Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Shelter Island

We loved staying at Ann’s place. Exactly like the photos, very close to Sag Harbor and the beach. The cottage has everything you would ever need! We would love to stay again in the future.

Our book club group thoroughly enjoyed our stay here! The home was beautiful and everything was spotless. Everything was as advertised. Beds were very comfortable.

Terrific stay at Ellen’s lovely cottage. The house is warmly decorated and cozy. Amazing patio with outdoor fireplace and big gas grill. Fully equipped kitchen for gourmet cooking. The bathrooms are new and very clean. Lots of delightful and thoughtful little touches. A great base for exploring the North Fork!

What a lovely place! Kitchen was a pleasure to use. Location was great for wineries and Greenport restaurants/bars. Spacious.

Such a great house for a group! Well kept and very accommodating. Will definitely be back

We had another great stay at Claudia's place! This was our third visit to this location, and likely not our last. Thank you!!

We had an amazing time here! The home is very charming, in a great location on the North Fork close to our favorite vineyards and restaurants. Paul was kind enough to offer us an early check in so that we may accommodate our guests traveling to visit! We really enjoyed our stay & made great memories.

Terence reached out to me before I left for NY. Everything was as he described it and I know he would have been happy to answer any further questions I might have. Nice place, great location!

There are not enough stars to give to Nancy and her air b&b. This was our first experience with the app. The room was better than advertised. But what made this even more special was Nancy herself. What a sweet, kind woman. We plan on going back often. Not only to explore the Hampton area. But to make sure we have a drink around the fire pit with Nancy and her husband. Thank you again Nancy. You were awesome.

La maison de Peter et Rory est absolument charmante : confortable, bien équipée et joliment décorée. Le quartier et paisible et les voisins sont charmants. Nous avons visité l'université de Yale : c'était super. Nous remercions vivement Peter et Rory pour la qualité de le leur accueil. Hautement recommandé !

We had a wonderful Valentine's day Weekend at Deborah's. The loft was so cozy and so cute. She allowed us to bring our cat (who also had a blast sleeping in the cozy beds). The hot tub was also super relaxing and Deborah was nice enough to put an orange tarp on top of the tub so it can be a bit covered from the snow (which by the way, super unserious suggestion, a roof over the tub would be amazing). We also enjoyed how close it was to Sag Harbor and some other Vineyards we were able to visit. The property itself was also super peaceful, it was an overall relaxing weekend. Thank you for being such a great host!

Thank you for the lovely accommodations! The space was well appointed and we loved the attention to detail with the decor and amenities. It was the perfect space for us with a living space, kitchen and nice bathroom. The airbnb had everything we needed and more! Thank you, Nina!

It was a pleasure staying at Ezequiel’s home! Perfect location for what we needed. He responded promptly and everything went very smoothly. Thank you!

Our second time staying at Vanessa’s place. It’s absolutely perfect for a girls trip. Great location, clean, and Vanessa is extremely responsive. Can’t wait to come back again!

Dies ist unsere erste AirBnB Erfahrung. Die Kommunikation mit KC im Vorfeld war super. Die Unterkunft ist sehr hübsch eingerichtet, so dass wir uns gleich sehr wohl gefühlt haben. Unseren Kindern hat das Kinderzimmer sehr gut gefallen und mir die Veranda. Unsere Kinder sind sehr aufgeweckt und laut und das ist für Gastgeber sicherlich eine Herausforderung. Wir sind dementsprechend froh, dass es keine Beschwerden gab. Die Gegend ist sehr schön und ruhig. Wir kommen gerne wieder.

Great stay! Perfect location being 10 minutes from everything :)