Vacation rentals in Protestant Cay

Another terrific stay at the Bonney.! Water main replacement has been completed on Queen street and the surface is surprising smooth. Parking was never an issue. As always, the building, grounds and our room were perfect (we're not disclosing which one because we hope to book the same week next year!), and quiet. Brittany Sue and staff are extremely attentive. We had several memorable meals, including at old timers like Duggan's Reef, the Bombay Club and Rainbow Beach (now Rhythms). Very happy all are still going strong. Hamilton's, of course, and we finally got up to the Mt. Pellier Domino Club - not for the pigs, for the food and ambiance. St. George Village Botanical Garden and Estate Mt. Washington are stops we make on every trip.

We had an amazing stay at this unit! It was so peaceful and quiet, which was exactly what we were looking for. The view of the ocean was absolutely stunning, and we spent a lot of time enjoying it. The pool was fantastic and a perfect place to relax. Melanie and Steve were super friendly and made us feel right at home. Use Melanie’s guidelines, they were incredibly helpful and made navigating the area a breeze. We loved being away from the hustle and bustle of the city—it was the perfect escape. Everything we needed was provided, and the unit was fully equipped with all the amenities. Highly recommend grabbing a bite at Blue's Backyard BBQ—delicious! Overall, a fantastic experience, and we would love to return!

The location is amazing. Snorkeling in a beautiful place with thousands of tropical fish right outside the back door. Loved the spiral staircase and cozy upstairs loft. Great for kids. Everything else was comfortable and delightful.

My teenage kids and I have adopted Gabrielles place as our home away from home. When we ponder staying elsewhere the thought is quickly dismissed as it just wouldn’t feel right to be anywhere else! From getting to know downtown Christiansted and the Boardwalk intimately -rich with restaurants, shops and personality to sitting in her peaceful Courtyard either quietly on our private patio or visiting with Gabrielle and other guests at the community table the space is perfect. She truly has created a magically warm and welcoming space as a home base for your visit.

Had a wonderful time at Susan’s place in St. Croix! The unit is in a peaceful neighborhood convenient to town. It’s very clean and modern on the inside and the mini-splits operate quietly and will keep you comfortable at night. The only issue I had was the directions from the app took me to a house on the next street over, but I just drove around the corner and noticed the green and white house from the pictures. Susan was very nice and easy to communicate with. Overall, it was a very relaxing experience.

Shawn's place is a wonderful piece of paradise. The location is perfect and so close to all the fun. The pool and hot tub are lovely. We are glad to hear the restaurant is reopening soon. The condo is exactly as described and kept very clean. The views from the balcony are just heavenly. It was the perfect spot. Shawn is very responsive and a great host. We highly recommend and cannot wait to return. We liked it so much that we are dreaming of owning our own slice of this resort. The pictures are so accurate but must be experienced in person to truly appreciate.

100% would recommend. Went with a group of 7 and felt very comfortable. Place is spacious, peaceful and clean. The hosts are lovely and very attentive. It's also a great location; we could get to our activities in less than 20 mins, no matter what part of the island it was. Whenever I go back to St.Croix I'll definitely consider staying here again.

quiet, beachfront location (best beach out of all the condos nearby), Leslie had everything we needed for our stay. The refrigerator was a little warm and feezer was slow to freeze items at times, but overall we are extremely happy with the experience. Would definitely come back here to stay if coming back to St Croix.

Nadia was an amazing host. Thanks for allowing us to stay at your property. St Croix is beautiful and really enjoyed our time on the island.