Vacation rentals in New Amsterdam

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Amsterdam

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

An original fireplace made of dark wood is set against a warm, orange wall, highlighting its historic charm. A large mirror above the mantel reflects the light from the nearby window. Furnishings, including an antique chair and table, complement the inviting living space.

Home in Corydon

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Indian Creek Lodge

Indian Creek Lodge is located in the historic district of downtown Corydon. Our house is newly renovated with all new appliances while also keeping the charm of a circa 1910 house. This property features a newly renovated and fully equipped kitchen, a full dining room, a living room with an original fireplace, and a sitting room any family would enjoy. You can awake in our cozy sunroom with your morning coffee. Step back in time and enjoy our period antiques and relax in our cozy neighborhood.

Guest favorite

The living area showcases a comfortable sofa with decorative pillows, adjacent to a dining table with elegant chairs. A modern kitchen area is visible, highlighted by stainless steel appliances and overhead lighting. The space features a neutral color palette and wooden flooring.

Apartment in Corydon

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 273 reviews

Vera's Loft in Historic Corydon, IN

Vera's Loft is named for my mother who grew up just 2 blocks from here in historic Corydon. Completely renovated and updated 1 Bedroom Loft in a historic home built in 1900. At nearly 500 square feet, it is much larger and certainly more comfortable than your typical hotel room. Located in the downtown historic district, it is walking distance to shops, restaurants and more. Private off street parking and private, secure entrance make this an appealing choice for business or leisure travelers.

Guest favorite

An outdoor patio area features a concrete surface adorned with colorful furniture. Two teal chairs and a dark wicker seating set are arranged on a vibrant rug. Soft lighting is provided by hanging string lights. The entrance to the bungalow is framed by large windows.

Home in Milltown

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Blue River Bungalow, Milltown, In.

This newly renovated home was an early post offices in Milltown. It is now a paddlers dream! All surfaces are new and compliment the vintage patina of the building. Guests are just one block from Cave Country Canoes and only steps away from the beautiful Blue River. The Bungalow includes an outdoor patio and private parking. Even though the location is downtown, it is quiet and private. Maxine's Market and Blue River Liquors are all just a short walk. Very close to lots of outdoor activites

Top guest favorite

A cozy bedroom features a spacious bed with crisp white linens and decorative pillows. Above the bed, a vibrant artwork of a cow adds a touch of character to the room. A bedside lamp and a small blue nightstand provide additional comfort.

Place to stay in Vine Grove

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

Fort 5400

Rustic 1 bedroom unit on 6 acres. Beautiful creek a couple hundred yards from your door with lovely sunsets. Vaulted living room, dual reclining sofa, 50 inch ROKU TV & dinette. Kitchenette with full size refrigerator, microwave, and Keurig coffee maker. King size bed, cozy electric fireplace, 32 inch ROKU TV and closet with washer/dryer. The grounds are shared with one other tenant. FT Knox-6.2 Miles Elizabethtown Sports Park-15 miles Church Hill Downs-36 miles Boundary Oak Distillary-7 miles

Top guest favorite

A gravel parking area is surrounded by lush trees, with a cabin visible in the background. Adirondack chairs are arranged around a fire pit in the foreground, creating a space for gathering. Bright blue skies with scattered clouds enhance the serene atmosphere.

Cabin in French Lick Township

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Serenity Acres

Over 5 acres of pure serenity, just the sound of nature all around you! Beautiful Tucker Lake with hiking trail all around it just a mile away. This park like atmosphere has room for tents, RVs , boats, 4 wheelers and more. Just under 5 miles from the Fabulous French Lick and West Baden Resort town, but totally secluded.Cabin has two porches with rocker gliders and heavenly views. Cedar swing ,picnic table, fire pit with adirondack chairs for late night BBQs. Water park and boat rental, nearby

Guest favorite

A charming log cabin is framed by lush green trees, showcasing a warm exterior with a stone chimney. Rocking chairs are placed on the front porch, surrounded by vibrant flowers and a neatly maintained garden path leading to the entrance.

Cabin in Louisville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 346 reviews

Captain's Cabin: Bourbon Trail, History & Romance

Your own log cabin on a wooded hillside with gourmet breakfast served to your door (on weekends)! It's been the location for 5 movies, including Lifetime! Period furnishings and modern conveniences make this an unforgettable retreat. A massive stone fireplace creates a quiet ambiance. Watch wildlife by the lake, creek or from back porch swings. Comfy bed, luxury sheets, high-speed internet, bluetooth stereo and special touches make your stay magical! Ask for Cooking With Bourbon Experience.

Top guest favorite

A view from above captures a six-person hot tub with inviting blue water. Nearby, a circle of Adirondack chairs surrounds a fire pit, all nestled in a wooded area illuminated by warm string lights hanging overhead.

Cabin in Eckerty

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Whitetail Woods cabin w/ HOT TUB and Patoka pass

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful cabin minutes from Patoka Lake entrance, winery, distillery, brewery, and dining! Perfect for family adventures, romantic getaways, ladies' weekends, and hunting trips. The cabin is located in peaceful Grant Woods surrounded by gorgeous Southern Indiana nature. You'll love relaxing in the 6-person hot tub, rocking on the covered front porch, and roasting marshmallows around the backyard fire pit. Cabin is a short drive to French Lick/West Baden.

Superhost

The house is set on a gently sloping hill, surrounded by trees. Large glass windows offer views of the landscape and the lake beyond. A stone chimney adds a rustic touch to the contemporary design, and a spacious deck wraps around the structure.

Home in Brandenburg

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 280 reviews

Luxury lakehouse retreat with picturesque views

A nicely appointed lake house with rustic contemporary decor. Gourmet kitchen includes dishes, cookware and small appliances as well as a deluxe espresso/cappuccino maker. House is located in a gated, private community with a 320 acre lake up to 70 ft deep. Only pontoon boats and fishing boats permitted, ensuring a quiet lake experience and wake-free dock sitting. Two kayaks, canoe, paddle board and some basic fishing equipment for guest use. Pontoon rental by owner - separate contract.

Superhost

The wooden cabin features a traditional design with a peaked roof and a red door. Surrounded by trees and under a clear sky, it is situated near the Ohio River, with gravel pathways leading to the entrance and an expansive view of the water visible in the background.

Cabin in Cannelton

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 243 reviews

Isaak's Hideaway - "Newly Remodeled"

Isaak's Hideaway is a spacious cedar log cabin with expansive windows overlooking the Ohio River and surrounded by Hoosier National Forest in Magnet, IN. Sleeping up to eight, this cabin is ready to entertain a houseful of family and friends. Enjoy the amazing river view and barge traffic while relaxing at the stone fire pit or lounging in the hot tub. Also, located about 50 minutes from Holiday World. Freshly painted with all new appliances! Also check out Pop's Hideaway - Magnet, IN.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the stone cabin is framed by lush greenery and flowering plants. Sunlight casts soft shadows across the textured stone walls. A decorative statue stands on a pedestal near the entrance, complementing the natural surroundings.

Cabin in Louisville

5 out of 5 average rating, 235 reviews

Historic Cabin by Bourbon Trail

Historic, unique, tasteful and serene - the Edward Tyler house, ca. 1783, is a stone cabin 20 minutes SE of Louisville on 13 acre estate. Near the famous bourbon trail, rental includes full cabin and large screen porch overlooking pond with fountain. First floor has living/dining/kitchen space with small sofa bed and stone fireplace (gas); queen bed and full bath on second floor. American and European antique furnishings and fine art welcome you to fully updated home with central HVAC.

Top guest favorite

The cabin's exterior exhibits a rustic charm with unique angles and a mix of textures. Wooden walls are complemented by a metal roof, while multiple windows add character. A simple porch with log railings invites relaxation, surrounded by lush greenery.

Guesthouse in Hardinsburg

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 301 reviews

Once Upon a Time little Cabin in the Woods

Welcome to Always Ranch where this unique tiny cabin offers you a tranquil spot to relax. You will be surrounded by nature and off the beaten path. The cabin may look like a lean to but the inside is rustic and warming. We are located 20 minutes form Salem, 20 minutes from Paoli and Paoli Peak, and 35 minutes from Frenchlick Casino The kitchenette includes mini fridge, microwave, double hot plate and, grill on the outdoor firepit or grill. Boats are NOT available for guests at this time

Top guest favorite

The cabin is elevated on stilts, surrounded by trees, and features a wraparound screened-in porch. A wooden deck leads to the entrance, where a flag hangs proudly. Gravel pathways converge near outdoor seating areas with picnic tables, providing a welcoming outdoor space.

Home in Elizabeth

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

Cabin on Lake Close to Louisville Ky

Welcome to Little Cedar Lodge, our little slice of heaven near the town of Elizabeth, Indiana. Enjoy the peace and solitude overlooking the quiet private lake (wake speed only), yet close to Caesar’s Casino, golf, wineries, and the city of Louisville with all its activities and nightlife. Great for a romantic getaway for two, or for your entire family. It would also be great for a small church or business retreat. We can accommodate up to 10 if you double up in some beds.