Places to stay near Theater of the Sea

Book unique vacation rentals, homes, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals near Theater of the Sea

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

The eco-friendly two-story River Queen vessel is anchored in a calm harbor, showcasing a modern design. The structure features large windows and a rooftop terrace, with a wind turbine on the left. The surrounding landscape includes lush greenery, complementing the serene water view.

Boat in Tavernier

Island Sanctuary Islamorada

Stay aboard the eco-friendly two-story 63 ft River Queen with a 360 degree view with beautiful sunrises and sets, mored 1/8 mi offshore in a quite harbor close to shopping center, movie theater, hospital, bars & restaurants. A 10-foot dinghy with small outboard to come & go from shore "ONLY", nowhere else. I also offer Personal Training, deep tissue work & Life Coach sessions. I live on the vessel about a hundred yards from you so if there are any questions, etc. I will be there to assist you.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 401 reviews

Guest favorite

A comfortable living area is highlighted by a light-colored sofa with textured cushions, accompanied by a woven coffee table. Natural light enters through multiple windows, revealing touches of coastal decor and a glimpse of a bedroom in the adjacent space.

Cottage in Islamorada

Islamorada bungalow 2 bed & pool

Welcome to paradise! Completely remodeled and immaculately maintained, Bungalow Blue is nestled away in the quiet quaint Shady Palms community of 7 cottages in Islamorada, MM 76. Ideally situated next to the community heated pool, down the street from private boat ramp. If you're looking to relax and unwind while also being close to all that Islamorada has to offer, this is the place for you. Enjoy the FL Keys lifestyle in your private backyard, take a bike ride to World Famous Robbie's Marina

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Islamorada

OceanView 2/2.5 w Beach Pool & Marina Islamorada

Everything you need for your Islamorada vacation is here including 2 gorgeous private beaches, kayaks, paddle boards, heated resort style pool, porch seating with ocean view, and 2 balconies. Located in the middle row of Anglers Reef, this home accommodates up to 6. Boat slip can be reserved for additional fee, if available. REELaxation is our only vacation rental and with an extensive background in customer service, extraordinary guest service and helping to make lifetime memories are our goal.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Guest favorite

Houseboat in Islamorada Tavernier

Baycation Houseboat • Florida Keys Waterfront Stay

Escape to the laid-back luxury of the Florida Keys aboard your own floating oasis. This fully equipped houseboat offers the perfect blend of comfort, adventure and true waterfront living. Wake up to breathtaking sunrises, sip your morning coffee as the marine life glide by, and fall asleep to the gentle sway of the water. Whether you’re celebrating something special or simply craving a one-of-a-kind getaway, this houseboat is the ideal home base for both keys adventures and peaceful retreats 💫

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 281 reviews

Guest favorite

A window reveals a lush garden filled with tropical plants and flowers. The words 'Keys Life' are displayed on a wooden sign above the window, enhancing the connection to the surrounding nature.

Cottage in Key Largo

Cottage By The Sea

Cottage By The Sea...! If you love turtles.This is the spot for you.I have a 150 pound giant sulcata tortoise in the front yard.And then I have four other little turtles that live in an enclosement , also in the front yard and a giant snapping turtle in my koi pond Our 2 bedroom Guest House is located on the Oceanside of Key Largo in a quaint and quiet neighborhood, with a huge yard surrounded by exotic flowers and trees. It is walking distance to a famous local's Tiki Bar and Restaurant

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 422 reviews

Top guest favorite

A serene waterfront view captures the modern multi-story building surrounded by lush greenery. The calm water reflects the clear blue sky, while a private wooden dock extends into the water, providing an inviting entrance to the property.

Townhouse in Islamorada

NEW - Luxury Seascape w/Pool+Free Dockage+Gameroom

🌊Welcome to The Seascape🌊 Experience waterfront living at its finest at The Seascape, a modern, newly constructed retreat nestled directly on the ocean where every morning begins in color, and every evening ends in calm. Here, the ocean isn’t just a view. It’s a presence. Come make memories at Islamorada's famous sandbar, legendary fishery, or gather on sunlit shores to relax and revel in life’s simplest joys with stunning views, direct water access, and a stylish escape from the everyday.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Top guest favorite

Townhouse in Islamorada

Closest Oceanfront Home - 3 Stories and Boat Dock

Welcome to Paradise Palms, the crown jewel of oceanfront living in Islamorada. This gated, three-story retreat is one of the closest homes to the water, offering unobstructed panoramic views, rare third-floor balcony access, and boat dockage. Thoughtfully designed with modern coastal elegance, enjoy two oceanfront balconies, luxury amenities, and unforgettable sunrises and sunsets. Your comfort and satisfaction are our top priorities. Let us help you turn your vacation dreams into reality.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Guest favorite

Home in Key Largo

Largo Getaway: 3 King Suites + In-Law Space

🔑 Managed by KEYLARGOTRAVELS See our profile for all listings. VIRTUAL TOUR: YouTube @Keylargotravels, go to Shorts it is called Mariners 🛏 SLEEPING Bedroom 1 – First Floor In-Law Suite: King bed, en-suite full bathroom with shower, plus a full-size sleeper sofa in the living area Bedroom 2 – Third Floor Master: King bed, en-suite full bathroom, plus a twin floor mattress available if needed Bedroom 3 – Third Floor Guest Suite: King bed plus twin bunk beds, en-suite full bathroom

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Top guest favorite

A sunset view is captured from a covered outdoor seating area, showcasing a tranquil waterway. Silhouettes of kayaks and a table are visible, while the setting sun creates a warm glow across the horizon. Natural textures are evident in the thatched roof above.

Tiny home in Key Largo

My Little Oasis2 Waterfront Retreat, Key Largo

Million Dollar view at a fraction of the price! This property is on the water with amazing bay views. It includes one kayak for 2 people, paddle board, fishing rod, washer and dryer, kitchen with all cooking utensils. Note: The upstairs room is not comfortable for seniors or adults, the ceiling height is 4 feet (an adult has to walk on his knees). The property is located on a residential island, restaurants, bars, stores and grocery stores are within a 15 minute drive from the property.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 236 reviews

Top guest favorite

The living area features a comfortable light blue sofa and a glass-top coffee table, complemented by tropical-themed decor. A ceiling fan circulates air above, while a kitchen bar with high chairs is visible in the background. Natural light enters through multiple windows, enhancing the welcoming atmosphere.

Home in Islamorada

Flakey's

Flakeys, short for Florida Keys is everything you would expect to find on the small Caribbean island. Its paradise! Located in the heart of Islamorada there is no need for a car. You can walk or bike to the best restaurants, bars, beaches and shops this island has to offer. On Morada Way in the middle of the Art and Culture district. Everything at Flakeys is brand NEW! All new appliances, furniture and decor. Shabby Island Chic! Affordable, super clean and you can't beat the location.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 220 reviews

Top guest favorite

A solar and wind powered houseboat is moored on calm waters, featuring bright yellow shutters and a roof deck. Wind turbines and an American flag adorn the top, contrasting with the soothing blue sky and fluffy clouds in the background.

Boat in Islamorada

360 DEGREE WATERVIEW HOUSEBOAT

IMPORTANT Enjoy your own private retreat aboard a solar and wind powered houseboat moored 1/2 mile from land in the beautiful Islamorada Please do not arrive after dark and NO night riding. Need experience with hand pull outboard motors a 12 foot skiff with a 6hp outboard motor is provided reliable to go back and forth from shore NOT reliable for exploring No hot water on shower, heat water in Tpots or Solar bags. Please shave before arriving No suitcases, least amount of cloths.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 394 reviews

Top guest favorite

A clear view of the ocean is captured from the balcony, showcasing the shimmering water beneath a bright blue sky. Lush greenery lines the foreground, while a dock extends into the sea. The scene conveys a serene coastal atmosphere.

Condo in Tavernier

Ocean Views at Ocean Pointe

Conveniently located at MM 92.5, approximately 1 hour drive from Miami, you can enjoy a modern, newly redecorated Keys escape with amazing views of the sunrise right from your oceanside balcony. 2 bed/2 bath with full kitchen and washer/dryer. Pool, beach, pier, BBQ area, and private boat marina within this private community. Kayaks, paddle boards and bikes available for rent. No need to leave, but grocery stores, spas and ample restaurants are close by to fill any need.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 225 reviews