Guidebook for Montauk

Lawrence
Guidebook for Montauk

Food Scene

Old school bakery, coffee. Our kids love it. Cookies, Scones, etc.
16 locals recommend
Montauk Bake Shoppe
29 The Plaza
16 locals recommend
Old school bakery, coffee. Our kids love it. Cookies, Scones, etc.
Healthy, good food. Made to order to stakes a while. Call in an order.
20 locals recommend
Joni's
South Elmwood Avenue
20 locals recommend
Healthy, good food. Made to order to stakes a while. Call in an order.
Walking distance. Bands, sometimes. Small plates.
16 locals recommend
Swallow East
474 W Lake Dr
16 locals recommend
Walking distance. Bands, sometimes. Small plates.
High end, seafood. Used to be an old lobster shack that is now fancy, but if you are in the mood for St. Barts, it is worth overpaying for lunch or dinner. Still serving lobster and fries. Beautiful setting.
77 locals recommend
Duryea's Lobster Deck
65 Tuthill Rd
77 locals recommend
High end, seafood. Used to be an old lobster shack that is now fancy, but if you are in the mood for St. Barts, it is worth overpaying for lunch or dinner. Still serving lobster and fries. Beautiful setting.
Fish, Sushi, Kid-friendly. Old school Fish / Clam house. Good food. Touch tank for kids outside. Bands sometimes. Can be loud.
14 locals recommend
Westlake Fish House
352 W Lake Dr
14 locals recommend
Fish, Sushi, Kid-friendly. Old school Fish / Clam house. Good food. Touch tank for kids outside. Bands sometimes. Can be loud.
Good food. Great atmosphere. Often a long wait, so consider going early. Terrific sunset. Not packed like Surf Lodge, etc. Expensive, but you are paying for the atmosphere, which is right on as long as the crowd isn't too annoying. This was an old musty lobster shack when I was a kid. No longer.
94 locals recommend
The Crow's Nest
4 Old West Lake Dr
94 locals recommend
Good food. Great atmosphere. Often a long wait, so consider going early. Terrific sunset. Not packed like Surf Lodge, etc. Expensive, but you are paying for the atmosphere, which is right on as long as the crowd isn't too annoying. This was an old musty lobster shack when I was a kid. No longer.
Very good bagels. Also has sandwiches for lunch. Another branch in town.
Goldberg's
57 Kirk Avenue
Very good bagels. Also has sandwiches for lunch. Another branch in town.
Left Hand Coffee (by the Harbor)
57 Flamingo Avenue
Organic market with healthy breakfast & lunch too. Lots of Vegan options
32 locals recommend
Naturally Good
779 Montauk Hwy
32 locals recommend
Organic market with healthy breakfast & lunch too. Lots of Vegan options
Good for a quick bite
6 locals recommend
Tacombi
752 Montauk Hwy
6 locals recommend
Good for a quick bite
Nearby Mexican joint by the docks. Popular local spot. Good with kids or without. Food is ok plus. Atmosphere relaxed and a little gritty. Indoor/outdoor. We go often.
18 locals recommend
The Hideaway
364 W Lake Dr
18 locals recommend
Nearby Mexican joint by the docks. Popular local spot. Good with kids or without. Food is ok plus. Atmosphere relaxed and a little gritty. Indoor/outdoor. We go often.
Standard plus, has your staples and very close. Some organic food too.
The Market | Montauk
463 W Lake Dr
Standard plus, has your staples and very close. Some organic food too.
Eat outside.
9 locals recommend
Gosman's Clam Bar
484 W Lake Dr
9 locals recommend
Eat outside.
49 locals recommend
Clam Bar At Napeague
2025 Montauk Hwy
49 locals recommend
Old school ice cream shop. High recommend, especially with kids.
28 locals recommend
John's Drive-In
677 Montauk Hwy
28 locals recommend
Old school ice cream shop. High recommend, especially with kids.
Nice outdoor lunch
49 locals recommend
Navy Beach
16 Navy Rd
49 locals recommend
Nice outdoor lunch

Shopping

High end spot for fresh fish (ask what's fresh, usually scallops, striped bass, squid, black fish, black bass), meat, prepared foods (sesame noodles), local vegetables.
22 locals recommend
Gosman's Retail Fish Market
484 W Lake Dr
22 locals recommend
High end spot for fresh fish (ask what's fresh, usually scallops, striped bass, squid, black fish, black bass), meat, prepared foods (sesame noodles), local vegetables.
Supermarket for regular stuff.
27 locals recommend
IGA
95 S Emerson Ave
27 locals recommend
Supermarket for regular stuff.

Parks & Nature

Walk around the light house, nice shop. Great kids playground
257 locals recommend
Montauk Point Lighthouse
2000 Montauk Hwy
257 locals recommend
Walk around the light house, nice shop. Great kids playground
Great playground
Montauk Public School
50 S Dorset Dr
Great playground
Terrific beach. Public Parking for a small fee. Worth it.
50 locals recommend
Hither Hills State Park
164 Old Montauk Highway
50 locals recommend
Terrific beach. Public Parking for a small fee. Worth it.
Surfing beach. Crowded, fun scene. Need a parking pass.
79 locals recommend
Ditch Plains Beach
18 Ditch Plains Rd
79 locals recommend
Surfing beach. Crowded, fun scene. Need a parking pass.