Cabin vacation rentals in Gilbertsville

We were attending an event up the road, and the location of Tony's cabins could not be beat! The cabins are exactly as described - rustic-style fishing cabins - so if you need anything 'extra' be sure to bring it along with you. We had a great stay, the cabins were quiet and comfortable, and definitely car camping like some of the other event attendees opted for! :)

Perfectly peaceful! Relaxing and the hot tub was delightful! The indoor soaking tub was amazing. Plenty of outdoor setting to enjoy reading!

Absolutely loved the cabin. It’s peaceful and the fire pit and grill was extremely convenient and right out our back door. Very homey and can’t wait to visit again. If you’re looking for a nice relaxing pace to visit I highly suggest the cabins Tony offers.

This place went above and beyond what we thought! It was so beautiful and peaceful! The fireplace was ready to be lit the hot tub was ready to hop in the lights outside were spectacular!!! The pavilion was so beautiful had everything we needed! We couldn’t have asked for a better weekend the only complaint I had is we couldn’t stay longer!!! The house was beautiful inside and out and had everything we needed cozy blankets everywhere the decor was outstanding! I can’t say enough good things about this place. We look forward to visiting again in the warmer months! I know it was a place for up to 8 people but it was absolutely perfect for a romantic getaway!

Nice and spacious cabin. All of the bedrooms were nice sized and outfitted with comfortable beds. The kids loved the available games and puzzles as well as the chance to learn how to play pool. The movie room was their favorite part by far, and the available videos had something for everyone. The hot tub was a really nice way to unwind after our visits to the Land Between the Lakes National Forest. We would recommend that to anyone looking for something to do in the area.

love my time here. Just needed peace and quiet from the city. highly recommend this off grid cabin

Beautiful place to get away. Cabin has everything you need! Literally walk out of the back door and step out on to the lake. Kayaking and fishing was a blast! Hot tub after a long day on the lake was amazing! Can’t wait to come back!

This is our 5th year here and second with Jessica the new owner! Every year has been amazing and our kids always have so much to do and are outside pretty much the whole time we are there! We love how secluded and private the beautiful cabin is.

Really great location! There’s a dock onsite and a ramp 5 mins away so it’s perfect for boat weekends. The screened in porch is perfect to hangout and enjoy the weather. The place may not be anything fancy but it has everything you need for the perfect lake weekend!

Patty was wonderful, she sent instructions on how to get in ahead of time and called to make sure we were able to find it. The cabin was beautiful and very peaceful. While slower, I did have cell service but it was really nice to disconnect for the weekend. There is a beautiful porch overlooking a pond where we enjoyed our morning coffee. Our toddler loved walking around the property and had plenty of space on the porch to play. I would definitely stay here again and look forward to booking again next year!

This cabin was so beautiful and cozy. The host was amazing and helped us right away! We will definitely be coming back another time

We enjoyed our stay. We used the grill to cook out and the covered deck was a perfect place to eat, relax and have conversation. Sitting around the fire pit was a relaxing end to our evening.

This little place was amazing. There are breathtaking views from the cabin. the cabin is modern but also rustic, which we enjoyed. The kids loved sleeping in the loft. We rented a golf cart for our stay and the boys loved riding around on it. The boys enjoyed the community pool as well. Everybody is so laid-back and friendly. We rented a pontoon and a tube for one day and had a blast!!! We would highly recommend doing that if you have teenagers. Pagliai’s had delicious pizza and it’s only about 20 minutes away. There’s also a gas grill on the deck that works great. The place is stocked pretty well with basics for cooking. The Running Rooster antique/thrift shop is right next to/ behind the resort. It’s worth a visit, very friendly people and fun items to look at. We would definitely consider coming back again. We had a great time at Holiday Hills!

We enjoyed our stay at the Blue House! Quiet and peaceful neighborhood. The house had everything we needed for our stay and was close to the boat ramp. We loved sitting out on the porch and watching/listening to the chickens next door.

Julie’s little cabin was a very nice, and refreshing stay. She was very responsive, and everything was just as she had listed. Would recommend this spot to anyone, and would also plan another stay! 10/10!

Lucas’s home at the lake was everything my family needed. The home is very spacious for our group, very well thought out, and very well taken care of. The Lakeview is beautiful and we didn’t feel the need at all to leave the house. Lucas was very responsive with any questions and the one time we accidentally locked ourselves out he immediately sent someone over. 10/10 recommend. We are already planning our next stay at one of his other rentals.

We had the best time at Whitetail. It was very private surrounded by so much beauty. The cabin was adorable and clean and comfy. We were just 10 minutes from the closest Marina to load and unload our Tri Toon which was nice. There wasn't an oven/Stove but we didn't need one because there was a grill on the wrap around deck as well as a Traeger pellet grill a few steps away from the cabin and there was also a full size fridge to store groceries. This place was a hidden gem nestled in the woods. We will be back and hopefully be able to rent the other cabin on the property.

The cabinets, very cute and well restored. We booked this because we have a Lakehouse him yet overflow guests. Easy clear instructions for getting there and getting in. Decor was adorable. Location was peaceful, close enough to Eddycreek Marina and our Lakehouse to be totally convenient I highly recommend staying at the 1812 cabin.

Our little cabin was so nice. Brand new. Chris had everything that was needed in the cabin. Beautiful front porch, blackstone grill. So cozy.

I have stayed here before and loved how peaceful and beautiful it was. So I had to come back and will be back soon. Loved everything about the place and the way constance communicated with me.

Sean’s cabin was lovely. It’s tucked away in Cadiz in a very private hunting resort. There is a cute man-made pond right out front that my husband and kids enjoyed fishing in. There are also gravel trails around the property for walks. Sean was very responsive to our communication, usually responding immediately or within an hour. Please note that the listed nightly rate is for one person. Each additional person costs $20/night (so an extra $80/night for our family of 5). That wasn’t disclosed in the listing and wasn’t very clear as we were booking via the app, and also wasn’t broken out/itemized in the receipt. It caused a bit of confusion for us.

Always a great stay at the cabin! Great to have a washer and dryer while glamping!! Go to the Dairy Bar and have their world famous home made biscuits and gravy, it never disappoints!!

The cabin was cute and exactly what we were wanting. A little pricey but nice. He had many things that were added like coffee and snacks. And the kitchen was furnished with many items, but we mostly ate out on our trip. Very comfy stay there.

We had a really nice stay at this cabin. The space was clean, well-maintained, and matched the listing exactly. Check-in was easy, everything worked as expected, and the cabin felt peaceful and private. We especially appreciated that it was bug-free—always a plus when staying near the woods. The “bee” touches throughout the decor were a fun and unexpected detail, especially since our dog Bumblebee joined us and seemed to fit right in. Overall, it was a smooth and comfortable experience.