Vacation rentals in Shelter Island

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 311 reviews

An enclosed outdoor living space features a wooden deck overlooking a heated pool. Furnished with a large round table and comfortable seating, natural light floods through the screens, creating an airy atmosphere. Elegant trees and lounge chairs visible outside enhance the serene environment.

Home in Sagaponack

Amazing Home close to Everything -

Elegantly designed home featuring modern appliances, a seasonal heated pool, and situated just moments away from ocean beaches, Wolffer Vineyard, and the vibrant Bridgehampton/Sag Harbor villages. Set within meticulously curated landscaping, this property embodies perfection and meticulous attention to detail. Familiarize yourself with our disclosures, guidelines, and house rules. We maintain a strict no events, no parties, and no smoking policy — our home and property grouds are smoke-free.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 164 reviews

A light-filled living space is highlighted by a wall of glass, providing expansive views of the water and a natural landscape. The space includes a round coffee table on a light floor, with comfortable seating arranged to enjoy the serene outdoor scenery.

Cottage in North Fork

Savor Ocean Sunsets at a Soothing Beachfront Haven

Newly renovated and featured as a top Airbnb by New York Magazine, The Beach Cottage has been designed and decorated in a modern organic style, with a palette of whites and neutrals to create a serene and peaceful escape. Relax in the airy, light and open living room, which features a wall of glass for indoor/outdoor living with expansive, uninterrupted water views. Stay on the property for swimming, beach walks, sunsets and BBQs - or venture out to enjoy all the North Fork has to offer.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

A comfortable living room area is presented, featuring a light-colored sectional sofa arranged around a wooden coffee table. Natural light enters through a large window, illuminating a piece of artwork on the wall and adding a cozy touch to the space.

Apartment in Sag Harbor

PRIVATE BASEMENT APARTMENT WITH POOL IN SAG HARBOR

Beautiful basement apartment partially in-ground, with many windows and private entrance is located in Sag Harbor , 3 minutes from village and Heavens Bech by car or 15 minutes walking distance . The apartment has king size bed and comfortable sofa in the living room . In the kitchen you can find coffe maker , toaster , microwave, dishwasher, small fridge , hot plate for light cooking . Tv , WiFi , Airconditoining , access to pool from May till end of the September .

A bright living room features a comfortable gray sofa against a neutral wall, complemented by a light-colored rug with geometric patterns. A wooden coffee table sits in front, with a lounge chair nearby. Natural light enters through multiple windows, creating a spacious feel.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 370 reviews

The Sandpiper

Newly renovated 2-Family Home! Located right in Greenport Village providing walking distance to all the restaurants, bars, shopping, coffee shops, and Shelter Island Ferry, Long Island Railroad (LIRR), and Hampton Jitney. My place is close to restaurants and dining, the beach, family-friendly activities, nightlife, and public transport. You’ll love my place because of Location!. My place is good for couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, families (with kids).

Guest suite in North Fork

A wooden tray is centered on a neatly made bed, featuring a book and a coffee cup. The bed is dressed with a white quilt, and a softly textured pillow is placed against the headboard. A bedside lamp provides gentle illumination.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Comfortable Suite, a walk to the beach

Keep it simple at this spacious and peaceful home. Built in 2019, this home was specially designed for sustainable, green living; ground-source heating, and super insulation allow for minimal environmental impact. Less than five minute walk to McCabe’s Beach. Very near to wineries, farms, and the quaint shops and bakeries of Southold and Greenport. Little Fish restaurant and oyster sales all down the street. Short drive from Sparkling Pointe vineyard, and Love Lane.

A bright living area features light-colored walls and wooden flooring. A comfortable sofa and a plush chair are arranged around a rustic coffee table. A ceiling fan hangs above, while a kitchen with a blue island is visible in the background, enhancing the space's openness.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

Modern Farmhouse Steps to Beach & Love Lane

Our home is professionally designed and set on a spacious, manicured green parcel enclosed by a Cul-de-sac with complete privacy inside and out. The home is designed with all modern conveniences and is located less than a 5 minute walk to Love Lane (Mattituck's charming downtown), Veteran's Beach (one of the best beaches on the Northfork) and the Mattituck train station. It is a place to relax, unwind and enjoy all that North Fork has to offer.

Guesthouse in Shelter Island

A serene saltwater pool is framed by lush greenery and blooming flowers, enhancing the outdoor space. A hot tub is positioned alongside, inviting relaxation. The guest house is visible in the background, surrounded by trees and well-maintained landscaping.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

Bayfront 1BR/2BR detached guesthouse with pool

Perfect relaxing getaway for a couple or family. Bayfront 1BR/2BR fully detached guest house with gorgeous morning views. Property has saltwater pool + hot tub (open May -October) and bay access via private dock. Central to both north & south forks (wineries + Hamptons or Montauk just short drive away). Down the road from famous Shelter Island Sunset Beach + golf course. Come explore the beauty of the Hamptons without the stress!

A clear blue saltwater pool is surrounded by a landscaped yard featuring green grass and shrubs. Several lounge chairs are positioned nearby under light blue umbrellas, providing shade. A two-story house is visible in the background, framed by tall trees.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 220 reviews

Greenport Beach house Mini Resort Spa & Catering

Nestled steps from the beach, and all that Greenport and the North Fork has to offer, this exquisitely charming 3 bedroom 2 bathroom waterfront home is absolutely delightful.. You’ll love my place because of the views, the location, the people, the ambiance, the outdoors space, and the Saltwater pool.. My place is good for couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, families (with kids), groups, and furry friends (pets).

A rocky shoreline is framed by a silhouetted tree against a colorful sunset. Clouds display shades of pink and orange as the sun sets over the water, creating a serene atmosphere. The beach area offers a peaceful view of nature.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Shelter Island Getaway with Cozy Fireplace

Just 2 blocks from Hay Beach, our family & pet-friendly 3BR home offers space to relax & play. Enjoy a large yard w/ fire pits, beach gear, games, & toddler toys. Inside: open living area, fireplace, full kitchen, 2 baths, playroom, workout space, & extra sleeping options. Quiet neighborhood, perfect for families. Winter stays: cozy up by the fire & enjoy $0 cleaning fee Nov–Mar. Host lives next door for quick support.

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 270 reviews

An outdoor patio features multiple wooden lounge chairs arranged around a central fire pit. A gunite pool with clear water reflects the surrounding greenery. The main house, visible in the background, showcases a classic design with white siding and large windows.

Home in Sag Harbor

Exclusive Sag Harbor Compound

A private country compound in heart of Sag Harbor. House just gut renovated with all top of line (all Wolf and Subzero appliances). The main house is 3 bedrooms, 3.5 bath main house PLUS separate large guest cottage (with a King bed, bar fridge, and full bathroom). Gunite pool (i.e., salt chlorinated which makes it feels like clean freshwater). Walk to town, bay beach, public tennis courts, 1000 acre nature preserve.

The exterior of a two-story house is depicted, featuring a light-colored facade with a welcoming front porch. Clear blue skies and greenery surround the property, while the lawn is well-maintained, offering a spacious area in front of the house.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Hamptons - Shelter Island Farmhouse

Kid friendly! Perfect two family split! Come enjoy our island retreat. Relax with the whole family at this peaceful pad. You will be 2 min on bike from Wades Beach. You can also walk to the best BBQ/seafood in Shelter, Commander Codys. Features a large open kitchen/dining room plus also a spacious living room. 4 bedrooms with new mattresses, huge outdoor patio for family BBQs. No dogs please.

Guest suite in North Fork

The exterior of a historic Tudor home is shown, featuring a blend of brick and wood accents. A winding driveway leads to the entrance, surrounded by lush greenery and a decorative black fence. Trees provide shade, enhancing the serene outdoor setting.

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 689 reviews

Walk to Vineyards, Beaches, Farms & Town

Private bungalow with a separate entrance in a historical tudor home. Spacious bedroom with king-sized bed, kitchenette and bathroom. Two bikes, cable TV, internet, AC, beach towels, parking, snacks, coffee and water all provided. Walking distance to the beach, restaurants, shops, vineyards, grocery, farms and fish market. Jitney stop is one block away!

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Houses

A space thats all yours, with room for everyone

Hotels

Stylish accommodations with great services and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Popular amenities for Shelter Island vacation rentals

Gym

BBQ grill

Laptop-friendly workspace

Wifi

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Shelter Island

Superhost

A spacious backyard is bordered by lush greenery and has a view of the tranquil water. Two surfboards are propped against the house, and a set of bright pink chairs surrounds a dining table. Pathways made of stones lead to the water's edge.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Waterfront shelter island gem

Cottage in Shelter Island

A wooden dock extends over calm bay waters, leading towards a small boat anchored in the distance. Lush greenery lines the shoreline, and a clear blue sky complements the serene landscape. Birds are seen casually swimming near the water’s edge.

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 69 reviews

Large Waterfront Cottage on Historic Estate

The main house is framed by lush greenery and large trees, sitting on expansive lawns. Spacious outdoor seating is positioned in front, providing a serene view of the property against a clear blue sky.

5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

6-acre Hidden Estate for 10 w/FP, Pool, Chef's Kit

A beachfront house with a wooden exterior is depicted, featuring multiple windows adorned with green planters. Soft sand covers the area in front, leading to the water, which reflects the clear blue sky. A small chair is visible on the sand, emphasizing the serene beach setting.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

The Sandy Shack - Coastal Escape

The beachfront home features a wrap-around balcony and large windows that provide views of the shore. The exterior is surrounded by a stone wall and sandy beach, with a staircase leading down to the water from the deck.

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Kayaks ~ Bikes ~ Boards ~ 6mins> Greenport ~ 55"TV

A charming two-story house is surrounded by well-maintained greenery, showcasing a wraparound porch with multiple entry points. The exterior features wooden paneling, with large windows allowing natural light. Trees and shrubs frame the property, contributing to the serene setting.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Beautiful Home on Shelter Island

An expansive outdoor area features a heated pool and hot tub, surrounded by lush greenery and tall trees. Lounge chairs with umbrellas are positioned nearby, set against a backdrop of vibrant grass and shaded by mature trees, creating a serene space for relaxation.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Newly Renovated w/ Pool, Hot tub & Fireplace