
Vacation rentals in Silver Lake
Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb
Top-rated vacation rentals in Silver Lake
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Bristol Retreat Cottage
Unwind at this romantic getaway nestled in the beautiful Bristol Hills, just minutes away from Bristol Ski Resort, Canandaigua and Honeoye Lakes. This unique 1 bedroom 1 bathroom cottage is one of our two homes on the property along the peacefully flowing Mill Creek. Take in the natural beauty from the large patio and hot tub. Inside, enjoy the warmth of the gas fireplace, complimentary wifi and smartTV. The full kitchen and bathroom are well stocked with amenities to ensure a comfortable stay.

16 Sandals
Come enjoy the friendly neighborhood in our cozy lake front home. Bring your fishing boats, kayaks, canoes and fishing poles! Spend the day on the lake or on our large lake view patio, then unwind at night at our fire pit or in the hot tub! Nearby, you can find a drive-in movie theater, mini golf and ice cream- fun for everyone! In the winter months, bring your snowmobiles to enjoy direct access to hundreds of miles of marked and groomed snowmobile trails including nearby Letchworth State Park.

Offgrid Tiny home with private ponds, Finger lakes
This tiny house is surrounded by forest and ponds, just out of Naples. You will have private access to a pond and 15 acres of forest. In winter you are minutes away from Bristol mountain ski resort and Hunt hollow ski resort. For cross country skiing there is Cummings nature centre down the road. This property is in a prime area with lakes to kayak or fish on, many hiking trails including Grimes Glen, and the wine routes and arts and crafts the finger lakes are known for. 2 nights minimum

Bungalow in Bliss
Enjoy beautiful views from this quaint bungalow, perched on a hillside in the heart of farm country in Wyoming County, NY. Open concept space. Modern appliances. Retro lighting. Adirondack style furniture. Plenty of windows for natural lighting. Enjoy the panoramic view of the sunrise, sunset on the huge, private deck. Plenty of restaurants, convenience store, small towns in any direction, lake, river, parks and hiking trails nearby. Plus, enjoy Letchworth State Park just minutes away!

The Nut House
This apartment is located in a beautiful country setting. There is private parking available for guests. Located on the first floor is the entrance to the hallway. Once inside you will have a private door to enter your private apartment. Outside you can enjoy your private patio in the back, a well kept yard, and very nice gardens. There is no stove, but we do offer amenities for simple cooking and reheating food. We also offer a basic continental breakfast with cereal and coffee.

The Country Cabin
Quiet, peaceful, and private cabin in the woods. Explore 4000 acres of State Land nearby. Hiking, nature walks, or birdwatching. Enjoy cross-country skiing on the nearby state land. Relax by the pond, fish, or take a refreshing swim. Tall Pines ATV Park (11 miles) offers off-road adventures. Hit the slopes at Swain Ski Resort (22 miles) for winter sports. Located near SUNY Alfred and AU (2 Miles), ideal for parents visiting. Perfect for a family vacation or a weekend getaway.

Recently Renovated Lake House on Silver Lake
Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. Enjoy our recently renovated lake house! This all season lake house comfortably sleeps 8… Includes screened in porch with a beautiful view of the lake sunsets! 50 feet of private Lake front with two docks and plenty of green space. Minutes away from Letchworth State Park. Interested in a relaxing round of golf? The Club at Silver Lake, a public course, can be seen across the Lake and is only a few minute drive away.

Peaceful Country Home
A peaceful clean home for you to enjoy!! We have a very nice size yard for camp fires and just relax in without any neighbors.Welcome to a peaceful country home in the middle of several very large ponds. Relax on the covered screened porch or the back deck for peaceful meals or just some bird watching. Not super far off the road but you feel like it. Road is pretty quiet and lots of wild life. Ponds and woods not our property so please stay in yard/ grass only

Lemon Drop Inn" Letchworth /StonyBrook state park
The Lemon drop Inn is close to everything, making it easy to plan your visit Letchworth state park is just a few miles from This beautiful Victorian home. The home is perfectly set up with a two person jacuzzi bathtub with wall fireplace, wine and beer refrigerator within reach. There's a bluetooth speaker to play your own music. Wood burning stove. Whether it's your anniversary or honeymoon. This is the perfect spot to relax and have a romantic getaway!

Pine Hill Hideaway
Pine Hill Hideaway is your romantic escape in the woods and adventure haven in NY’s Southern Tier—just 25 mins from Letchworth State Park and steps from thousands of acres of state forest and wildlife management areas. This cozy luxury cabin features a queen bed, sleeper sofa, kitchen, 3/4 bath, and new AC for warmer months. Hike by day, stargaze by night. Weekend stays book 2–4 months out—reserve early!

Lake Haven
Our family friendly home is nestled in a wooded lot in the quaint historic Silverlake Institute. Just a short walk to the Silver Lake with Public Boat launch and Lake Beach/Swim area. Wonderful open kitchen/dining room with wifi and TVs with cable/Smart TV options. Huge yard with private parking area, picnic table, firepit and games. Spacious covered porches to enjoy in a quaint setting.

Countryside Zen Cottage with remarkable views
Spend a weekend, week or more in this fully furnished, dog friendly, 2 BR with loft country retreat near Rushford Lake, NY. Views, sounds and fresh air of the countryside will facilitate deep relaxation and re-energize. Surround yourself with nature, watch from your second story deck as deer feed in the fields, wild turkey gather and ducks frolic in the pond. This is true country living.
Popular amenities for Silver Lake, Castile vacation rentals
Lake side house rentals in Silver Lake, Castile

The Bungalow on Berkeley - NEW w/Game Room

Wooded Winter Wonderland 2 bedroom house w/hot tub

Private house with plenty of land and lakefront.

Lake front Cottage Silver lake

Luxury Lakefront Escape w/ Pool & Guest House

Lakefront home on Java Lake.

The Silver Lake House

Private 175 ft lake frontage secret cove, magical!
Silver Lake, Castile house rentals

Mud Creek Lodge .1 mi to Bristol Mtn/Hot Tub/Creek

The Creek House Private Home & Scenic Grounds

Cozy Serene 2bd Finger Lakes home w/amazing views

Finger Lakes Getaway

FLX lakeview w/ *NEW HOT TUB*, spacious 3 bd 2bath

Perfect choice for Alfred Univ./A. State visitors!

The Lakeview House in South Bristol

Timber-frame home on 12 wooded acres
Silver Lake, Castile fishing vacation rentals

The Bear Camp on Honeoye Lake

Lime Lake 3 bedroom getaway

A SHORE THING-Lakeview/access brand new apartment.

Quiet place- Beautiful Views

Lakefront cottage minutes from Letchworth

Captain Frank's Lakeside Get Away

Indian Lodge on Rushford Lake

Pond House at Rushford Lake
Quick stats about vacation rentals in Silver Lake

Nightly prices starting at
Silver Lake vacation rentals start at ﺩ.ﺇ404 per night before taxes and fees

Verified guest reviews
Over 410 verified reviews to help you choose

Popular amenities for guests
Guests love Lake access, Free parking on premises, and Gym across Silver Lake rentals

4.9 Average rating
Silver Lake stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!
Destinations to explore
- Letchworth State Park
- Holiday Valley Ski Resort
- Six Flags Darien Lake
- Knox Farm State Park
- Buffalo RiverWorks
- Sea Breeze Amusement Park
- The Strong National Museum of Play
- Bristol Mountain
- Buffalo Harbor State Park
- Stony Brook State Park
- Hamlin Beach State Park
- Keuka Lake State Park
- High Falls
- Hunt Hollow Ski Club
- Keuka Spring Vineyards
- Peace Bridge
- Hunt Country Vineyards
- Granger Homestead and Carriage Museum




