Vacation rentals in Preston-Potter Hollow

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Preston-Potter Hollow

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favorite
A comfortable living area features a white sofa paired with a woven coffee table and poufs. Natural light enters through large windows dressed with light curtains. A TV is mounted on the wall, alongside decorative artwork and a corner lamp that provides additional illumination.
Home in Durham
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Charming retreat near Windham NY

Welcome to the Durso House, our charming (and quirky) newly renovated home ten minutes from Windham, NY. If the outdoors are your thing, we are minutes from skiing, hiking, and all the activities that the "Gem of the Catskills" has to offer. If you're looking for a retreat in the country, away from the rigors of city life, then you are also invited to make our abode your cozy (and romantic) retreat. Conveniently located off Route 23, simply zip out the door and let the adventures begin (or not)!

Top guest favorite
A living area features a cozy gas fireplace framed by a white mantel. Comfortable seating is provided with a gray armchair, vibrant red chairs, and a green ottoman in the center. A dining table for two stands to one side, with artful wall decor enhancing the ambiance.
Cottage in Gilboa
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 352 reviews

Home Alone Mountain

Home Alone Mountain is a cozy cottage in a peaceful country setting. The house beautifully located in the small vacation community with a mountain view. Enjoy the privacy and tranquility of the 1,5 acre meadow adjacent to the state forest, take on the stroll in the woods, wander around the historic villages, take a swim in the pond, enjoy the open roads on a bicycle or visit Windham and Hunter villages. Find us on Instagrm @upstay z, #upstay z, #homealonemountain to learn more about the area.

Top guest favorite
A cozy living room features floral-patterned armchairs and a sofa, complemented by a low coffee table. A lamp provides soft lighting, and artwork hangs on the walls, enhancing the warm decor. A textured rug covers the floor, adding comfort to the space.
Home in Catskill
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 192 reviews

Cheerful Catskill Village Cottage

Bright and airy Catskill village refuge - a wildflower and wildlife haven in the thick of things. Historic house set on a quarter acre of trees and wildflowers, but blocks from Main Street, Catskill. Walk to Foreland, The Lumberyard, the incredible village cemetery, Thomas Cole House, restaurants and shops. Olana State Historic Site is right across the bridge! Cottage has a full kitchen, clawfoot tub, penny tile shower, front porch, dining room and large living room. Truly peaceful and lovely.

Guest favorite
Condo in Windham
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 228 reviews

Hideaway Windham/Hunter Fireplace, Snow & Skiing

Spacious 1BR condo for a max. of 4 guests , sleeps 2 in separate bedroom , additional 2 on an inflatable airbed . Balcony with mountain view ,2 tennis courts ,outdoor pool . Awesome location . Windham and Hunter within reach .Get close to nature in the nearby hiking trails, Windham Path, Kaaterskill Falls. Kayaking on North-South Lake or ziplining in Hunter,skiing ,snowboarding ,golfing and mountain biking . Leave your worries at home and come to relax.Enjoy many dining options in town.

Superhost
The cottage is set against a backdrop of rolling hills, with a serene pond reflecting the landscape. Lush green lawn is bordered by trees showing autumn hues. A wrap-around porch offers an inviting space to enjoy the surrounding natural beauty.
Cabin in Middleburgh
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 331 reviews

Thyme Cottage-Winter Getaway

Our cottage is located in an idyllic mountain setting surrounded by spectacular & breathtaking views. The 7 acre property boasts a serene pond stocked with koi, carp & gold fish that can be viewed from the wrap-around porch. It is conveniently located within close proximity to numerous options for dining and activities such as boating, fishing, hiking, & antiquing at local shops and flea markets. Thyme Cottage is perfect for couples, solo adventurers or anyone looking for tranquility.

Guest favorite
The log-built chalet is surrounded by lush greenery and rolling hills. A spacious porch wraps around the house, and a fire pit with seating is visible in the foreground, providing a welcoming outdoor space amidst the natural landscape.
Chalet in Gilboa
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 186 reviews

3BR/2BA Chalet w/ Views on 22 Acres Near Windham

Ski at Windham Mountain Club and stay with us just 7 miles away at this modern 3-bedroom/4-bed/2-bath modern log chalet perched high along the northernmost edge of Mt. Pisgah offering panoramic views and 22 acres of seclusion completely surrounded by nature. Located close to hiking trails, rivers, lakes, reservoirs, breweries and wineries as well as Hunter (17 mi), Catskill (26 mi) and Hudson (30 mi), this is the ideal location from which to explore the best of the Catskills.

Top guest favorite
A cozy seating area features a large, woven hanging chair with a white cushion and a bright green accent pillow. A textured pouf and a small side table complement the space, which is surrounded by large windows offering views of the mountains and natural light.
Apartment in Freehold
5 out of 5 average rating, 337 reviews

Mountain View Retreat~Sunny Hill Golf / Skiing

Welcome to Sunny Hill Road ! We are located in a small community of private homes in an open space overlooking the mountains. This one bedroom unit has everything you need to enjoy your stay in the Catskills. Relax on the private deck or inside with amazing views from every window. The kitchen is fully equipped and ready to cook a full meal and then enjoy it in the dining room overlooking the mountains. It is quiet and restful here, amazingly beautiful in all four seasons!

Superhost
An outdoor seating area is presented alongside a hot tub and a fire pit. The seating features a sectional sofa with light-colored cushions. Dividing panels with a leaf design create a sense of privacy, while surrounding trees provide a natural backdrop.
Cabin in Prattsville
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 293 reviews

Little Red Cabin Near Windham & Hunter w/ Hot Tub

Nestled in the woods, our 3 bedroom cabin offers the perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. The cozy interior features a warm, inviting atmosphere with all the amenities you need for a comfortable stay. The spacious living room is the perfect place to unwind after a long day of exploring the great outdoors, complete with a cozy fireplace and outdoor hot tub that offer stunning views of the surrounding landscape. Follow us on IG @thelittleredcabinny

Top guest favorite
A warm and inviting living space is seen, featuring a round wooden dining table surrounded by four rustic chairs. An adobe wood-burning fireplace is visible in the background, with seating arranged nearby for relaxation. Natural light flows in through a window, enhancing the cozy atmosphere.
Home in East Jewett
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Creekside Couple's Retreat w/Hot tub, Sauna & More

Tucked by an enchanting creek, this newly built cabin is a serene haven where nature and comfort meet. Unwind together in the hot tub beneath the stars, relax in the wood fired sauna, or enjoy a fun evening in the game room. Let the soothing sounds of the creek lull you to sleep as you take in the beauty of the outdoors from every window. Explore nearby trails, quaint towns, and secret escapes. Pet-friendly, perfect for couples seeking a magical retreat in every season.

Top guest favorite
Cabin in Broome
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

30minsWindham/Game Room/Woodstove/King Bed/Firepit

Welcome to the Stone Wall Cabin — Your Cozy Mountain Retreat in Preston Hollow! Unplug, play, and relax in this secluded Catskills cabin—perfect for ski weekends, families, and friends’ getaways. Just a scenic 30-minute drive to Windham Mountain, this cozy retreat combines rustic charm with a dedicated game lounge. After a day on the slopes or exploring the Catskills, come home to warm fires, classic games, and peaceful wooded surroundings.

Superhost
A cabin is nestled in a wooded area, characterized by large windows that invite natural light. A green roof is complemented by a front porch, while a small shed is visible to the right. Surrounding greenery enhances the serene atmosphere of the location.
Cabin in Conesville
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 189 reviews

Cozy mountain hideaway - Catskills Windham

Escape to a private Catskill Mountain cabin surrounded by woods and comfort. Video available at vimeo: vimeo/1090353214 Enjoy Wi-Fi, a cozy fireplace, full kitchen, plush Queen bed in the master, plus a loft with another Queen and futon. Bluetooth speakers, Smart TV, A/C & heat, BBQ grill, and outdoor fire pit. Firewood available. Just 25 mins to Windham Mountain. Pet-friendly. Perfect for a peaceful, modern mountain retreat!.

Guest favorite
Guest suite in Windham
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Cozy Cabin Condo by the Mountain, 5mins to skiing!

Steps from the Mountain! Just 1 mile away with a crisp mountain view, our beautiful chalet is a mere 5 minute drive from the slopes of Windham and just 15 minutes from Hunter! A short walk or drive from the charming town of Windham, you're perfectly located for a country getaway. The town itself is a wonderful mountain community with many great shops, restaurants and activities all within a short drive.

Popular amenities for Preston-Potter Hollow vacation rentals