Vacation rentals in Eagle Bay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Eagle Bay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favorite
Home in Eagle Bay
5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Eagle Bay ADK House Vacation

NEW LISTING! Year round 4 bedroom and 2 bathroom home with pine interior on a quiet private closed end road. Excellent snowmobile trail access right of Big Moose Road only 1 minute from Big Moose Yamaha. Fully furnished and updated. Guest must provide sheets, pillowcases and towels. We provide blankets, comforters and pillows. Fast Wifi and internet FireStick TV provided. Outside fire pit w/ chairs, new gas barbecue grill, & picnic table. Basement has dart board, pool table, & foosball table.

Top guest favorite
A scenic view of a peaceful waterfront area, featuring a private dock painted in red. Two Adirondack chairs are placed around a stone fire pit, surrounded by lush greenery and tall grasses, with calm water reflecting the blue sky and clouds.
Apartment in Old Forge
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Moose River cottage on the water in Old Forge

Soak in the Adirondacks from this rustic, newly remodeled one-bed apartment with a king size bed, full kitchen and bathroom. Start your day with a beautiful view of the sunrise over the Moose River. Feel free to launch one of our kayaks from our private dock, watch the stars from the hot tub or by the fire pit, take a bike ride on our bikes or just watch the amazing wild life and sunset from your private deck. Close to restaurants, shopping, hiking, and all of the summertime fun in Old Forge.

Top guest favorite
A charming two-story home features a light-colored exterior with multiple windows allowing natural light in. The gravel driveway accommodates parking for vehicles, and a welcoming front entrance is visible. Surrounding greenery enhances the tranquil setting of the property.
Home in Old Forge
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 279 reviews

Moose Riverside Bungalow 3BR Home Old Forge NY

Moose Riverside Old Forge in town. Ski,snowmobile,ice skate, fish, hike, swim, shop. Walking distance to everything in Old Forge. 3 bedrooms, fire pit, charcoal grill, generator, external security cameras. Check calendar availability. 1 Amazon firestick TV and 1 smart TV. Fans/window AC 1st & 2nd floors. Grab bars, bath seat 1st fl bathroom. Driveway 50 ' long /park 2 cars front of house. Review amenities & pictures. Rent Kayaks/canoes at Mountainman Outdoor Supply Co. Rte 28 in season

Guest favorite
A scenic view features a fire pit surrounded by two chairs, overlooking a calm lake. The shoreline is lined with boats docked nearby and hills in the background are adorned with trees. The sky is partly cloudy, reflecting a serene outdoor setting.
Home in Old Forge
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Lake Front Adirondack House

Discover this fabulous 2-bedroom gem in Old Forge on 1st Lake. This tremendous house boasts a cozy living room with an extra full bed, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring. With a queen bed, bunk bed, and 2 full beds, this tranquil retreat comfortably accommodates all guests. Two full baths have been newly renovated. The covered back deck has a grill and a newly added second stone porch is great for your sunning pleasure. Bring the Boat - huge dock with space for a couple boats

Top guest favorite
A spacious wooden deck offers views of Sixth Lake, framed by lush trees. Two Adirondack chairs are positioned for relaxation, providing an inviting spot to enjoy the surroundings, with blue chairs visible by the water's edge in the background.
Cabin in Inlet
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Sixth Lake Retreat

NEW RENTAL PROPERTY - STARTING SPRING 2025! Enjoy this newly renovated, comfortable, seasonal lake house on Sixth Lake. Enjoy the summer sun or fall foliage in a peaceful setting. You can relax on the enclosed porch or back deck. You can enjoy the lake view while enjoying quality time around the fire pit. Have your morning coffee or evening cocktail in an Adirondack chair right on your private dock. It is located one mile from downtown Inlet in the heart of the Adirondack Mountains.

Guest favorite
The main living area features a queen-sized bed with light bedding, complemented by two bedside lamps. A small dining table is positioned nearby, and a futon couch adds extra seating. Natural wood finishes and vibrant green walls enhance the inviting ambiance.
Apartment in Old Forge
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Charming 1 Bedroom on Main St.

Everything you want to explore is right outside the door. Located on Main St in the heart of Old Forge. Local restaurants, retail stores, and recreation are just steps from your door. This newly renovated unit has everything you need. The kitchen features a large farm sink, butcher block counter tops, oven, fridge, coffee station, and open shelving stocked with supplies. The main living area has a new queen sized bed, futon couch, dresser, dining room table, and 55” smart TV.

Top guest favorite
Cabin in Eagle Bay
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Book for Summer Fun or the Fall Foliage Ahead!

Tucked away on a quiet road in Eagle Bay, Camp Adironjack offers the perfect summer escape just steps from 4th Lake. Enjoy easy days boating, swimming, fishing, and exploring the Fulton Chain, with hiking and local favorites nearby. Start your mornings with a walk to the water and end your nights unwinding back at camp by the fire. With garage space for kayaks, bikes, and gear, it’s ideal for couples, families, or friends looking to relax and enjoy the Adirondacks at its best.

Guest favorite
Cabin in Old Forge
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 37 reviews

Tiny Pine Cabin

Tiny Pine Cabin welcomes you for your next getaway, located just a little over a mile up the road from the center of town. This unique cabin boasts one bedroom downstairs with a queen bed and a cozy loft just up the ladder with 2 twin beds, a well appointed kitchen with a custom built eat in island, beautiful granite countertops & heated tile floors in both the kitchen & bathroom, a comfy couch with electric recliners. Enjoy all that Old Forge and the ADK have to offer!

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a spacious Adirondack home is shown, featuring a large wrap-around deck and surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage. A paved driveway leads up to the house, which is elevated on a foundation with wooden lattice accents.
Cabin in Old Forge
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews

“Hollywood Nights”

This Adirondack home is newly remodeled with a great view of 1st Lake. We are close enough to town where there are many restaurants, bars, mini golf, Enchanted Forest Water Safari Theme Park and Calypso's Cove Family Fun Park. Also right around the corner from the Hollywood Hills association beach where you have access to a private beach and boat launch. You can setup camp and be hiking, boating or skiing in no time. Come enjoy all the Adirondacks has to offer!

Superhost
Home in Eagle Bay
5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Juniper - Big Moose Lakeside

Nestled on the shores of historic Big Moose Lake, this charming cabin offers the perfect getaway for nature lovers. Wake up to breathtaking lake views that can be enjoyed from both inside the cozy living space and the outdoor surroundings. Whether you prefer summer or winter, outdoor activities abound in every season. After an active day, gather around your private firepit for a relaxing evening with friends and family.

Top guest favorite
Two red Adirondack chairs are positioned on a wooden dock overlooking a calm lake. The serene water is surrounded by rolling hills under a clear blue sky, with scattered clouds enhancing the outdoor scene.
Cabin in Old Forge
5 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Ramblers Bears Den on 4th Lake

Welcome to our cozy, four-season lakefront and mountain retreat with private access to Fourth Lake. Unwind by the fireplaces, soak up the sun on the dock, take a refreshing swim in the sandy bottom lake, or explore by boat. Whether you're here for lake or mountain enjoyment or simply relaxing, you'll find plenty to enjoy nearby in charming Inlet (just 4 miles away) or Old Forge (a 20-minute drive)

Top guest favorite
Cottage in Old Forge
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Cozy Lakefront Cottage | Dock | Kayaks | Fire pit

Lake + mountain views just 100 ft from the water with dock, fire pit, kayaks & spa-inspired ensuite. Escape to our Lakefront Boathouse, a cozy 3BR Adirondack retreat with vaulted ceilings, wagon-wheel chandelier & sliding doors framing the views. Cook in the chef’s ZLINE kitchen or relax in the spa ensuite. Turn-key with Roku TVs, linens, firewood & more — the perfect lakefront getaway.

Popular amenities for Eagle Bay vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Herkimer County
  5. Eagle Bay