Vacation rentals in New Milford

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Milford

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

The spacious great room features high wooden ceilings supported by exposed beams. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, which includes a cozy seating area with a light-colored sofa, a dining table, and a fully equipped kitchen in the background.

Barn in Jermyn

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 218 reviews

Restored Barn - 44 Acres, 100 Acre Lake

Reconnect with nature at this unforgettable retreat. Escape to our renovated barn on a 44-acre eco-paradise. Experience modern farmhouse living with 25-foot ceilings, a great room with beautiful views, fully equipped kitchen, king-size bed in giant loft bedroom, and cozy gas stoves. Hike, kayak or fish on the 100 acre lake, forage for wild berries and ramps in season, or go skiing at Elk Mountain right down the road. One-of-a-kind serenity and rustic, natural luxury in Pennsylvania's wilderness.

FamilyValueHospitality

Top guest favorite

A two-story farmhouse features a white exterior with red shutters and a welcoming porch. Surrounding trees display varying autumn leaf colors, while the neatly landscaped front yard displays seasonal decorations amidst fallen leaves.

Farm stay in Susquehanna

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Windcrest Country Home

Enjoy some time away in a renovated country farmhouse situated on 100 acres of farmland that raises Black Angus cattle. Located 3 miles outside of Susquehanna, PA we have ponds for fishing, swimming, and boating so bring your suits and fishing poles. We are surrounded by woods that have beautiful color in the fall. If you are a skier, Elk Mountain is only a short 25 minutes away. Any season is a relaxing time. After a peaceful day, end your night with a cookout and sitting around the fire pit.

ValueLocationBathroom

Guest favorite

An A-frame cabin is set amidst lush trees, featuring a spacious deck with a railing and steps leading to the exterior. Large windows reflect natural light, and the rustic wood facade is complemented by greenery surrounding the property.

Cabin in Susquehanna

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Quill Creek Aframe

Welcome to our charming A-frame retreat near Elk! At 101 Longacre Rd, Susquehanna, PA! This cozy cabin features 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, a spacious deck, back patio, and a fire pit. Perfect for couples, families, or friends, our cabin offers a serene escape with modern comforts. Enjoy the stunning surroundings, unwind by the fire, or explore the beauty of Susquehanna. Ideal for those seeking tranquility and adventure. Book your stay today and create lasting memories at our lovely A-frame cabin!

ValueLocationRiver

Top guest favorite

A cozy living room features wooden beams and warm wood flooring. A comfortable dark sofa is complemented by a coffee table and a lamp. Artwork adorns the walls, while large windows allow natural light to fill the space, creating a serene atmosphere.

Home in Susquehanna

5 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Olivia House

Olivia House is located in the quaint village of Steven's Point Pa. There is a large kitchen, dining & living room area and the original farm house features the family room which has been re-modeled but still retains the rustic farmhouse charm. The master bedroom has an attached bathroom with a large shower. The second bedroom is near another bathroom with a tub. There are 5 twin beds upstairs with an ajoining loft. A half bath is located in the laundry room. A BBQ grill inhabits the deck.

FamilyValueNearby

Guest favorite

A comfortable living area is depicted, featuring a brown couch paired with a light-colored loveseat. A coffee table sits in the center on a soft area rug. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, complemented by decorative lamps and wall art.

Home in Susquehanna

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 83 reviews

Susquehanna Home - Next to Priesthood Restoration

Escape to your own charming retreat in this newly renovated 3-bedroom house in Susquehanna, PA. Perfect for families or groups, this modern and cozy home, thoughtfully designed for Airbnb guests, is a minute's walk from the Priesthood Restoration Site and Penn Can Speedway. Prepare a delightful meal in the fully equipped kitchen, enjoy the huge yard, field and fire pit, relax on the patio, and experience the peace and quiet of the countryside. Elk Mountain is a scenic 30-minute drive away.

FamilyValueOutdoor spaces

Guest favorite

Home in New Milford

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Lakefront Home, Fast WiFi+Workspace, stay the week

Lake Front home with 230 feet of Lake frontage on Page Lake. Walk out the door onto the grass and into the lake. Escape to this peaceful 3,042 sq. ft. log-sided lakefront home, perfectly tucked away on a quiet, wooded 3.5-acre parcel overlooking a 100-acre, mile-long private lake. With this exclusive property you’ll enjoy unparalleled privacy, sweeping lake views, and easy access for swimming, floating, fishing, or simply soaking up the sun. Just 16 miles from Elk Mountain Ski Resort.

LocationAccuracySkiing

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a restored vacation home is displayed, featuring white siding and black shutters. A welcoming front door stands out, complemented by landscaped gardens. The lawn leads towards a serene lake visible in the background, under a partly cloudy sky.

Home in Montrose

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Fieldstone Farm Vacation Rental on Lake Montrose

A beautifully restored early vacation home on Lake Montrose that offers guests private lakefront access directly from the house for boating, fishing and swimming. Kayaks, a canoe and a paddle boat and a 28 foot dock are available for your enjoyment. Relax and enjoy the large back deck and lawn area overlooking the lake and the Montrose Golf Club. The home has comfortable open living spaces and is conveniently located to shopping, restaurants and area events. There is also a full garage.

ValueLocationSkiing

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Walton

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 258 reviews

The Mill House: An Enchanting Stream-Side Retreat

Nestled in the heart of the Catskills and just a 2.5-hour drive from NYC, escape to the perfect fall retreat where you can reconnect with nature and enjoy the serene beauty of the season. This historic gem underwent a recent restoration, marrying its saw mill heritage with contemporary luxuries, including a Nest thermostat, smart speakers, keyless entry, and fast wifi. Original exposed post and beam construction and Scandinavian-inspired design make for a unique and cozy atmosphere.

LocationFamilyNearby

Guest favorite

A cozy living area features a warm brown leather sofa paired with decorative cushions. Two windows provide natural light, while a wooden chair and a small table complement the space. A smart TV is positioned on a white console, enhancing the cabin's inviting atmosphere.

Cabin in Thompson

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 304 reviews

The Hemlock House

Escape to the Endless Mountains at this cozy 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath cabin, just 7 miles from Elk Mountain. Perfect for skiers, hikers, and outdoor lovers, it offers easy access to scenic hiking and biking trails along the Rails-to-Trails system. Unwind by the fireplace or explore the open land. Renovated in 2020 with custom details while keeping its original charm, this rustic retreat is the perfect getaway for adventure or relaxation. Book your stay today!

FamilyValuePets

Top guest favorite

The spacious living area features a high wood-beamed ceiling with a chandelier and a stone fireplace. Comfortable seating arrangements invite relaxation, while large glass doors provide views of the outdoors. Options for gathering are enhanced by the open layout and natural wood elements.

Cabin in Susquehanna

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

The TimberLodge on Butterfield, near Elk Mountain

Welcome to the beautiful Timber Lodge of Susquehanna County! A craftman's dream,this timber frame house is built with reclaimed wood, has vaulted ceiling's and a stone fireplace. Plenty of space for large gatherings or family ski trips. Conveniently located 15 miles from Elk Mountain Ski Resort. Guests can enjoy hottub and fire pit, outdoor dining area plus grill, a large game room,water fun with swimming and kayaking in the pond.

FamilyLocationWalkability

Guest favorite

A scenic view from the cabin deck showcases a vast green field lined with trees and gentle hills in the background. The landscape is bathed in natural light, with clear skies visible above.

Cabin in South Gibson

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Elk Mountain Ski Area; Rustic Cabin on 15 Acres

Escape to a rustic cabin retreat set on 15 acres with breathtaking mountain views in the heart of the Endless Mountains. Just 5 miles from Elk Mountain Ski area and conveniently close to NEP Rails to Trails, Lackawanna State Park, and other natural attractions like Salt Springs Park (35 min away). Enjoy proximity to shopping and dining in Clifford, Clarks Summit, and the Scranton area.

ValueFamilyParking

Top guest favorite

The vibrant sunset casts a warm glow over Tingley Lake, reflecting shades of orange and pink on the water's surface. A wooden dock extends into the lake, surrounded by lush greenery and a visible kayak. A flag gently flutters in the foreground.

Apartment in New Milford

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 235 reviews

Tingley Lake Super Suite

The house includes a master suite and 1 bedroom, 1.5 bathrooms, a full kitchen / living area. There is a walk out patio, spacious deck area and dock for swimming, canoeing, kayaking or paddleboarding in beautiful Tingley Lake.Continental breakfast (cold and hot cereal and / or pastry with coffee and fruit) is available for stays less than 3 nights. Private entrance and self-check in.

LocationFamilyShared spaces