Vacation rentals in New Milford

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Milford

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1

Top guest favorite

The spacious great room features high wooden ceilings supported by exposed beams. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, which includes a cozy seating area with a light-colored sofa, a dining table, and a fully equipped kitchen in the background.

Barn in Jermyn

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Restored Barn - 44 Acres with 100 Acre Lake

Reconnect with nature at this unforgettable retreat. Escape to our renovated barn on a 44-acre eco-paradise. Experience modern farmhouse living with 25-foot ceilings, a great room with beautiful views, fully equipped kitchen, king-size bed in giant loft bedroom, and cozy gas stoves. Hike, kayak or fish on the 100 acre lake, forage for wild berries and ramps in season, or go skiing at Elk Mountain right down the road. One-of-a-kind serenity and rustic, natural luxury in Pennsylvania's wilderness.

Top guest favorite

The A-frame cabin is nestled among trees, featuring a wooden deck and wide glass doors that open to the interior. A private hot tub is positioned nearby, providing a relaxing outdoor space surrounded by nature.

Cabin in Damascus

5 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Cozy A-Frame | Hot Tub, Fire Pit & Pet-Friendly

Escape to the Cedar Haven A-Frame in Damascus, PA – the perfect romantic hideaway just a short drive from NYC. Nestled in peaceful woods, this cozy 400-square-foot retreat offers all you need for a relaxing escape. Soak in the private hot tub, roast marshmallows by the fire pit, or unwind to music as you watch the forest through wide windows. Whether celebrating a special occasion or just needing time away, the tiny cabin invites you to unplug, reconnect, and make memories in nature’s embrace.

Top guest favorite

An A-frame cabin is set amidst lush trees, featuring a spacious deck with a railing and steps leading to the exterior. Large windows reflect natural light, and the rustic wood facade is complemented by greenery surrounding the property.

Cabin in Susquehanna

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Quill Creek Aframe

Welcome to our charming A-frame retreat near Elk! At 101 Longacre Rd, Susquehanna, PA! This cozy cabin features 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, a spacious deck, back patio, and a fire pit. Perfect for couples, families, or friends, our cabin offers a serene escape with modern comforts. Enjoy the stunning surroundings, unwind by the fire, or explore the beauty of Susquehanna. Ideal for those seeking tranquility and adventure. Book your stay today and create lasting memories at our lovely A-frame cabin!

Guest favorite

A cozy living room features wooden beams and warm wood flooring. A comfortable dark sofa is complemented by a coffee table and a lamp. Artwork adorns the walls, while large windows allow natural light to fill the space, creating a serene atmosphere.

Home in Susquehanna

5 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Olivia House

Olivia House is located in the quaint village of Steven's Point Pa. There is a large kitchen, dining & living room area and the original farm house features the family room which has been re-modeled but still retains the rustic farmhouse charm. The master bedroom has an attached bathroom with a large shower. The second bedroom is near another bathroom with a tub. There are 5 twin beds upstairs with an ajoining loft. A half bath is located in the laundry room. A BBQ grill inhabits the deck.

Top guest favorite

A charming cabin sits on a sprawling green lawn, surrounded by trees and hills. The structure features a classic design with a front porch, picnic table, and grill. A small shed is visible to the left, against a backdrop of a colorful sunset.

Cabin in Montrose

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Cozy Cabin with Mini Goats & Hot tub Starlink WiFi

Here you can relax with the whole family or it’s a perfect getaway for 2. From Spring to late fall we’ll have mini goats and free range rabbits & chickens. The creek is perfect for tubing on a hot summer day.Have a picnic in the trees next to the water.Just a mile away is an ice cream/petting zoo and greenhouse with amish gifts. Next door is our operating hobby farm with donkeys, sheep alpacas, goats and chickens.If you’re looking for a nice relaxing retreat, we have what you’re looking for.

Top guest favorite

A lakeside home is viewed from across the water, showcasing large windows and a deck accessible by stairs. Greenery surrounds the property, with a stone border along the lake, reflecting the house and trees in the calm water.

Guest suite in Montrose

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 245 reviews

Hoots Inn, (formerly Noonan's Getaway)

If you are looking to escape to the woods and a lake this is your place. We are 25 minutes from Binghamton, NY and 35 minutes to Elk Mountain PA. Our place is comfortable and is your home for the time you are here. Complete house with lake access from the yard, kayaks, canoe, paddle boats, row boat and more. There is a pavilion, firepit and BBQ grill at your disposal. Peace and quiet with no motors allowed on the lake. NO PARTIES OR EVENTS ALLOWED DUE TO COVID CONCERNS.

Guest favorite

A quaint cabin constructed from logs features a vibrant red door, inviting guests inside. The natural stone pathway leads to a small outdoor space, surrounded by lush greenery and rolling hills, under a sky adorned with soft clouds and warm sunset hues.

Cabin in Thompson

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 248 reviews

Peaceful Summer Escape w/ Hot Tub & Firepit

Reconnect with nature at Queen Cabin—your peaceful summer retreat for couples, solo travelers, or close friends. Soak in the communal hot tub, grill on the patio, or stargaze by the firepit. Quiet, comfy, and surrounded by trails, it’s perfect for slowing down and recharging. ⭐ “Beautiful relaxing country getaway!” 🌄 HIGHLIGHTS ✓ Cozy cabin for couples or small groups ✓ Stargazing, firepit, and (communal/shared) hot tub nights ✓ Trails, views & outdoor peace

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area is presented with a comfortable sectional sofa and a rustic wooden coffee table. A small, decorated Christmas tree adds a festive touch, while a flat-screen TV is mounted on the wall opposite. Wood beams enhance the rustic charm of the space.

Loft in Union Dale

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 198 reviews

“The Loft” of Elk Mountain Area

Cozy one bedroom loft located in the heart of the Endless Mountains. A short driving distance from Elk Mountain Ski Resort, D&H Rail Trail, state game lands, summer camps, and many great local bars, restaurants, and wedding venues. The perfect spot for a getaway! There's a fully furnished living area (with pullout queen-size bed) and large dining area that is perfect for a hangout before you hit the slopes. This little slice of cabin-style heaven will not disappoint!

Guest favorite

A cozy living area features a warm brown leather sofa paired with decorative cushions. Two windows provide natural light, while a wooden chair and a small table complement the space. A smart TV is positioned on a white console, enhancing the cabin's inviting atmosphere.

Cabin in Thompson

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 267 reviews

The Hemlock House

Escape to the Endless Mountains at this cozy 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath cabin, just 7 miles from Elk Mountain. Perfect for skiers, hikers, and outdoor lovers, it offers easy access to scenic hiking and biking trails along the Rails-to-Trails system. Unwind by the fireplace or explore the open land. Renovated in 2020 with custom details while keeping its original charm, this rustic retreat is the perfect getaway for adventure or relaxation. Book your stay today!

Guest favorite

A charming cottage is surrounded by autumn foliage, showcasing a large tree casting a long shadow on the well-maintained lawn. The screened-in porch is visible at the front of the cottage, along with a detached structure in the background.

Cottage in Thompson

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Lackawanna Lodge - Cozy two bedroom cottage

Relax with the whole family in this peaceful cottage, nestled in the Endless Mountain Range of PA. Only 6.5 miles from Elk Mountain skiing and minutes from several golf courses, great fishing locations and rails & trails hiking/ biking paths. This is the perfect location for year round activities! Enjoy custom details throughout, screened in wrap around porch, modern amenities and 2.5 acres of land to roam around.

Guest favorite

A waterfront property is showcased with a raised structure featuring a large deck and steps leading up to the entry. The exterior is clad in neutral siding, while the area underneath provides a shaded space. An American flag gently flutters in the breeze.

Home in Kirkwood

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 191 reviews

Susquehanna River House

Welcome to the Susquehanna River House — a peaceful, fully remodeled 3-bedroom retreat on the Susquehanna River in Kirkwood, NY. Wake up to river views, sip coffee on the deck, and spend your day kayaking, fishing, or enjoying the sauna. Whether you're visiting for adventure or rest, this cozy escape offers the perfect mix of comfort, nature, and small-town charm — with Downtown Binghamton just 15 minutes away.

Guest favorite

A scenic view from the cabin deck showcases a vast green field lined with trees and gentle hills in the background. The landscape is bathed in natural light, with clear skies visible above.

Cabin in South Gibson

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

Elk Mountain Ski Area; Rustic Cabin on 15 Acres

Escape to a rustic cabin retreat set on 15 acres with breathtaking mountain views in the heart of the Endless Mountains. Just 5 miles from Elk Mountain Ski area and conveniently close to NEP Rails to Trails, Lackawanna State Park, and other natural attractions like Salt Springs Park (35 min away). Enjoy proximity to shopping and dining in Clifford, Clarks Summit, and the Scranton area.