House rentals near Anna Maria Island

AMI Dock of the Bay - "On the Water" 1st Floor

AMI Beach + Bay Home with Fishing Pier + Heated Pool on Sarasota Bay - "Dock of the Bay" / Entire 1st floor of Duplex called "On the Water" • Unbelievable views of water + birds + wildlife + night lights! • Relax with fish jumping and birds flying along 1 of only 34 coveted docks/piers south of Cortez Bridge! • Fish off dock and rod holders! • Heated pool w/ spa jets/benches only 10 ft from Bay! • Walk 2 blocks to Bridge Street/Key West-style restaurants, bars. • Live Music heard on dock!

The Florida Rooms

NEW POOL/SPA. Just 10 minutes from the beach, The Florida Rooms is a 3BR, 2BA retreat with NEW RESORT POOL & SPA, outdoor dining and living space, premium beds, rain showers, a full kitchen, and dining for 8. Extra sleeping includes a queen sofa bed and Pack ’n Play. Enjoy a pool table, ping-pong, board games, outdoor string lights, and a fire pit. We include beach gear—chairs, towels, umbrella, and wagon—for easy fun in the sun. Comfort, charm, and convenience await! Pool/spa heating included!

Carissa A | Beachside Retreat | Golf Cart | Pool

Carissa Loft A🏝️ A well-designed home offering comfortable spaces to relax, reconnect & experience all that AMI has to offer! Step inside to discover a private lower level retreat featuring a queen bed, sofa, TV and game table. Upstairs you'll find the fully stocked kitchen, inviting family room, 2-bedrooms & 2-full baths. The private outdoor oasis features a heated/cooled cocktail pool. 🚙Park the car & let the island adventures begin! The 6-person golf cart is complimentary with your stay!

Stunning beach house with heated pool and hot tub!

Welcome to The Colony, a stunning vacation rental on Anna Maria Island, designed to capture the essence of Palm Beach living. This spacious 4-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom house features elegant decor and modern amenities. Step outside to discover a beautiful backyard oasis, complete with a large pool, hot tub, and a well-appointed patio that invites relaxation. Just a 5 minute walk to the pristine beaches of AMI, The Colony is perfectly situated in charming Holmes Beach for an unforgettable getaway.

Gulf Front! Sunset Deck! + Walk to Bridge St Pier!

🌊🏄Welcome to The Surof House - where panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico welcome you from almost every corner! 🏖️Experience the ultimate beachfront retreat at this unique & stunning property nestled across from one of the top beaches in the world. A perfect blend of luxury, comfort, & unparalleled views awaites. With an upstairs loft featuring 3 single beds & 2 downstairs rooms with king beds, it's an ideal getaway for families, friends, or anyone seeking a slice of paradise.

1/2 Block from Beach- Private Boat Dock & 30' Pool

o A beautifully renovated 3-bed 2-bath oasis designed for unforgettable family getaways, boating adventures, and pure relaxation. o While many rentals claim to be in Anna Maria, they are actually situated in the heavily congested Holmes Beach or Bradenton Beach areas. Nestled on the quiet, historic North End of Anna Maria City. Completely bypass the tourist traffic and long car lines, enjoying a peaceful, authentic neighborhood where everything you want is within a short stroll.

NEW! w/ Pool - The Pearl Unit 2 on AMI

The Pearl (Unit 2) is a newly renovated oasis in the heart of Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island. Just a 3–5 minute walk to the beach, this sunny AMI duplex home has everything — sparkling saltwater pool, fresh interiors, no stairs, beach gear, and parrots that may say hi on your morning walk! Centrally located and steps away from the AMI trolley to whisk you around the island! Relax, explore, and live your best island life. *pool is shared with one other unit in the duplex home*

Stylish Pool Home 4BR Near Siesta Key "Palm Noir"

Welcome to Palm Noir, a brand-new modern luxury retreat in Sarasota just 12 minutes from Siesta Key Beach and 9 minutes from Downtown. This stunning pool home features soaring ceilings, impact windows and doors, designer finishes, luxury furnishings, bright open living spaces, and a private heated pool with spa. Enjoy premium bedding, fresh towels, a fully equipped kitchen, outdoor dining, lounge seating, and everything needed for the perfect family vacation or group getaway.

The Beach House 2 by Duncan Real Estate

Welcome to The Beach House 2! Price Reduction due to construction on Tuna St through April 30, 2026 arrival! Enjoy newly renovated absolute beachfront on the North end of Anna Maria. Directly on the Gulf of Mexico, North of Pine Avenue on beautiful Anna Maria Island, The Beach House 2 is a spectacular beach retreat. This Old Florida beach house on the outside, the interior has been remodeled and updated with all the comforts of a family home.

Luxe Island Escape by Beach Boutique Rentals

*Features include* * Huge heated pool and spa * Swim up bar seating * Rooftop deck with sweeping water views * 4 bedrooms, 4 ½ baths * 3 king master suites with attached baths * Indoor/outdoor living on all 3 levels * Patio dining for 6, plus lounge area * Chaise loungers by the pool * Garage game room with ping pong table and TV * 2 blocks to beautiful Bean Point beach! * Beach chairs, umbrella, and cart

Pine Avenue next door!~Heated pool~Steps to Beach

AMI Oasis is a luxurious 4-bedroom retreat steps from Pine Avenue and a 5-minute walk to the beach. Enjoy a private heated pool, backyard putting green, ping pong table, and outdoor dining area. Inside features a bright open layout, gourmet kitchen, and four king suites with spa-like ensuite baths. Owner managed and perfectly located, this Anna Maria gem delivers the ultimate island getaway. 🏖️✨

Bean Pt. Bungalow - Half duplex w/private pool

Welcome to Bean Pt. Bungalow! A charming 3/2 villa with a private saltwater pool in the heart of Anna Maria. You're only 0.2 miles from the nearest beach access and 0.2 miles from the Rod and Reel Pier. The home comes equipped with 6 beach chairs and cart. This boutique rental is the perfect place for your next getaway! Primary - King Bed Front bedroom - King bed Bunk room - 4 twin beds