Vacation rentals with lake access in Montauk

We had a great stay coming back to Long Island to spend the week celebrating Thanksgiving with my crazy big Italian family. Staying here made our time back on LI so much more enjoyable. We loved the peaceful setting on the lake. Our breakfast time was great, just sitting in the dining room / sun room and enjoying the amazing view. We even used the Kayaks a couple of times.

Woke up to a blue heron fishing outside the kitchen window. This home is in a serene and beautiful location. The generous five bedroom and four bathroom house is well appointed and still feels intimate. We really enjoyed our stay and look forward to returning soon.

Awesome house - right on the lake with a huge yard. And a beautifully decorated interior with high end furniture. I would highly recommend the house and would like to stay there again!

We had a wonderful stay and the host was friendly and accommodating! Location was perfect for exploring and the home is spacious yet cozy. Everything was in clean condition but large groups may need to stock up on additional tissue products and soap. I celebrated my 30th birthday with my family here and made cherished memories. Would stay here again in future!

Such a lovely home and amazing view. Host was great communicating with us. Would stay again!

Sarah was wonderful as a host and the home was very well maintained in a beautiful neighborhood. Thank you!

Amazing place , impressive host, Good people. Nichole was great.

We must have passed the residence hundreds of times going out Montauk over the past 40 years. What a hidden gem. We were so fortunate to have the opportunity to stay at this location. The home was very well appointed, tidy and clean. What a gem of a home, even in the off season. We would love to return.

We had an amazing stay! Beautiful condo the decor is spotless & the outdoor deck is a huge bonus. Watching the sunset or having coffee in the morning really lade the stay even more relaxing. I cant wait to go back. :)

We've stayed at Kelly's before, and we keep coming back because it matches our vibes perfectly - quiet, private, and low-key. It's a great place to get away from the fast-paced city, and it's far enough removed from the center of Montauk that it really feels like you're the only ones there. Bonus - the stargazing in this part of the island is top-notch. You'd never expect that this close to the city. Check in and check out couldn't be easier.

We had a very enjoyable time in the apartment. Everything was as described. Would come back without hesitation.

Amazing Airbnb! Eli’s place is comfortable and clean, with amazing views of the lake. Close drive to town, beach, and train. And Eli is flexible and easy to communicate with. We had a great time!

This might be the best place to stay in Montauk...so many things to walk to and you wake up right next to the water it's perfect. Westlake Marina is perfect if you want the real Montauk experience you can go fishing and a lot of other activities. The room feels brand new and really nicely done they even have heated floors! 10/10 would return

Amazing views! Beach. Glamping. Camp store and great pizza place.

Eli's spot exceeded our expectations! The location is excellent—right on the pond with beautiful views, and centrally located for easy access to Montauk's restaurants and beaches. The apartment itself was clean and spacious, comfortably accommodating our group of five adults. Most of all, Eli was incredibly hospitable--super responsive, friendly, and went above and beyond with thoughtful gestures throughout our stay. We'd highly recommend this spot to all!

This stay was absolutely perfect for my first trip to Montauk. Quiet, clean, and convenient. It was a delight to meet Kelly and Rick, and we loved their recommendations for fun things to do nearby. Definitely hope to return!

Deb’s place was very peaceful, comfortable, and well appointed. We immediately felt at home and enjoyed the interesting decor and personal style. It felt like staying in your own bed and breakfast. There were so many places to relax, and the front and back porches were so welcoming. The location can’t be beat if you want to check out the local wineries, farmstands, and great restaurants. An easy walk across the street to Peconic Bay, you can see from the upstairs bedroom. Kitchen was well appointed with everything you would need for cooking. Short ride to markets, farmstands, and Love Lane for shops and restaurants, about 20 minutes to Greenport.

Head of the Pond House was in such a beautiful peaceful setting and was exactly what we needed! Quaint, beautifully decorated, cozy, and thoughtfully stocked for a very relaxing stay. Monika was super proactive and helpful with recommendations and left us lots of local yummies. The birds and the sights on the pond (ice sailing!) were lovely. Highly recommend the cottage to take in all that the Hamptons has to offer in a peaceful and tranquil setting.

Wonderful all around!! Thank you again to Noah who was terrific. Lovely place :)

My friends and I stayed at Richard's cottage for the long weekend (4th of July) and we had a blast. The view of the lake from the living room was amazing, and the place was cute (even cuter than the pics) and comfortable with everything we needed, we all had a great sleep since it's so peaceful around the area, and the beds were really comfortable same as the big sofa. The cottage was perfect for the 3 of us and our 2 pups. We enjoyed the sunset from the lake and went for a swim a couple of times, the water was delicious. Richard was very good at communicating; he was very responsive, he helps us with the beach essentials, provided guidance, and great recommendations around the area. We are already planning on returning and getting both cottages this time, hoping are available for our next trip!

We had a wonderful stay! The cottage is adorable, very clean, well-maintained, and very comfortable. Has a warm "homey" feel from the moment you walk inside. Big windows with lots of natural sunlight and views of the beautiful lake and landscape. The neighborhood is very peaceful and quiet, perfect for relaxing and sitting outside. Robert was a gracious host... very friendly and had excellent communication throughout. We're very happy to have found this place and would definitely stay there again!

Jean Marc’s cottage is a cozy and convenient hideaway at the beach. The cottage is simple but has all the necessary amenities for a comfortable stay, with kitchen utensils, beach chairs, and a picnic table facing the pond. My partner and I loved being able to walk 5 minutes to the beach and to little fish restaurant. Jean Marc was a lovely and responsive host, making the whole experience a breeze. Thanks for a great stay!

This was our 4th year staying here. It was perfect as always. Thank you to Deborah for sharing this wonderful cottage. It feels like our home away from home. The best sunsets can be seen from the deck!!!