Restaurants and deliveries
Food scene
Carribean. Reserve in advance! Spicing up the Long Island waterfront, RUMBA is a special dining spot serving up a unique combination of Island-inspired food, premium handcrafted rum libations, happy staffers, reggae and a low-key vibe all on the Shinnecock Bay
159 locals recommend
RUMBA Inspired Island Cuisine & Rum Bar
43 Canoe Place RdCarribean. Reserve in advance! Spicing up the Long Island waterfront, RUMBA is a special dining spot serving up a unique combination of Island-inspired food, premium handcrafted rum libations, happy staffers, reggae and a low-key vibe all on the Shinnecock Bay
American. Great spot for brunch, lunch and dinner. Reserve in advance! Nice water views, a kids play area outside, indoor seating, outdoor bar and patio overlooking the canal. Kid friendly atmosphere.
201 locals recommend
Cowfish
258 E Montauk HwyAmerican. Great spot for brunch, lunch and dinner. Reserve in advance! Nice water views, a kids play area outside, indoor seating, outdoor bar and patio overlooking the canal. Kid friendly atmosphere.
For a quick bite. Shack with deck overlooking the marina and the Shinnecock Canal. They make a great Lobster Roll in a ciabatta bread, voted Best Lobster Roll by Dan's Papers! Enjoy the gorgeous views and a laid-back vibe.
64 locals recommend
Canal Cafe
44 Newtown RoadFor a quick bite. Shack with deck overlooking the marina and the Shinnecock Canal. They make a great Lobster Roll in a ciabatta bread, voted Best Lobster Roll by Dan's Papers! Enjoy the gorgeous views and a laid-back vibe.
Soothing views and fabulous food. Dine on the deck, one of the most desired vantages overlooking Shinnecock Bay, or inside where the expanse of windows provides gorgeous views along with a bright, open atmosphere.
69 locals recommend
Edgewater Restaurant
295 E Montauk HwySoothing views and fabulous food. Dine on the deck, one of the most desired vantages overlooking Shinnecock Bay, or inside where the expanse of windows provides gorgeous views along with a bright, open atmosphere.
Great place for American breakfast and brunch. Everything is good, and some of our favorites are their pancakes and omelets. Same as above… reserve in advance
50 locals recommend
The Hampton Maid
259 E Montauk HwyGreat place for American breakfast and brunch. Everything is good, and some of our favorites are their pancakes and omelets. Same as above… reserve in advance
Pricey but great for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Elegant Italian eatery serving great croissants and pastries, amazing panini, gelato & refined dishes for dinner.
83 locals recommend
Sant Ambroeus
30 Main StPricey but great for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Elegant Italian eatery serving great croissants and pastries, amazing panini, gelato & refined dishes for dinner.
Thin-crust pizza, pasta & light Italian fare served in a hip trattoria with a people-watching patio.
47 locals recommend
Serafina East Hampton
104 North Main StreetThin-crust pizza, pasta & light Italian fare served in a hip trattoria with a people-watching patio.
Gemelli Gelato is a beautiful Gelato shop located in Hampton Bays. Enjoy outdoor seating!
16 locals recommend
Gemelli Gelato
139 W Montauk HwyGemelli Gelato is a beautiful Gelato shop located in Hampton Bays. Enjoy outdoor seating!
Grindstone Coffee & Donuts
7 Main StSome of the best donuts in the area!
Enjoy the famous and delicious Tate’s cookies! Also has vegan & gluten-free options.
76 locals recommend
Tate's Bake Shop
43 N Sea RdEnjoy the famous and delicious Tate’s cookies! Also has vegan & gluten-free options.
Food delivery
For the best Lobster rolls, and a really good Lobster bisque.
10 locals recommend
Shinnecock Lobster Factory
42 Montauk HwyFor the best Lobster rolls, and a really good Lobster bisque.
Salvatores of the Hamptons
149 W Montauk HwyItalians / pizza. Great both on site and for delivery