Vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

The spacious kitchen features light green cabinetry, a large island with seating for three, and modern pendant lighting. A coffee station is present, along with stainless steel appliances, offering a welcoming environment for meal preparation and gathering.

Home in Geneva

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Sand V-Ball Ct w/ Vineyard Views SPIRE 5 Min

MaureenRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Great place for family get away. Good location, clean, bright and spacious. The kitchen was roomy, had everything we needed and was perfect for playing games. We had a group of 8 adults and had plenty of room. We all agreed we would definitely come back

Guest favorite

A wooden sign stands at the entrance of Pat Crawford Beach, featuring white lettering against a dark brown background. Surrounding the sign, green grass and shrubs enhance the setting, with a view of the sandy beach and lake visible in the background.

Cottage in Edinboro

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

The Cove, cozy cottage by Edinboro Lake

ReneeRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

The Cove was a delightful stay for my husband and I. I especially appreciated that this location was pet friendly and a great place to bring our dog. Lots of space, quiet, and cozy. We also appreciated her responsiveness to the front porch lights being burnt out- this was taken care of immediately the next day and we extremely grateful for the care shown by our host. Would absolutely book again!

Top guest favorite

A serene view out of the window showcases a calm lake at dusk, framed by lace curtains. Soft twilight colors reflect off the water, with silhouettes of trees and nearby structures visible along the shoreline.

Apartment in Findley Lake

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Becker Rentals

LeahRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Leanne’s place was so cozy and a great stay for a weekend spent skiing at Peek n peak resort! She was so kind and always responded quickly to any questions we had. She was flexible for our check in and check out times which is really appreciated! Would definitely recommend staying here.

Guest favorite

A spacious deck is shown overlooking the lake, framed by lush greenery. A stone table is surrounded by metal chairs, with colorful flower pots decorating the railing. The water's reflective surface and trees enhance the calming atmosphere, creating a serene outdoor setting.

Cottage in Findley Lake

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

Just another day in paradise

RandyRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Beautiful lake setting even for a rainy March weekend. Did get to enjoy fire on the 1 dry evening. Seating for meals was limited but outside table would help in warmer months. Also lower level bedrooms could be warmer. Loved the decor of old school local items.

Guest favorite

A snow-covered deck surrounds a hot tub with steam rising gently from the surface. The scene features wooden safety steps leading to the tub and a sturdy bench partially blanketed in snow. Soft glowing lights can be seen strung across the railing.

Apartment in Madison

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Cozy winery getaway with hot tub!

DanaRating, 5 stars4 days ago

We really enjoyed our second stay at Patricia’s home. Lovely, private space that’s quiet and very conveniently located to so many parks and wineries. Lots to do and see and the hot tub is perfect for unwinding after a day of wine tastings or the beach. We would definitely love to come back soon!

Guest favorite

An inviting seating area is positioned alongside the water, with two chairs and a small table visible. Natural light streams through an open doorway, enhancing the serene lakefront view. Wooden walls and a striped rug provide a cozy and rustic ambiance.

Cottage in Findley Lake

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Hidden Cove

CindyRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Had an amazing quiet get away! Everyone in town was friendly and helpful! The cottage was clean, well stocked and had more than we could have imagined. Looking forward to a future stay when the weather is warmer! We had everything we needed and more to recharge our batteries.

Guest favorite

A small cottage features a light gray exterior with white trim and a front porch. Two wooden chairs are placed on the porch, while a tree provides shade nearby. The entrance is framed by two windows, and the cottage is surrounded by a neatly landscaped area.

Cottage in Geneva

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

Serene Suite right on the GOTL Strip!

BarryRating, 5 stars5 months ago

Rina was extremely responsive, especially since I booked very late in the day. she also explained some questions I had about the charge structure which I was concerned with, but that was only the way Airbnb presented it. the place was perfect and had everything I needed. i would definitely stay there again and highly recommend the place and the host!

Guest favorite

A serene view of the lake is presented, with lush greenery framing the scene. A large tree stands prominently, while the calm water reflects the surrounding nature. In the distance, various boats and lakeside structures are visible, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere.

Home in Lake Milton

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 88 reviews

Scenic Shores Guest Lake House with dock.

LukeRating, 5 stars3 months ago

Stayed at 294 Shore Dr. from 12/24–1/2 and had a great experience! The house is super convenient, with easy freeway access and beautiful views of Lake Milton. It was the perfect spot to rest, shower, and recharge after spending our days out and about. The home had everything we needed, and the hosts clearly put thought into making guests comfortable. Highly recommend this spot for anyone looking for a cozy and convenient stay in the area!

Superhost

A spacious deck overlooks the tranquil waters of Lake Erie, featuring a circular table surrounded by metal chairs. Two red and blue lounge chairs are situated nearby, providing comfortable seating for relaxation and enjoying panoramic views of the lake.

Cottage in Geneva

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

Lake Front Oasis with Breathtaking Lake Erie Views

ChrissyRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

Wow! What an adorable cottage right on the literal edge of Lake Erie! Wonderful sunset views right from the swing or back porch. Kitchen had everything needed to cook, bathroom had everything needed to shower, and bedroom had everything needed to sleep comfortably. Extra blankets and thin and full pillows for a great choice. Just a wonderful place to stay if you’re wanting to be in the Geneva area. Geneva State Park and Headlands Park were close by and have good walking trails and beaches. We went in the off season so everything was pretty quiet - just the way we like it.

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

Sunny Daze: Updated cozy cottage near Midway Beach

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews8 months ago

The home was beautiful, very comfortable and my family felt right at home. Very walkable neighborhood and it was great for walking the dogs. Private fenced in back yard with two decks. Great selection of board games for us to play. Washer and dryer. The owner communicate ahead of time, made us aware of how to access the home and the guest book. Super great to have! Restaurant locations and things to do. Very responsive with questions about boat, kayak and wave runner rentals. Couldn’t have been happier with our stay.

Cottage in Conneaut Lake

What guests are saying

Dreamy Home on Lake Erie

5 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews5 months ago

This place really felt like our home away from home. My kids especially felt comfortable and enjoyed the main living area and games the most. I appreciated the attention to detail. It’s rare to get a rental that included everything (toiletries, kitchen spices, etc.). It made packing so much easier. I will definitely be renting another place by Janelle when we go back to Erie!

Cottage in Erie

What guests are saying

Mermaid Inn romantic house on the lake

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews6 months ago

Anna thought of everything someone might need for a “home away from home.” The place was beautifully decorated with everything seemingly brand new. It was a very comfortable and peaceful place to hang out. Being outside was so relaxing. We enjoyed the pond and the backdrop of woods with changing autumn leaves. It was the perfect location being so close to the outlets and restaurants too.

Cottage in Mercer

What guests are saying

Nature's Nest: A peaceful and relaxing get away

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews5 months ago

We had an amazing stay! The home was incredibly well-supplied with everything we needed and more – from kitchen essentials to cozy blankets. The hosts clearly put thought into every detail, making it easy to settle in and relax. The location was perfect: set in a quiet, friendly neighborhood surrounded by nature, which made it feel like a real getaway. We loved sitting on the porch in the mornings, enjoying the peace. The proximity to local sights and Lake Erie was also a huge plus. We highly recommend this place for anyone looking to unwind in a comfortable, serene environment!

Home in Ashtabula

What guests are saying

4 BDRM Double Cottages Sleeps 10 on The GOTL Strip

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews8 months ago

Great place but for the price paid you would expect high end. This town has very expensive prices for lower quality than most areas. That being. Said the place was clean, neat and nice. Just not high end, no granite, it’s a double wide home, plastic showers. Would have loved more mirrors. Only mirrors in the bathrooms. When you have 10 people in a house it’s nice to have mirrors in bedrooms or common areas. Needed a stand or two in bedrooms as there was nothing to put your suitcase on. Had to keep it on the floor. Great outdoor area, pizza oven, fire pit and smoker all available. Would be helpful to have a keypad door lock on the back door as well as the front door, as you had to walk around the house each time to lock the door, as parking was in the back.

Cottage in Geneva

What guests are saying

Lake Life 2BD in heart of GOTL

4.71 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews7 months ago

One of the best Airbnb’s I’ve stayed at! I would recommend this place to anyone who enjoys being in walking distance of everything and anything you want. Very clear instructions were sent out before arrival and the place was spotless. The loft was very spacious and fit everyone comfortably. Thank you for an awesome stay!

Apartment in Geneva

What guests are saying

AMAZING Lake Road location!!!

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews6 months ago

We had a really nice stay at Jane’s place. The home was clean, comfortable, and had everything we needed. The location was convenient and in a quiet area. Jane was easy to communicate with and made sure we had what we needed. Overall, it was a great stay, and we’d recommend this place to others and we would definitely stay there again.

Home in Conneaut

What guests are saying

Geneva-On-The -Lake through the seasons

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews7 months ago

The condo was very nice. It's in a great location easy to walk to the strip or the walking trail at the lodge. The kitchen had everything that you would need to cook. I loved the directors chairs that was on the porch and it was a beautiful view of the lake.

Condo in Geneva-on-the-Lake

1 of 12 pages

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Cottages

Quaint homes, peaceful surroundings

Cabins

Kick off your hiking boots at these rustic lodgings

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Popular amenities for Pymatuning Reservoir vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Top guest favorite

Home in Geneva

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews

Wooded Creek Retreat ~Getaway | Geneva on the Lake

AngelaRating, 5 stars2 months ago

What a fantastic house. It was so close to the lake and park to the lake. The whole house was clean and inviting. We had no issues. The host was very responsive. We spent a lot of time in the basement listening to music, shooting pool, playing card games and just hanging out. I would absolutely stay at this location again. It was as described and very close to it all. Thank you for having us!!

Guest favorite

Apartment in Conneaut Lake

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 83 reviews

Lovely, Two Bedroom Apartment with tons of space

JuliaRating, 5 stars4 days ago

The airbnb was clean and beautiful. It looked exactly like the photos and had a ton of space. The co-host Will was always reachable and responded timely with questions, etc.

Guest favorite

A large covered deck is showcased with a bright sun casting rays over the scene. Comfortable seating options, including white lounge chairs and a larger dining table, are visible. Lush greenery surrounds the area, enhancing the outdoor space.

Cottage in Linesville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Pymatuning Lake Cottage - Walk to the Lake

DakotaRating, 5 stars8 months ago

Matt’s place was perfect for my family and I we enjoyed the privacy while being close to everything we were there to do! Very responsive and made us feel at home will definitely stay again in the future.

Guest favorite

An outdoor deck area features a dining table surrounded by four metal chairs, set against a backdrop of lush greenery. The space is illuminated by natural light, creating a serene environment that connects with the surrounding trees and landscape.

Home in Warren

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Serene Retreat Near The Grand Resort

KellyRating, 5 stars4 months ago

This AirB&B was my husbands childhood home. Jim purchased this home from my Mother in Law about 2 years ago. It was fun having all her grandchildren stay there while we had lots of guest in the area for my husbands Retirement party. House was in good shape and we enjoyed the stay very much.

Top guest favorite

A modern hot tub features bubbling water, with jets creating a soothing flow. The sleek surface and well-maintained design invite relaxation, set against a neutral backdrop that enhances the tranquil atmosphere.

Home in Sebring

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 248 reviews

“Little Mansion” with Private Hot Tub Patio

CameronRating, 5 stars3 days ago

We loved staying at Kevin’s place, very helpful when we had anything to ask. Place was clean, beautiful and relaxing! Couldn’t say one negative thing! Hope to be back soon!

Top guest favorite

A deck railing is covered with fresh snow, while soft yellow lights add a warm glow. Snow-covered trees and a tranquil landscape create a serene winter scene. A road is visible in the distance, surrounded by a blanket of white.

Home in Clymer

5 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Haasienda Slopeside Condo

TomRating, 5 stars3 months ago

Perfect for what we were looking for. Very convenient ski in/out right off the slopes. Very responsive host and very clean.

Guest favorite

An indoor swimming pool is highlighted by natural wood beams and stone accents. Soft lighting from hanging fixtures casts a warm ambiance. Lounge chairs and a round table with a water bottle are positioned nearby, creating a welcoming space for relaxation.

Condo in Clymer

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Home Away From Home at Peek n Peak

SarahRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We had an amazing stay here! Perfect for ski in and ski out!

Guest favorite

A group of five individuals is seen walking down a quiet road bordered by greenery. In the background, a large, striking house with a symmetrical facade and multiple windows is visible, along with a tranquil lake beyond the property.

Home in Conneaut Lake

5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Lakeside Landing

KarenRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Plenty of room, very comfortable. Although we didn’t cook there much, everything we needed was available. The fenced yard was very convenient for our two dogs. Bed was very comfortable. I would definitely stay here again when visiting our Granddaughter at Allegheny College.

Show all

Vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Top-rated vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Sunny Daze: Updated cozy cottage near Midway Beach

Dreamy Home on Lake Erie

Mermaid Inn romantic house on the lake

Nature's Nest: A peaceful and relaxing get away

The Inn at Lakewood Beach Retreat

Lake view cottage w hot tub & AC

Ashtabula Harbor Retreat

4 BDRM Double Cottages Sleeps 10 on The GOTL Strip

Lake Life 2BD in heart of GOTL

AMAZING Lake Road location!!!

Lake View Cottage ~ GOTL | Wineries | Spire

Geneva-On-The -Lake through the seasons

Vacation rentals for every style

Popular amenities for Pymatuning Reservoir vacation rentals

Other great vacation rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Destinations to explore