Vacation rentals in Sugar Loaf Cay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sugar Loaf Cay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

A comfortable sofa is adorned with decorative pillows, positioned next to two woven lamps on a wooden side table. A circular shelf with a plant is mounted on the wall, while a tall plant adds a touch of greenery in the corner. The warm-toned walls complement the earthy palette.

Condo in Marsh Harbour

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Abaco “Glow” Condo #1 Bay Street at Regattas

Welcome to paradise! This centrally located condo offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience for your island getaway. This charming condo offers a cozy living space, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploration. The two bedrooms provide ample space for four guests, and the fully equipped kitchen allows you to whip up delicious meals or enjoy light snacks. Relax on the private patio and soak up the sun – the perfect spot to sip your morning coffee or enjoy a relaxing evening drink.

Guest favorite

A plush blue sofa is adorned with an array of decorative pillows in various textures, including smooth and ribbed fabrics. A light-colored woven throw blanket is draped over one arm, complementing the cozy seating area that invites relaxation.

Apartment in Marsh Harbour

5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Comfort Cove

Welcome to your home away from home! This cozy, luxurious apartment is perfectly located in the heart of town — putting everything you need right at your fingertips. You’ll love the convenience of being minutes away from the airport, grocery stores, and liquor stores. Gigi's takeout is across the street and many other restaurants are nearby. Nightlife hotspots like clubs and bars are a few minutes’ drive. Take a day trip to the cays on a ferry or explore other parts of this beautiful island.

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor dining setting features a table with two coffee cups and a vase of colorful flowers. The backdrop showcases the expansive Sea of Abaco, with sailboats gliding in the distance under a clear blue sky.

Villa in Marsh Harbour

5 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Brand NEW Oceanfront Villa with protected dockage

MERMAID COVE is a BRAND-NEW one bedroom open plan waterfront Villa directly on the Sea of Abaco. Includes a 50-foot private protected dock. Spectacular 400 sq ft outdoor lower deck with stairs that lead directly into the ocean and a huge upper covered patio and deck. Our luxurious villa with outdoor living is the ideal private getaway for a couple looking for a picture perfect location with all the amenities. Kayak, paddle board and snorkel without leaving the property (Equipment included).

Top guest favorite

A private dock extends into clear water, supporting colorful lounge chairs that invite relaxation. The cottage features a light exterior, flanked by greenery, with steps leading to the surrounding landscape. Beach towels hang on the railing, ready for guests to enjoy the nearby aquatic activities.

Home in Marsh Harbour

5 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Tucked In on Eastern Point, Marsh Harbour

Welcome to our little slice of heaven, located on Eastern Shores. Named for its' "Tucked In" feel, you will think you are floating on water when you wake up each morning in our studio-style cottage that can sleep up to 4, with a queen bed and pullout couch. Park your boat up to 40’ on the private dock or take the ferry to surrounding islands. Or just relax, enjoy the kayak or swim in the crystal clear waters of the Bahamas. The airport, grocery store and restaurants are just 15 minutes away

Superhost

A serene seascape captures a gentle sunset with warm hues of orange and red reflecting on calm waters. A shark is visible swimming just below the surface, illustrating the vibrant marine life in the area.

Home in Marsh Harbour

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Luxurious Waterfront Home with Private Dock & Pool

Get ready to be wowed by the amazing water views, private pool and private dock for your 60ft boat* – this Bahamas house has it all! A luxurious 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home, that sleeps up to 10 guests. The house offers a large kitchen and gas grill for unforgettable dining at home. Or, if you want to venture out, you are just steps away from the renowned Jib Room, along with other eateries, bars, markets, and boat rentals nearby. You will relax in paradise within minutes of arriving.

Superhost

A fenced outdoor area features a neatly maintained lawn and a concrete pathway leading to a small seating area. Two chairs sit on a patio surrounded by lush greenery, creating a tranquil space for relaxation.

Apartment in Marsh Harbour

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Getaway Hill, By Living Easy Marsh Harbour, Abaco.

Getaway Hill offers exactly what it’s name means & what you desire a quick “Getaway” from reality! Located conveniently & safely in downtown Marsh Harbour on a private road with no thru traffic. All business commerce & island activities close by. Offering a spacious one bedroom & one bath. Recent solar system added for backup lights, fans, TV, internet etc.

Guest favorite

The open kitchen and dining area feature modern finishes and sleek cabinetry. A long island with seating is complemented by pendant lighting, while a dining table with six chairs occupies one side. Tropical plants add a refreshing touch to the space.

Apartment in Marsh Harbour

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Secluded Contemporary 2BR 2BA Suite

Emerald Suite - Experience a true hidden gem with modern finishes and spacious living. This secluded retreat features 2 baths and comes fully loaded with top-of-the-line appliances. Each room boasts a TV for your entertainment. Located on a hill, it offers the tranquility of a private getaway and is only 7 minutes away from the main airport.

Top guest favorite

A two-story blue house is seen with a covered porch and a balcony above the main entrance. Lush green grass surrounds the exterior, while glimpses of the distant sea can be noted beyond the property. The house features white shutters and a welcoming front door.

Home in Marsh Harbour

5 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Outa The Blue - Hill Top Views

You will enjoy the hill-top views from this safe and quiet neighborhood on Pelican Shores. Hill top position provides views of the Sea of Abaco and the Harbour. Access to the Sea of Abaco for swimming. Walking distance to Mermaid’s Reef for snorkeling and the Jib Room for dinner. Close to the ferries for island hopping.

Superhost

A spacious bed with a wooden frame is dressed in neutral linens and a light-colored throw featuring a leaf pattern. An air conditioning unit is mounted above, providing comfort. Light-colored walls and curtains enhance the bright and airy feeling of the room.

Apartment in Marsh Harbour

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Rest Easy Nightly Rental

Enjoy easy access to everything from this perfectly located nightly room rental. A one minute walk from Baker's Bay dock. A two minutes drive from the center of town and the food store. A five minutes ride from the Marsh Harbour Airport. A minute walk from the conch stand and restaurant.

Guest favorite

A panoramic view of the tranquil Sea of Abaco is presented, showcasing clear turquoise waters meeting a blue sky. Lush greenery and palm trees frame the scene, with a gentle sloping lawn leading to the water's edge.

Apartment in Marsh Harbour

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 219 reviews

Oceanfront Apartment/Pelican Shores/Walk to town

Our one bedroom apartment offers a tranquil setting overlooking the turquoise Sea of Abaco. We are a 5 minute walk to Boat Harbour. Located nearby are restaurants, shops and activities which make Seagrape by the Sea a perfect location for exploring the Abacos.