Beach house vacation rentals in Bay Shore

We loved staying here! Stayed in October but had stunning weather, quick walk to town, walked the Sunken Forrest, which was easy to get too. Quick walk to the ocean for morning sunrises and enjoyed some wildlife friends, loved the deer. Hosts were accommodating, can’t beat three master bedrooms, would absolutely stay again, my family had a wonderful time!

So glad we stayed at John's beachfront home. We wanted a way to escape the noise and chaos of a large city and this was the perfect fit. Granted the commute is longer, but we couldn't get enough of the amazing ferry ride from Rockaway to Manhattan/Wall Street. Such a great way to explore NYC.

Christina’s place is a lovely cottage by the marina and walkable into town. The main loft bedroom and sitting area is spacious and comfortable. We stayed for the holiday with our adult daughter and we were all comfortable and cozy. She had her own bedroom on the main floor. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay while we visited our family over the holiday.

Easily one of the nicest homes I’ve stayed in! The hosts were very accommodating, responsive, and had the BEST amenities. My kids really enjoyed the board games and the beach down the street. Highly recommend this hidden gem!

My daughter and I had a lovely stay at this apartment. It was perfectly located to allow us to take a great long walk on the boardwalk in the morning, and was an easy drive to the events we were on Long Island for. Bruce was a great host and very responsive to questions ahead of our stay. We so appreciated the special touches like cookies left for us and a bottle of milk to go with our coffee! Our stay was easy and comfortable we would definitely stay there again.

John and his wife are excellent hosts. Their home is pristine with an abundance of amenities. The sunset on the bay is spectacular. I highly recommend. Thank you. Keith and Donna W.

So many wonderful things to say about Mario and this place. Clean, newly renovated, so many amenities and a quick walk to the beach and restaurant. Mario was very responsive and ensured our stay was comfortable. Would recommend to the Airbnb community!

Absolutely stunning! This house has an amazing view from gigantic glass doors in the main room. Details in the house are well thought out and of great quality, including a high end coffee maker and other appliances. The place has lots of premium touches that make this experience a cut above the rest. Steven is an amazing, friendly, and communicative host. Incredible experience all around, I would definitely book here again.

David and Ileana are exceptional hosts. The Long Beach Bungalow exceeded every expectation from the time I was greeted by David, throughout my week long stay, and the minute it was time to head back home. My intention was to have a week of rest and relaxation. A daily walk on the boardwalk and beach was invigorating. I walked everywhere. The supermarket, restaurants, a spa day, and a boutique. The bungalow is equipped with every amenity you could possibly want. That shower was AMAZING. But let me say, David and Ileana’s attention to detail and kindness is extraordinary.

Such a great house for a group! Well kept and very accommodating. Will definitely be back

Place was clean and reasonably priced for the area. Conveniently furnished with many kitchen appliances. Moderately noisy from the traffic (as you can expect close to the road) and typical noise from the rest of the house. Johnna was very easy to communicate with. Got greeted by a very cute cat as we parked outside :)

Five stars doesn't feel like enough, if anything I'd say everything was better than we'd expected based on the pictures and the reviews! First, as others have mentioned John was an incredible host, the place was well stocked and had all sorts of snacks and drinks (and a nice bottle of wine); he also bought us dinner and was very good about keeping in touch the whole time we were there. The house was amazing top to bottom, but I have to specifically call out the pool, which was jaw-droppingly beautiful and the perfect temperature despite cold weather outside. We loved the neighborhood and yard to walk our dogs, and the kitchen was great to cook in (made me miss having a gas stovetop). We'll definitely be visiting again, it was the kind of stay that sets a new bar for what to look for in a vacation!

I cannot describe accurately how lovely and comfortable Jonathons house is It was more than perfect for us in every way! The fenced in yard was perfect for our little dog and we all enjoyed turkeys and deer hanging out. Walking the neighborhood and to the beach with leaves changing It couldn’t have been any better.

A lovely stay for my brother in-law. Very comfortable with easy check-in and fast communication. Exactly what we needed!

We really enjoyed our stay at Bellport, it was extremely clean! The kitchen/baths were well appointed. The yard is gorgeous and the pool was delightful. Beds were very comfortable and the bathrooms are beautiful. Such a great place!

Great stay and location with lots to do close by. thanks for a great stay!

Excellent location. An easy inexpensive ride into Penn Station via LLRR. A suggestion: I recommend those luggage racks one finds in hotels for your suitcase in each bedroom. That, or foot of bed benches. There is no closet for the small bedroom, so a place for your suitcase would be great. A chair in the small bedroom would also help.

This place is amazing!!! Our family of four stayed with two teenagers and it was perfect for everyone to have their own space. The location is great. It’s a short drive to the beach, an hour train ride to the city, or stay home & enjoy the amazing views. All the amenities were luxurious from towels and bedding to the super comfortable beds and the place was spotless which isn’t easy to do next to the water. Our family loved it, it’s one of the nicest places we’ve stayed. I would highly recommend.

This home was everything and more than Chris said it would be. Immaculate. Roomy. Even the little details were there. I will be requesting this home again. 10 stars.

this home makes you feel right at home. plenty of room. great location. great host , very courteous. best place to stay if visiting long island. very safe neighborhood, short walking distance to shops, beach and LIRR station

My family and I had a very relaxing stay at this place. Cozy with plenty of amenities. PAPA, the neighborhood cat likes to visit in the morning on the front deck and he’s a very good boy. Bring him treats.

Had a truly amazing stay! House was exactly as pictured and was perfect for sleeping 8 people comfortably. Perfect location in between the beach and the town. Host was incredibly accommodating and very responsive. Outdoor roof space was perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach. Highly recommend!!

Wally’s place is advertised. More an old school beach house than a luxury stay. A bit no frills, but it certainly had what our group needed, and the location more than makes up for it. The design is a bit unorthodox (kitchen/living room separate from the rest of the house), but worked for us. Make sure you watch the video tour, as it provides a more accurate view of the house than the photos. ACs functioned, grill heated up, speaker connected, and always enjoy an outdoor shower. Easy 5 min walk from the ferry (less if you’re not carrying bags) and even shorter walk to the beach. Really enjoyed Kismet, just a quiet, friendly neighborhood and a nice break from real life. Wally was very responsive, making sure to touch base before check-in and check-out, and we were able to leave our bags on the porch after checkout to get some extra time on the beach, which we certainly appreciated.

We had a wonderful stay with Cat and family. The apartment is very very spacious and comfortable, had everything we needed! The heated bathroom floor was the cherry on top. We will definitely be back!