Vacation rentals in Horseshoe Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Horseshoe Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A castle-style retreat is showcased, featuring a whimsical dragon statue and a large chess set in the foreground. A tranquil pond with a fountain is visible, alongside a magnificent castle structure designed with classic stone elements and a welcoming entrance, all set amidst lush greenery.

Castle in East Stroudsburg

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 393 reviews

Pocono Castle w/ Dungeon Escape Room &Private Pond

OMG! Sleep in a Fairy Tale at Pocono Castle! Live the dream in this 2,300 sq. ft. storybook retreat, where you’ll sleep like royalty in a real fairy tale castle. Unwind in luxury with a bubbling hot tub, a cedar sauna, and endless magical touches. Dress up as Kings, Queens, or Knights and explore the grounds, featuring a private one-acre pond & maybe you’ll catch a Golden Fish! With enchanting bedrooms, outdoor adventures, and unforgettable charm, this is the OMG getaway you’ve been waiting for

Guest favorite

The A-frame chalet is surrounded by lush greenery, featuring a welcoming front porch with steps leading to the entryway. Large windows allow ample natural light to fill the interior. A small shed is visible in the background, accentuating the tranquil forest setting.

Cabin in East Stroudsburg

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Norway Chalet: Forest Escape

Located Conveniently in the Pocono's, just 1 hour 30 minutes from Manhattan and under 2 hours from Philly! Our relaxing A-Frame Chalet is inspired by European design/ architecture and gives you the feel of a Nordic Home in the Poconos. Enjoy 4 large decks where you can hear the birds chirping and watch humming birds, butterflies, deer, and other wildlife in a "jungle like" back yard. Just minutes from the most popular hiking destinations, and water falls. Pets are welcome free of charge (:

Guest favorite

A spacious outdoor deck overlooking the lake is furnished with comfortable seating, including a sectional sofa and lounge chairs. Two large umbrellas provide shade, and a potted plant adds a touch of greenery, enhancing the tranquil lakeside setting.

Home in Andover

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 307 reviews

Stay at beautiful Leisure Lake Lodge

Leisure Lake Lodge is located on beautiful Lake Hopatcong just 1 hour from NYC. You'll fall in love w/ stunning lake views from all 3 levels of this large home, two massive decks over the lake & totally updated home easily sleeps 9. Fireplace, hot tub, sauna, foosball, ping pong, grill, 65" UHD TV, fully equipped newer kitchen, newer bathrooms, newer mattresses, 50 ft lake frontage w/ 80 ft dock, 32x20 ft boathouse w/ 400 SF deck over the lake & 19x12 ft 4-season game room with ping pong.

Top guest favorite

The living area presents a spiral staircase leading to extra loft space, complemented by two comfortable armchairs and a stylish coffee table. A door provides access to the outdoor area, while natural light fills the space through nearby windows.

Apartment in Morristown

5 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Trailside Morristown Apartment

This fully renovated 1-bedroom 1 bath apartment with a full kitchen, gas fireplace, washer/dryer, extra loft space and its own entrance is ideally located less than a mile from Morristown Memorial and just minutes from vibrant Downtown Morristown. Across the street is one of the areas most popular parks with miles of bike and walking trails. Whether you’re visiting for work, study, or to explore No. Central NJ, this inviting Airbnb offers the perfect blend of convenience and comfort.

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor space is outlined by stepping stones leading to the water’s edge. Comfortable seating is arranged around a fire pit, with dining furniture positioned nearby. Kayaks rest along the dock, with a clear view of the lake and surrounding landscape.

Home in Jefferson

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Adorable quiet & cozy lakefront studio on dead end

Welcome to your next getaway! This charming, lakefront studio views will wow you. Let the sound of the lake be your next therapy session! Perfect for a weekend getaway or long-term stay. Bring your work or leave it all behind. House sits at the end of a dead end street uninterrupted by traffic. Short trip from NYC. Enjoy access to kayaks, fishing, gazebo, BBQ & equipped with kitchen essentials. Great eateries & close to hiking trails or shopping centers. You won't be disappointed

Guest favorite

An outdoor area is illuminated by a vibrant red fireplace, surrounded by cozy seating arrangements with cushions and throws. Potted flowers add color, while string lights gently glow above, enhancing the serene atmosphere of the deck. A natural stone backdrop is visible in the distance.

Cottage in Greenwood Lake

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 352 reviews

Luxury Cottage with Spectacular Lake Views

Ultra Chic Cottage set high above Greenwood Lake with Private beach and lake front community access. Minutes away from Mountain Creek Ski Resort, Spa & Water park, Mt. Peter Ski & Tubing, Warwick creameries, breweries & vineyards & apple picking. 1 BR, 1 Bath, play/office/common room. Huge wrap around fenced in deck with Mid century modern fireplace allows for scenic dining, lounging and around the fire gatherings. #LakeViewCottage_GWL Town of Warwick Short Term Rental Permit #33593

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a waterfront house is shown, featuring three levels with multiple balconies and large windows. A private dock is visible in front, equipped with seating and a shaded area with an umbrella. A boat is docked alongside, highlighting access to water activities.

Place to stay in Hopatcong

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 245 reviews

Lake Sports Home !

Luxury water front suite, 40 ft. encl. deck, 26 windows, king bed, bath, 83 inch TV, LED fireplace, Hot Tub, dock, . Capacity 2 guests. Plus : optional 2nd bedroom/bath/2 single rolling beds avail. (small extra charge), Kitchenette : appliances [8]: fire pit, BBQ grill, hammocks, dining table, deck chairs. Dock umbrellas, Electric mountain bikes , world class kayaks, dry suits, rafts , floats . Extras: Surfing Boat, electric surfboards, electric hydrofoils, (Permit 2024-13)

Top guest favorite

A well-lit living room features a gray sectional couch with decorative pillows and a matching chaise lounge. Three large windows are adorned with light-filtering shades, allowing soft natural light to fill the space. A small bookshelf and a lamp add to the cozy ambiance.

Apartment in Morristown

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Location! Location! Location!

This sophisticated gem in Morristown is minutes from South Street’s bars, restaurants, and the NYC train station. The spacious living room has a couch, a desk, and fast internet. The kitchen is fully equipped with essentials. The cozy bedroom features a queen-sized bed, work desk, and private bathroom. Note: This is our personal home, so you'll find some belongings, but there’s ample storage for your stay, and we ensure it remains welcoming and comfortable for guests.

Guest favorite

A cozy living area is highlighted by a blue sofa adorned with decorative pillows. Natural light fills the space through two windows, revealing wooden flooring and a light-colored rug. An air conditioning unit and two dining options are visible in the background.

Bungalow in Jefferson

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 411 reviews

2 Queen Sized Beds - Lake Hopatcong Cottage

This little house offers a lot for visitors to the area: - near Route 15 and minutes to US 80 - two comfortable queen sized beds - sofa bed that comfortably sleeps 2 - kitchen with basic cooking amenities - rear patio with grill and fire pit - walking distance to boat rentals - near trails and restaurants - popular wedding venues within 15 mile drive: Perona Farms, Waterloo Village, Crossed Keys Estate, Sussex Fairgrounds -Mountain Creek approximately 20 miles away.

Guest favorite

A living room features a cozy arrangement with a brown armchair and a matching chaise lounge. Natural light filters through partially draped windows, illuminating polished wooden floors. Decorative wall art and a potted plant add subtle touches to the inviting space.

Home in Boonton

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

The Boonton Revival- A restored treasure in NJ

The Boonton Revival is an updated 100-year-old home within walking distance of historic Main Street, quaint restaurants, and unique shops. The nearby train and bus stations can connect to the NYC Port Authority (7th Ave) in one hour. Newark Liberty Airport is a 30-minute ride; you can be at the Jersey Shore in an hour! We are avid gardeners who enjoy raising beautiful koi fish. Guests are welcome to admire our pond and sample in-season vegetables.

Superhost

The open-concept living area features a modern kitchen equipped with stainless steel appliances and a central island with bar seating. A cozy seating arrangement invites relaxation, while decorative light fixtures enhance the ambiance. Laundry appliances are discreetly integrated into the cabinetry for convenience.

Home in Hopatcong

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Fireworks from the Porch!

Welcome to the largest lake in NJ! Freshly renovated with 4 beds & sleeper sofa, perfect for families and friends. Enjoy multi level comfort. Fun awaits with Kayaks, Paddle Boards, and space for your Boat/Jetski! A fully equipped kitchen leads to a spacious deck with weber grill & 4 burner griddle! Stunning sunset views &High-speed internet make remote work a breeze. Close to waterfront restaurants, shopping, & Hopatcong State Park.

Top guest favorite

Two mini donkeys graze peacefully in a grassy field, surrounded by trees with green foliage. A blue sky with a few scattered clouds provides a bright backdrop, and wooden fences outline the pasture, enhancing the farm-like setting.

Farm stay in Frenchtown

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 558 reviews

DREAM BIG! Rustic Tiny Home on Hidden Farmlet

Ready to kick back and relax from your busy life? Have you ever dreamed of waking up on a farm? Then our charming 170 sq ft tiny home is perfect for you! Situated on 10 picturesque acres, and home to one horse, two mini donkeys, two goats, a pig, twenty-two chickens, five ducks, a goose and, of course, a barn cat. This is the place to disconnect and get back to nature!