Vacation rentals in The Bluff Settlement

This charming cottage in Rainbow Bay, Eleuthera, is the perfect island retreat! Nestled in a peaceful setting with breathtaking ocean views, it offers a cozy and well-appointed space for relaxation. The location is very nice, just minutes from beautiful Rainbow Bay Beach and local dining spots. Toni and Alex were quick to reply to any of our messages leading up to the stay and their property manager was very kind when we messaged her during our stay as well.

I had such a lovely stay—exactly what I needed for a relaxing and simple solo trip. The space was clean, peaceful, and felt like a little home away from home. Everything was just as described, and I really appreciated the thoughtful touches. Thank you for creating such a welcoming and restful environment.

The Sea Spray Cottage is the perfect getaway. If you’re just trying to relax and look out over the water listening to the sounds of the waves, then this is the place for you. Absolutely stunning views. Wonderful hosts. And the surrounding neighborhood is full of friendly people

This place is a little piece of paradise! The house was perfect for my husband and I on our honeymoon. Everything was clean. The view from the back deck was absolutely breathtaking. It was private and peaceful!

Sadly we left Thea's place in Harbour Island/Dunmore Town today, and we can't wait til the next trip back. The unit felt like home the second we entered it -- we loved the location (no bad location on HI but this was perfectly situated near both the bay and beach), the cleanliness, the comfort of the bedrooms, and the correspondence with Thea who was incredibly thoughtful and responsive the entire way from booking to check-out. She was an amazing host in every way. Thank you for an amazing stay...

Our stay at "Paradise at Sunset" was wonderful. The beach house had it all, from hot tub, to sauna, to his and her outdoor tubs, to your own private beach, the place is incredible. The three bedroom, three bath house is very tastefully and comfortably furnished. With the outdoor kitchen, dining, and entertainment area, you will not find a better place to watch sunsets over the gorgeous turquoise waters. This place is even better than advertised. We enjoyed the swimming, paddle-boards, snorkeling, and fishing right out the back door. We saw so much sea life, we brought our own rods and caught yellow jack, and needle fish right from shore. There is never a lack of things to do or places to relax. When messaged the hosts were impressively helpful and responsive. The island of Eleuthera is a special place and we felt so blessed to have these accommodations while we were there. Can't wait to come back again.

My wife, 2 teenaged children and I had a wonderful time at Pedro and Karen’s place. With its own private beach, it was peaceful and beautiful. The home was very comfortable and perfectly equipped. It was our first time in the Bahamas, and the village of Current provided an excellent glimpse of the evolving island culture. Current Beach is spectacular. We enjoyed driving to other local sights as well and exploring.

Great family vacation spot. We had a wonderful week. Sea turtles and rays greet you right off the beach as you paddle by. Perfect, simple Bahama get away.

We had an incredible stay at TeeJay's place. If you know Harbour Island, you know that this is a very good option compared to the hotels and villas. Her garden is gorgeous and the beach is basically right out the front door down a short path. TeeJay has a chair rental business further down the beach where she reserves chairs for her guests which was an incredible perc. TeeJay also sells food and drinks at her chair rental place. The burgers were some of the best we've had anywhere. We slept incredibly well on the King size bed as the AC worked very well. We also had hot water the whole time which isn't a given in some island bnb rentals. The kitchen is small but has all the basics, however we ate out most of the trip. Also there is some expected wear and tear in the apartment but we found it to be very comfortable and just right for our needs. Anyways, we LOVED her spot and really hope to be back.