and lounge chairs. The backyard has a 5-burner gas grill, a gliding bench, and an outdoor table with a retractable umbrella, ideal for dining and relaxing. Book now for a great stay!

Guest favorite
The yellow farmhouse is set amidst lush greenery, surrounded by trees. A spacious driveway leads to the front porch, which is shaded by overhanging branches. A basketball hoop and a grill are visible near the garage, contributing to the outdoor recreational space.
Home in Penfield
4.84 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Penfield-Webster Home w/Pool - Park Like Setting

Charming 19th century 2,300 sq.ft. farmhouse with 3 large bedrooms on 1 acre. Stately coffer ceiling in expansive living room. Recently update with refinished floors, paint and new kitchen appliances. Inviting breakfast room with french doors leading to side yard. Private 1+ acre yard with 18'x38' in-ground pool on park like setting directly across from Town Park. 5 minutes to shopping and entertainment and a short 15 min. drive to downtown Rochester.

Guest favorite
A serene outdoor view features two comfortable chairs positioned around a small table, overlooking a lush green lawn and a tranquil pond. Trees frame the scene, and clear blue skies provide a bright backdrop.
Apartment in Ithaca
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 243 reviews

Private apartment with full kitchen (dog friendly)

This apartment is located in the basement of a family home. It is a self-contained private unit with a separate entrance, full kitchen, bathroom with shower and washer/dryer and a living space. The property is fenced and has a pool for use in the summer and a pond with fish to feed. Friendly dogs are welcome (the owners have a friendly beagle-basset who loves to meet other dogs). Please note that we have ducks who free range in the yard.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a two-story white house is framed by lush green trees and manicured lawns. The front porch features white railings, while large windows reflect the sunlight, enhancing the inviting appearance of the home. A sense of spaciousness is conveyed by the surrounding open area.
Home in Fairport
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Esten-Wahl Farm - Historic Landmark Victorian Home

The farm is 30 acres of pasture, woods and a stream - peaceful, yet within a bike ride to the village of Fairport and the Erie Canal. There is a small cottage hidden behind the historic barn where we live and care for the animals on the farm. Our guests' privacy is paramount and the farm is yours to wander and enjoy (including the pool and tennis court) as you wish! The pool is open mid-May through Mid-September.

Popular amenities for Cayuga Lake rentals with a pool

Destinations to explore