
Boutique hotel vacation rentals in Tisbury
Find and book unique boutique hotel rentals on Airbnb
Top-rated boutique hotel rentals in Tisbury
Guests agree: these boutique hotel rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Privacy & history in downtown Sandwich Village!
Located in the historic "Painted Lady" Inn building (a converted Rectory in heart of historic Sandwich Village), the "Ida" room features 2 skylights, lots of sunshine, and plenty of privacy. As part of the award-winning Belfry Inn compound, your staff with help you orchestrate your days! Walk the shops, galleries, restaurants & cafes, historic sites, gardens & museums, and the local beach & boardwalk! Try the Cape's best burger in the downstairs bistro and bar. Continental breakfast is included.

Luxury SeaSide King Suite, Frederick William House
The Luxury SeaSide Suite...beautifully appointed, Cal-King suite, pet friendly options with pet fees collected at check-in separately from booking details on Air bnb...located on the Shining Sea Bikeway in Falmouth, across the street from Goodwill Park. Stay includes bike rentals. Enjoy being a short walk to the Steamship Authority parking & shuttle to the ferry boat. Guest are welcome to take bikes over to Martha's Vineyard for day excursions. 139 private and public beaches to choose from.

Boutique motel w/ private beach, steps from ferry
Lovely, modern room in boutique hotel with private beach. Watch the Steamship Authority ferries come into the harbor. No need for a car as the property is just steps from the ferry terminal, art galleries, shops and restaurants like the famous Black Dog Tavern. Unit was completely remodeled in 2021 featuring all new furniture and decor. The property offers friendly service and amenities such as outdoor grill, picnic tables, beach loungers, and a community room. A perfect island getaway!

Three bedrooms for travel group/excellent location
The charming Tivoli Inn is walking distance to all downtown shops and restaurants, beach, in-season ferry terminals, and public transportation. This listing is 3 bedrooms of 6 bedrooms at the Tivoli Inn with common areas with other guests. There is one full bath. In addition there is a lovely outdoor shower and an extra sink in 1 of the 3 bedrooms. Bring your flip flops to enjoy the outdoor shower! There are 3 full size beds and one twin bed...a total of 4 beds to accommodate 3-6 guests.

Porch Room 1 queen bed
The Porch Room has a queen bed and private shower room and half bath located next door to the room in the hallway. This bedroom also has its own entrance to the wrap around porch. The Porch room is one of six rooms at the Tivoli Inn. The Tivoli Inn is a charming Victorian Gingerbread house which has the island charm and a clean and friendly atmosphere. The inn is walking distance to all downtown amenities including town beach, seasonal ferry terminals and public transportation.

Treehouse Lodge, Canopy style rooms
This beautiful modern meets classic style property is a 10-minute walk from the beach and ferry to Martha's Vineyard in Woods Hole. Free private parking and free WiFi is available on site. Quick walk to the beach, several restaurants, and most science facilities. Guests can enjoy various activities in the area, including windsurfing, fishing and traveling to Martha's Vineyard. *Note to bookers- We are located on the mainland where you get the ferry to go to Martha's Vineyard*

Boutique 1950s Cape Cod motel
We are a small 1950s motel in a tranquil setting. You drive up to your room. We offer breakfast, housekeeping, and have guest laundry and vending and ice. Every room has a frig, microwave, coffee and tea service, and bath amenities. We offer suites with kitchenettes but these you book directly with us. You have to be 21 to rent a room, we are no pet-friendly, and 100% non-smoking. There are places to smoke. Office is open 6am-10pm. You can check-in after, just let us know.

Sandy Neck 24 with 2 Queen Beds 1 mi to beach
20-minute walk from the beach. Located in Sandwich, within 6 miles of Sandwich Glass Museum and 7 miles of Heritage Museums & Gardens, Sandy Neck Motel provides accommodations with a garden and free WiFi as well as free private parking for guests. All rooms Flat-screen TV, air conditioning and includes bed linen and towels. *Tripadvisor 2022 Travelers Choice Award Recipient *THAwards 2022 Family Friendly Hotel of the Year *Bookingcom 2023 Traveler Review Award

THE FRANKLIN HOTEL~NEW Pet friendly Standard Queen
Located on Upper Main Street in Edgartown, the Franklin Hotel is a short stroll from the heart of the historic village and its famed island beaches. A fresh take on the nautical style with modern, luxury finishes will provide all you need for work, play and relaxation. The Franklin grounds offer distinct seating areas including the covered patio, perfect to enjoy three season island breezes. The chic design of our 18 guestrooms will delight every sense.

In Town Queen Room
The Attleboro House has all of the conveniences of a modern hotel in the quaint atmosphere of a historic inn. Located among the famous Gingerbread Cottages and directly on the Oak Bluffs harbor, you’ll be in the perfect place for your visit to Martha’s Vineyard. Originally built in 1874, The Attleboro House was completely renovated in 2018. Relax on our wrap around porch to enjoy the bustling harbor and impressive views of the Nantucket Sound.

Glendale Petite @ Frederick William House
The Glendale Petite Room is Double Deluxe Room at Frederick William House. Located on the Shining Sea Bikeway in Falmouth Massachusetts across the street from Goodwill Park. Your stay includes bike rentals. Short walk to the Steamship Authority parking & shuttle to the ferry boat. Guest are welcome to take bikes over to Martha's Vineyard for day excursions. Beach passes are available allowing access all 139 private & public beaches.

Balcony Room at the Tivoli Inn
The Tivoli Inn is a charming Victorian Gingerbread house which has the island charm and exudes a clean and friendly atmosphere. The inn is walking distance to all downtown shops and restaurants, town beach, ferry terminals, and public transportation. The charming Balcony Room boasts a private flowery balcony and a private bathroom in the room. Stenciled bordered walls and original wide pine flooring.
Popular amenities for Tisbury boutique hotel rentals
Family-friendly boutique hotels rentals

Balcony Room at the Tivoli Inn

Treehouse Lodge, Canopy style rooms

Luxury SeaSide King Suite, Frederick William House

Briarwood Beach Motel

The Boutique Stagecoach Stop #1

Boutique motel w/ private beach, steps from ferry

Vineyard Harbor - Unit 108

Glendale Petite @ Frederick William House
Boutique hotels rentals with a patio

MORGAN HOTEL ~ David Healey Suite w/ private bath

THE FRANKLIN HOTEL ~NEW Pet Friendly Standard King

THE FRANKLIN HOTEL ~NEW Pet Friendly Luxury Queen

THE FRANKLIN HOTEL ~NEW Pet Friendly Luxury King

MORGAN HOTEL ~ Ocean view King Room w/ Verandah

MORGAN HOTEL ~ Standard Queen Room ADA w/ Bathroom

MORGAN HOTEL ~ Standard King w/ Private Bathroom
Other boutique hotel vacation rentals

The Cape's most FAMOUS suite! Jacuzzi, Fireplace

Private 2 Bedroom suite downtown Sandwich Village

Private & clean Jacuzzi room in converted Rectory!

Sandy Neck 23 with 2 Queen Beds 1 mi to beach

Peaceful history in downtown Sandwich Village...

Inn suite in converted church! Fireplace, Jacuzzi

"Pet Friendly" & Private, Fireplace & Jacuzzi room

Private fireplace suite in converted church!
Quick stats about boutique hotel rentals in Tisbury

Total vacation rentals
Explore 20 vacation rentals in Tisbury

Nightly prices starting at
Tisbury vacation rentals start at ﺩ.ﺇ845 per night before taxes and fees

Verified guest reviews
Over 910 verified reviews to help you choose

Wi-Fi availability
20 of Tisbury vacation rentals include wi-fi access

Popular amenities for guests
Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Tisbury rentals

4.8 Average rating
Tisbury stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.8 out of 5!
Destinations to explore
- Plainview Vacation rentals
- New York Vacation rentals
- Long Island Vacation rentals
- Boston Vacation rentals
- East River Vacation rentals
- Hudson Valley Vacation rentals
- Jersey Shore Vacation rentals
- Philadelphia Vacation rentals
- South Jersey Vacation rentals
- Mount Pocono Vacation rentals
- The Hamptons Vacation rentals
- Capital District, New York Vacation rentals
- Rentals with pools Tisbury
- Rentals with breakfast Tisbury
- Rentals with a fireplace Tisbury
- Rentals with outdoor seating Tisbury
- Pet-friendly rentals Tisbury
- Hotel rentals Tisbury
- Rentals with a washer and dryer Tisbury
- Rentals with an EV charger Tisbury
- Condo rentals Tisbury
- House rentals Tisbury
- Beachfront rentals Tisbury
- Rentals with beach access Tisbury
- Rentals with a fire pit Tisbury
- Bed and breakfasts Tisbury
- Rentals with lake access Tisbury
- Waterfront rentals Tisbury
- Private suite rentals Tisbury
- Rentals with a kayak Tisbury
- Apartment rentals Tisbury
- Family-friendly rentals Tisbury
- Rentals with a hot tub Tisbury
- Rentals with a patio Tisbury
- Boutique hotel rentals Dukes County
- Boutique hotel rentals Massachusetts
- Boutique hotel rentals United States
- Cape Cod
- Mayflower Beach
- Brown University
- West Dennis Beach
- East Sandwich Beach
- Craigville Beach
- Point Judith Country Club
- Duxbury Beach
- Easton Beach
- Onset Beach
- Oakland Beach
- Roger Williams Park Zoo
- Horseneck Beach State Reservation
- White Horse Beach
- Coast Guard Beach
- Second Beach
- Chapin Memorial Beach
- Pinehills Golf Club
- Island Park Beach
- The Breakers
- Nauset Beach
- Lighthouse Beach
- South Shore Beach
- Goddard Memorial State Park